Communal urban parks originating from the 19th and early 20th centuries are key elements of the European heritage and provide numerous ecosystem services. Here, we examine five public parks in Berlin, Germany, to evaluate whether their historical plantings have left ecological footprints. In a brief presentation, we explore why and when these parks came into being. The park design and development, original plant assortment and plant use patterns within the parks revealed continuities and discontinuities over time that influenced the vegetation, particularly woody species. In four of five parks only a few historical patterns and materials were preserved, and the original species diversity decreased significantly over the centuries. Finally, we discuss the potential spread of exotic ornamentals from the parks to their surroundings and the ecological impacts of horticultural history within the urban matrix.