The thermodynamic comparison of small mixed-refrigerant J-T (MRJT) and gas expansion (Kapitza cycle) LN2 generators are conducted by the exergy method in this paper. Both of two types are employed for low pressure N2 liquefaction and air separation (< 9.0 bar). Pure N2, PSA units or cryogenic air separation columns are used for LN2 production. The MRJT type is driven by single-stage compressors. It is indicated that the efficiency of MRJT type is higher than Kapitza type. With pure N2 at 8.0 bar, the figures of merit (FOM) of MRJT and Kapitza types are 26.86% and 12.79%, respectively. With mini air separation columns, the FOM of MRJT and Kapitza types are 21.42% and 11.34%, respectively. The large exergy losses in the compressor unit and non-isentropic expansion are the main reasons of the inferior efficiency of the Kapitza type. In addition, the Kapitza type requires larger total compressor displacement than the MRJT type. The MRJT type is recommended to be used in small LN2 generators.
Read full abstract