The biota of the Indian subcontinent is a result of Gondwanan vicariance to some extent but largely through multiple faunal exchanges between neighbouring regions. However, in recent times, humans have influenced regional biotas through the human-mediated transport of many generalist species. In this study, we report populations of Lankascincus fallax, a skink species supposedly endemic to Sri Lanka, from the west coast of Kerala in India. We conducted morphological and genetic analysis to ascertain the identity of this species and to check whether the Indian population is monophyletic. We then performed a divergence dating analysis to test whether the presence of this population is a result of ancient dispersal into India or a result of more recent events. Additionally, we used species distribution modelling to test whether the Indian L. fallax is a result of natural dispersal into India during the past (mid-Pliocene to the last glacial maximum) when there were possible land bridges between India and Sri Lanka. We find that the Indian population is nested within the Sri Lankan L. fallax and that this population diverged from the Sri Lankan population very recently, during the Pleistocene. We do not find climatic suitability between the Indian west coast and Sri Lanka under current climatic conditions, or during the past suggesting no suitable dispersal corridors between India and Sri Lanka. Overall, we hypothesize that the Indian populations of L. fallax are likely a result of human-mediated transport into India and subsequent dispersal across the west coast of Kerala.