The mechanisms of concerted and stepwise dihydrogen transfer reactions have been studied for a wide variety of hydrogen donors and acceptors using the MNDO and AM1 semiempirical SCF-MO methods. The calculated barriers for concerted [1,2]dihydrogen transfer from cis-di-imide were sensitive to the strain and geometry of the π acceptor but less so to polar substituents, and with the exception of sterically hindered alkenes and systems with silicon and phosphorus double bonds, the energy differences between this route and an alternative stepwise process were surprisingly constant. The AM1 method tends to favour a concerted and essentially synchronous transfer of hydrogen whereas MNDO tends to favour a stepwise mechanism, with signficiant differences also for sterically hindered systems, for the barriers to the concerted hydrogen transfer, and in the disproportionation energies of the intermediate radical pairs involved in the stepwise mechanistic pathway. Highly strained alkene acceptors induce asymmetry in the concerted transfer, and such alkenes also form hydrogen bonded complexes with diimide. Transition state frontier orbitals are shown to give a simple interpretation of selectivity and reactivity, particularly for strained systems and allene it acceptors. The entropy of activation is suggested to be important in rationalising cis/trans alkene selectivity. Bis-α(oxy-anion) substituents on the donor significantly decrease the activation barriers, but induce a stepwise transfer of hydride anion rather than a concerted dihydrogen transfer. Hydrogen kinetic isotope effects show significantly different behaviour for the concerted and stepwise transfer. The concerted [1,4] reduction of butadiene proceeds antarafacially with a much higher barrier than [1,2] reduction. Dimethyl transfer from diazomethane proceeds with double inversion rather than with double retention of configuration at the methyl groups.
Read full abstract