According to "the new global tectonics," the Caribbean Sea and the marginal lands surrounding it comprise one "lithosphere plate." Its eastern margin includes the Barbados Ridge, Lesser Antilles arc, and Aves Ridge; the western margin is composed of Central America and the Middle America Trench. These two margins are interpreted as subduction zones by "new global tectonics" advocates. The northern and southern margins are the alleged North Caribbean and South Caribbean faults, respectively. According to recent JOIDES drilling data, the Caribbean "plate" may be underlain by Late Cretaceous (75-85 m.y.) basaltic crust, and therefore is younger than both the Americas plate on the north, east, and south and the Cocos plate on the west. From this, some workers have inferred that the Caribbean formed by sea-floor spreading which separated North and South America. However, there is no spreading center in the Caribbean. Moreover, geologic and seismic data prove that the proposed North Caribbean and South Caribbean faults do not exist. La Désirade is a Jurassic or older island east of the Lesser Antilles. Barbados Ridge is an aseismic, pre-Late Jurassic salient of South America (that is, part of the so-called Americas plate) that parallels and lies just east of the alleged Lesser Antilles subduction zone. The stratigraphic units of Barbados are correlat-able with those of northern South America. Structural trends on Barbados strike east-northeast, are Late Cretaceous-early Eocene, and parallel those of South America. These facts show that the position of Barbados with respect to that of South America has not changed for more than 140 m.y. Yet "the new global tectonics" require that La Desirade and the Barbados Ridge must have been subducted more than 70 m.y. ago. On the basis of the facts presented here, the so-called Caribbean plate and the regions surrounding it have held the same positions relative to one another since pre-Jurassic (probably pre-Paleozoic) time. "The new global tectonics," therefore, are not applicable in the Caribbean area.
Read full abstract