Numerous techniques are currently available for measurement of plant water status in field environments, including pressure chambers and indices based upon infrared-determined canopy temperatures. The Campbell-Brewster (J-14) leaf press has been promoted as a compact alternative to the pressure chamber for plant water potential determination. In-depth comparisons of the J-14 ( Ψ J) with the pressure chamber ( Ψ x) or with canopy temperatures ( T c) and crop water stress index ( CWSI) have been limited, and an evaluation of the technique in a humid environment was needed. All three J-14 end points [exudation from cut ( Ψ Jc) or uncut leaf edges ( Ψ Ju) or darkening of interveinal areas ( Ψ Jd)] were highly correlated among themselves for the four species studied. Correlations of J-14 end points with other stress indicators from unstable diurnal periods were poor. None of the water status indicators correlated well with leaf diffusive resistance. Our data showed a species-related reliability of the J-14. The J-14 produced r 2 values above 0.7 for soybean [ Glycine max. (L.) Merr.] for all but comparisons with CWSI or T c minus air temperature (Δ T), and for corn ( Zea mays L.) for Ψ x only. The J-14 did not perform well for tomato ( Lypersicum esculentum Mill.) or rapeseed ( Brassica napus L.), and is probably best regarded only as a relative indication of plant water status in the absence of calibration with other techniques. Failure of Ψ x or J-14 to correlate well with CWSI underscores difficulty with CWSI measurement under humid conditions.
Read full abstract