The US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration established a buffer zone around marine mammals to prevent harassment. The buffer zone varies by species listing status and by geographic area. However, it is unknown the extent to which vessels comply with these buffer zones. We selected harbor seals ( Phoca vitulina L., 1758) as a case study to describe compliance with the buffer zone. We conducted land-based observations from Yellow Island, Washington State, in a geographic area where the buffer zone is 91 m (100 yards), to estimate vessel distance from hauled-out seals and to evaluate seal response. We recorded 85.7% of kayaks, 57.1% of stopped powerboats, and 4.6% of passing powerboats violating the buffer zone. Seals were disturbed by kayaks and stopped powerboats at distances >91 m from the haul-out sites but not by moving powerboats ≤91 m from the sites. Hence, compliance of the buffer zone varied with vessel type and vessel activity. We suggest that a larger buffer zone for vessels lingering around the haul-out sites and enforcement of the buffer zone will minimize seal disturbance.