Reviewed by: La Femme Qui Lisait Des Romans Anglais by Sylvia Tabet Eilene Hoft-March Tabet, Sylvia. La femme qui lisait des romans anglais. Lattès, 2019. ISBN 978-2-7096-6058-7. Pp. 300. Jane Austen's title, Sense and Sensibility, names the dilemma of Tabet's protagonist, Juliet. Like Austen's Elinor, Juliet struggles with the question of marriage and whether her choice of partner should be determined by reason or emotion. Unlike all of Austen's heroines, Juliet is already twenty-five years into a happy, stable marriage with many of the accoutrements of success: children on the cusp of independence, a thriving and nourishing academic career, and a sensitive and solicitous partner. Her second-guessing about her life choices begins when she attends a professional conference in Rio that brings her in contact with a photojournalist, Jeremy. In this exotic Brazilian setting far from the national despondency and anxieties of post-Bataclan France, she finds Jeremy irresistible. Consequently, she fully contributes to the dalliance that lasts the duration of the conference. Once back in Paris, Juliet assumes that the amorous arrangement can continue as it began, without having to decide between the reasonable choice, François, and the romantic choice, Jeremy. (There are hints that having them both would give some kind of liberatory parity with men.) Jeremy, however, presses for exclusivity, promising not only exhilarating passion but constant adventure, this last confirmed by his new job assignment to Lebanon, where he wants Juliet to follow him. She hedges, seeking guidance in therapy and in literature, especially that of the novelists of English tradition (Austen, the Brontës, Hardy, Woolf, etc.). The book's a-chronological flashbacks and interior monologue reveal the various considerations poured into Juliet's agonized decision-making: her revisions of key memories, her methodical comparison of the two men and the lives associated with them, and the maternal "advice" she extrapolates from the notebook of literary quotes her mother kept. (Both Juliet's parents died in her youth, leaving her to make her own way as an adult.) Anxiety, perimenopause, grief, and the negative Zeitgeist around her contribute to this hardcore case of dithering. At times, readers need to keep a tight rein on the novel's chronology to be able to follow its seemingly endless tergiversations. This reader also found the insertion of extensive plot summaries of the beloved British authors something between pedantic and disruptive. On balance, later chapters pick up speed and emotional resonance. Possibly the most important aspect of this novel is its reminder that the life decisions of older adults are no less complicated than those of the young, compounded as they tend to be with histories, commitments, and dwindling opportunities. What would Jane Austen have had to say? [End Page 252] Eilene Hoft-March Lawrence University (WI) Copyright © 2020 American Association of Teachers of French
Read full abstract