Reviewed by: Pastime Lost: The Humble, Original, and Now Completely Forgotten Game of English Baseball by David Block Jason Cannon David Block. Pastime Lost: The Humble, Original, and Now Completely Forgotten Game of English Baseball. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2019. 320 pp. Cloth, $29.95. On November 14, 1748, Mary Lepel, known as Lady Hervey after her marriage to an English aristocrat, wrote a letter to her friend, the Reverend Edmund Morris, while visiting Frederick, Prince of Wales, and his family at their London home. She noted that "'the Prince's family is an example of innocent and cheerful amusements,'" and, on this particular winter day, the family "divert themselves at base-ball, a play all who are, or have been, schoolboys are well acquainted with" (16). Frederick's oldest son, ten-year-old George, joined his family to play baseball inside a "large room" of Leicester House (16). Twelve years later, following the deaths of his father and grandfather, the youngster became King George III, the nemesis of colonists in the New World seeking their independence from England. The story about George, player of English baseball, "mainly a country game, played casually in the towns and villages of the rural counties surrounding London," is just one of the remarkable discoveries detailed by historian David Block in his enlightening and engaging new book, Pastime Lost: The Humble, Original, and Now Completely Forgotten Game of English Baseball (xix). Block takes readers on a journey into the "curiously shrouded history" of English baseball (xx). He aims to "acquaint you with this long neglected original member of the baseball family," and Block hits the mark with aplomb (xxii). Initially, he theorized that "the eighteenth-century name baseball gradually gave way in England to the name rounders in the early nineteenth century;" however, his latest research has left him with "no doubt in [his] mind that English baseball and rounders were distinct games" (xx). The value of Pastime Lost goes beyond Block's excellent telling of the history of English baseball. Simultaneously, it provides an inside look at how a [End Page 258] historian goes about the craft of research. Block notes that, "For years my continuing research efforts had been turning up scads of new data, and I knew that I needed to devise a way to make those findings accessible to others" (xi). How to present them? Block considered several possibilities before landing on a "chronological history of English baseball" (xiii). However, he wisely incorporates aspects of his other ideas, particularly the lively descriptions of his "voyage of discovery," that creates a crackling analytical narrative that is both rigorous and accessible (xii). As a result, in addition to his search through newly digitized archival resources, readers join Block on his travels throughout England as he follows clues that lead him to unsuspecting places that yield surprising results. Block examines a variety of primary sources, including, amongst other items, letters, newspapers, children's literature, and a diary to determine that, indeed, "a game called baseball existed in England in the middle of the eighteenth century" (3). However, he confesses that the starting point for the sport is a little muddy. "The diversity of these references suggests to me that English baseball at the midpoint of the eighteenth century had not just freshly arrived," he notes (3). Block points out that he assumed the game developed over a period of time, but he allows that it is possible that "baseball was the inspired invention of some unknown genius" (3). Block's transparency regarding English baseball's starting point provides the reader access to his research process and demonstrates the unique challenge of hunting for puzzles pieces in order to piece together a historical mystery. Block's embedding of his search for clues within the chronological development of English baseball results in a stunningly informative and entertaining work. In a chapter titled "Two Weeks, Two Discoveries," he tells the story of visiting England in 2007 and learning about the existence of an eighteenth-century diary with a reference to baseball. Tricia St. John Barry, a resident in the county of Surrey, saw a news segment on Block's research trip and contacted BBC South...