Microorganisms are the most diverse and abundant life on earth. They are responsible for recycling the elements of our planet and keeping our world habitable. Despite their importance, genome‐based analyses estimate that 90% of the microorganisms on our planet have not been cultured for laboratory investigations. The crustal biosphere of the Juan de Fuca Ridge Flank is a warm, subsurface environment, which has been shown to contain many uncultured organisms. Some of these uncultured groups harbor functional genes of evolutionary and biogeochemical significance, suggesting that further study will increase our knowledge of microbial survival on early Earth, as well as in this hydrothermal, nutrient‐limited crustal environment. In previous work the recovery of mono‐ and bifunctional carbon monoxide dehydrogenase genes suggested that carboxydotrophy may be a viable lifestyle in this environment. In May of 2019, the RV Atlantis traveled to the Juan de Fuca Ridge Flank to test this hypothesis. Equipped with custom fluid samplers the ROV Jason‐II was used to collect pristine crustal fluids from subsurface borehole observatories for chemical analyses and microbial culturing efforts. Our main objective was to measure potential carbon substrates, including carbon monoxide and methane, and to cultivate unique organisms from this environment to better understand carbon‐related metabolisms in this important but understudied aquifer.