The development of hydrophobic poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) hydrogels, which are typically hydrophilic, could significantly enhance their application as artificial extracellular matrices. In this study, we designed PEG hydrogels with enhanced hydrophobicity through gel-gel phase separation (GGPS), a phenomenon that uniquely enhances hydrophobicity under ambient conditions, and we elucidated the pivotal role of elasticity in this process. We hypothesized that increased elasticity would amplify GGPS, thereby improving the hydrophobicity and cell adhesion on PEG hydrogel surfaces, despite their inherent hydrophilicity. To test this hypothesis, we engineered dilute oligo-PEG gels via a two-step process, creating polymer networks from tetra-PEG clusters with multiple reaction points. These oligo-PEG gels exhibited significantly higher elasticity, turbidity, and shrinkage upon water immersion compared to dilute PEG gels. Detailed characterization through confocal laser scanning microscopy, rheological measurements, and cell adhesion assays revealed distinct biphasic structures, increased hydrophobicity, and enhanced cell attachability in the dilute oligo-PEG gels. Our findings confirm that elasticity is crucial for effective GGPS, providing a novel method for tailoring hydrogel properties without chemical modification. This research introduces a new paradigm for designing biomaterials with improved cell-scaffolding capabilities, offering significant potential for tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.