The mechanical response and fracture behavior of two architected 3D-printed hardened cement paste (hcp) elements, ‘lamellar’ and ‘Bouligand’, were investigated under uniaxial compression. A lab-based X-ray microscope was used to characterize the post-fracture crack pattern. The mechanical properties and crack patterns were analyzed and compared to cast hcp. The role of materials architecture and 3D-printing-induced weak interfaces on the mechanical properties and fracture behavior are discussed. The pore architecture that inadvertently forms in the design of solid architected materials dictated the overall mechanical response and fracture behaviors in both 3D-printed architected materials. While no specific crack pattern or microcracking was observed in the cast element, lamellar architecture demonstrated a crack pattern following weak vertical interfaces. Bouligand architectures, on the other hand, exhibited a helical crack pattern with distributed interfacial microcracking aligned with the helical orientation of filaments. As a result, the bouligand architected elements showed a significant 40% increase in work-of-failure compared to cast counterparts. The enhanced energy absorption was obtained without sacrificing the strength and was attributed to higher fractured surface and microcracking, both of which follow the weak helical interfaces.