Aradus cinnamomeus, a pest of pines, shows a two-year life cycle with two widely distributed parapatric alternate-year populations and a narrow overlap zone in southern Finland. To explain the dynamics of this unique biogeographical pattern the intraspecific competition hypothesis was tested by field experiments involving crowding, transplantation and mixing the two reproductively isolated populations. The study was carried out simultaneously in both the evenand odd-year populations areas (defined according to the reproduction year of the locally dominant population) and in the narrow overlap zone. In addition to the mortality of both age-classes, the growth rate of larvae and the adult size were studied in the tests. The results suggest that younger larvae are better exploitation competitors than older larvae or adults. They can penetrate deeper into smaller crevices in the bark than the larger bugs, and thus exploit a wider range of resources. However, exploitation (within test bags) competition plays only a minor role in the regulation of the biogeographic pattern of the pine bark bug. The presence of the natural background population in the test trees (mostly outside the test bags) increased the mortality of the transplantated bugs of the other age-class to about the same extent as on a highly unfavourable site. Interference competition between the two age-classes, reinforced by the impact of exploitation competition and parasitism, can reasonably well explain the parapatry of the alternate-year populations, although direct evidence for interference is still lacking.
Read full abstract