SummaryThe effect of replacing proportions of local farmer bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) mixtures with varieties resistant to angular leaf spot on grain yield was evaluated under local disease pressure in the Kivu region of Zaire. Local bean mixtures in on‐station and in multi‐locational trials containing respectively 25%, or 50% of Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical (CIAT) breeding lines BAT76, or A285, resistant to angular leaf spot yielded significantly more than the local mixture alone. Yields exceeded expected values in three seasons of on‐station testing and in two seasons of multi‐locational trials. Yield over the expected was found to be a property of new mixtures not protected with fungicide and were attributed to disease control. Relative to expected yields non‐protected farmer mixture components performed 17% and 16% better than in protected plots and A285 components yielded 24% and 16% better at respectively 25% and 50% A285 supplementation levels. A285 increased yields of the local mixture components and benefitted from the local mixture when not protected by fungicide. Yield increases in multi‐locational trials were largely attributed to the higher yield potential of the resistant variety A285, although angular leaf spot severity was significantly reduced. It was concluded that high yielding, resistant varieties were able to increase bean yield in the region, but probably at a substantial cost in genetic diversity in farmer bean mixtures. That said, a partial replacement strategy is preferable to strategies which encourage complete replacement of local germplasm with one or few high yielding varieties.
Read full abstract