Improving crop yield is essential to meet increasing global food demands. Boosting crop yield requires the coordination of carbon acquisition by leaves and carbon utilization by roots and seeds. Simple modelling approaches may be used to explain how this coordination is achieved within plant growth. Here, the limits to allocation strategies and the influence of maintenance costs are explored by analysing the sensitivity of a simple root–shoot carbon allocation model for vegetative and reproductive growth. The model is formulated based on fundamental constraints on plant growth and therefore can be applied to all plants. This general but quantitative approach shows that the relative costs of root and leaf respiration alter the relationship between carbon allocation and final plant size, enabling a range of allocation strategies to produce a similar total amount of plant material during vegetative growth. This plasticity is enhanced by increasing assimilation rate within the model. Results show that high leaf allocation during vegetative growth promotes early reproduction with respect to yield. Having higher respiration in leaves than roots delays the optimal age to reproduce for plants with high leaf allocation during vegetative growth and increases the restrictions on flowering time for plants with high root allocation during vegetative growth. It is shown that, when leaf respiration is higher than root respiration, reallocating carbon towards the roots can increase the total amount of plant material. This analysis indicates that crop improvement strategies should consider the effects of maintenance costs on growth, a previously under-appreciated mechanism for yield enhancement.