To the Editors: We read with interest the recent case report by Oberdorfer et al1 published in the June edition of the journal, entitled “Human immunodeficiency virus-infected boy with Stevens-Johnson syndrome caused by nevirapine.” However, we believe that certain aspects of the report require further clarification for readers. Following an initial report by Warren et al2 in 1998, nevirapine-induced Stevens-Johnson syndrome (SJS) is now a well-recognized and -documented phenomenon. Although data in children are relatively limited, to our knowledge the first description of this particular complication in children was in a report by Pollard et al in 1998.3 That report summarized the early experience with nevirapine in adults, as well as children (pediatric investigational trials BI 892, ACTG 180, and ACTG 245), focusing primarily on adverse events. Interestingly, the authors described 2 cases of SJS in the pediatric population and estimated the overall incidence of this complication to be approximately 0.3%. Further pediatric cases of SJS related to nevirapine therapy have since been described.4,5 Oberdorfer et al's case adds to these previous reports. Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection alone is a significant risk factor for SJS and toxic epidermal necrolysis (TEN). In a recent, large European multicenter study (EuroSCAR study) on SJS/TEN, HIV-infected individuals had an estimated 12-fold increased risk of developing SJS/TEN compared with healthy controls.6 The mechanisms involved are not fully understood, although it has been postulated that immune dysregulation resulting from HIV infection plays a contributory role. Notably, the EuroSCAR study also reported a strong association between the administration of nevirapine and the development of SJS/TEN (relative risk: greater than 22), with the majority of cases occurring within the first 28 days of therapy. We would like to remind readers of the most commonly used terminology in relation to SJS/TEN originally proposed by Bastuji-Garin et al.7 In brief, SJS is defined as involvement of 2 or more mucosal areas and less than 10% of the body surface area. Epidermal necrolysis of greater than 30% of the body surface area is classified as TEN; cases with 10–30% involvement are referred to as overlap syndrome SJS/TEN. A patient with 60% body surface area involvement is therefore better described as TEN, although arguably the distinction between syndromes is somewhat arbitrary. Nevirapine is the only non-nucleoside reverse transcription inhibitor (NNRTI) recommended for use in children younger than 3 years, and is therefore an integral component of first-line NNRTI-based antiretroviral regimens in infants and young children. Liquid preparations of protease-inhibitors are generally unpalatable and thus used less commonly in this age group. Consequently, nevirapine remains invaluable in the treatment of HIV in children, despite the association with potentially serious side effects, which in addition to SJS/TEN include fulminant hepatitis and other variants of hypersensitivity reactions.8 Marc Tebruegge Nicole Ritz Tom Connell Nigel Curtis Department of Paediatrics The University of Melbourne Infectious Diseases Unit/ Department of Medicine Murdoch Children's Research Institute Royal Children's Hospital Melbourne Parkville, Victoria, Australia
Read full abstract