Isotopic Hydrograph Separation Research Articles

Comparison of two isotopic hydrograph separation methods in the Hydrological Open Air Laboratory, Austria

AbstractExploring the contributions of new and old water to runoff during precipitation events in agricultural catchments is essential for understanding runoff generation, solute transport, and soil erosion. The aim of this study was to investigate the variability in the isotopic composition of precipitation and runoff in the 66 ha agricultural catchment in Austria, in the Hydrological Open Air Laboratory (HOAL), in order to compare two isotope hydrograph separation methods. The classical two‐component (IHS) and the ensemble hydrograph separation (EHS) were applied to multiple large events in May–October of 2013–2018 using δ18O and δ2H. The peak flow new water contributions obtained by IHS were compared with the average new water fraction from EHS. The average new water fraction calculated with EHS based on regular weekly sampling was close to zero, which can be explained by the large diffuse groundwater discharge into the stream between the events. When only investigating events with high temporal resolution sampling, the results suggest that EHS provided average new water fractions during peak flows (0.46 ± 0.04 for δ18O, 0.47 ± 0.03 for δ2H) that were close to the averages obtained by IHS (0.47 for δ18O, 0.50 for δ2H). New water fractions tended to be higher for larger rainfall intensities. High peak flow new water fractions could be explained by the agricultural land use and soils with low permeability promoting overland flow generation and by some of the tile drainage systems contributing to the delivery of water. In conclusion, a weekly sampling frequency was not sufficient in the HOAL but instead high‐resolution sampling during events was necessary to estimate the average new water contributions during events. While EHS may be a more robust approach compared to IHS, as it relaxes some of the assumptions of IHS, IHS can provide information on the variability of new water contributions of individual events.

Isotope Hydrograph Separation Reveals Rainfall on the Glaciers Will Enhance Ice Meltwater Discharge to the Himalayan Rivers

AbstractThe Indian Summer Monsoon (ISM) and meltwater from the Himalayan are the two most important sources of water in the Indian subcontinent. However, the impact of ISM on Himalayan glaciers and subsequent stream hydrology remains largely unknown. To provide new insight into the impact of rainfall on glacial hydrology, here we present hydro‐meteorological and time‐series observations of meltwater stable water isotope compositions from the snout of the Chorabari glacier in the Upper Ganga Basin, Central Himalayas across the ablation season corresponding to 2019. We observe that rainfall events (>2 mm d−1) on the glacier enhance discharge driven by ice meltwater in River Mandakini. Energy balance calculations reveal that one of the drivers behind enhanced ice meltwater contribution could be rain‐induced melting of the glacier where rainfall on the ice surface melts the glacier producing up to 13% of the total discharge at the glacier snout. Further, rainfall on glacier surface have other control on glacial processes—for example, snow metamorphism, ice flow dynamics such as short‐term acceleration in ice speed flow, and reorganization of the englacial and subglacial drainage network—that are poorly studied and needs further investigation. We conclude rainfall events on the glacier have a complex control on mountain hydrology. This study, therefore, provides an interpretative framework that calls for additional assessments of the direct and indirect impact of rainfall in glacial hydrology.

How and when glacial runoff is important: Tracing dynamics of meltwater and rainfall contribution to river runoff from headwaters to lowland in the Caucasus Mountains

As glacier degradation is intensifying worldwide, understanding how and when glacial runoff is important becomes imperative for economic planning and societal adaptation in response to climate change. This research highlights a probable emergence of new low-flow periods, ranging from one to several weeks, with an anticipated 50–90 % reduction in runoff even in major rivers originating in glacierized mountains by the mid to late 21th century. While the predicted decline in annual and monthly runoff appears moderate for most glaciated regions globally, the emergence of new deglaciation-induced summer low flow periods could create critical “bottle necks” constraining effective water resources management.In this study, a nested catchment approach (7.6–2259 km2) in conjunction with an isotopic tracer method (D, 18O), was employed to quantify the seasonal dynamics of snow and glacial meltwater and rainfall contribution to runoff across various scales of river catchments for the underreported Caucasus Mountains. Although the contribution of meltwater was predictably dominant in the headwaters (75–100 %), it still constituted a substantial 50–60 % of river runoff in the lower reaches most of the time from June to September. While the relative capacity for rainwater storage was found to significantly increase with watershed scale, during weeks devoid of noteworthy rainfall, the runoff in river basins with a mere 7 % glaciation basically entirely consists of what is formed in the glacierized headwaters. The glacial runoff was prevalent in the melt component from late July/early August to mid-September: not less than 30–60 % to the total runoff in the headwaters and 30–40 % in the lower reaches.An approach is proposed to account for the spatial heterogeneity of stable water isotopic content within snow cover and glacier ice. Sources of uncertainties and soundness of assumptions typically used for isotopic hydrograph separation are discussed with particular consideration given to the study objectives.

Snow sampling strategy can bias estimation of meltwater fractions in isotope hydrograph separation

The Isotope based Hydrograph Separation (IHS) has been instrumental in understanding the partitioning of streamflow sources and processes. However, uncertainties persist in the accuracy of IHS estimations and the appropriate definition and sampling of endmembers. To address these uncertainties, we used field data of snowpack, snowfall, and snow meltwater isotopes (δ18O) from Pallas, Northern Finland to estimate the total meltwater contribution during the snowmelt period. We investigated the biases resulting from the application of different sampling strategies for event water endmember. The total meltwater contribution to streamflow was 59.6 % (±2% uncertainty) using the time-variant rolling runoff-corrected melt flux-weighted meltwater 18O isotope value. However, replacing it with either snowfall or winter snowpack 18O isotope weighted average values underestimated the meltwater contribution by 17.8 % or 22.6 %, respectively. Conversely, using time-variant instantaneous meltwater 18O isotope values overestimated the meltwater contribution by only 1.5 %. These discrepancies highlight the importance of choosing the appropriate endmember isotopes in IHS. The large differences in meltwater contribution for a 2-week peak discharge period based on different endmembers can lead to different interpretations of hydrological, ecohydrological, and biogeochemical processes. Thus, to better understand streamflow generation processes, we suggest using rolling runoff-corrected meltwater 18O or 2H isotope values in the IHS. In the absence of meltwater samples, the 18O or 2H isotope values of snowpack samples during the peak melt season may provide reasonable estimates of the meltwater contribution, with some minor underestimations. Our study highlights the importance of appropriate event meltwater endmember selection and sampling methodology for the IHS.

Using stable water isotopes to evaluate water flow and nonpoint source pollutant contributions in three southern Ontario agricultural headwater streams

AbstractImproved understanding of catchment‐scale hydrology and nutrient transport in agricultural catchments is needed. Here, the annual young water fraction is determined for three southern Ontario headwater catchments using the stable water isotope δ18O; the dominant event contributions for three streams were also determined using a two‐component isotopic hydrograph separation. On an annual average, Nissouri Creek (loamy soils, high tile drainage) sees the lowest amount of event water, followed by Big Creek (clay soils, high tile drainage) and then North Creek (clay soils, low tile drainage). Event hydrograph separations show Nissouri Creek has significantly higher median amounts of pre‐event water than Big and North Creek during events. These results in indicate soil type may be more influential than tile drainage presence with respect to the contribution of event contributions to total stream flow; specifically, higher contributions of event water occurred in the two clay soil catchments, despite differing tile presence. Antecedent moisture and event characteristics did not uniformly explain the observed pre‐event water contributions for events across all sites, with pre‐event contributions only weakly and positively correlated with discharge at event commencement and negatively with isotopic variability in stream water. The total contribution of pre‐event water during events was significantly correlated with mean event turbidity and the flow‐weighted mean concentrations of dissolved organic carbon, total phosphorus and total dissolved phosphorus, but not total nitrogen or nitrate. The correlations we observed between pre‐event water and water chemistry were stronger than between event size and water chemistry, suggesting isotopic information adds insight that simple hydrometrics are unable to provide. Our results show that event water is responsible for phosphorus loss at the watershed scale, indicating actions targeting fast pathways or targeting pools of phosphorus available to those fast pathways can aid in reducing phosphorus transported by event water.

Rapid mobilization of old water during urban stormflow

AbstractUrban landscapes do not easily fit into common conceptual models of streamflow generation because extensive impervious surfaces, artificial drainage via sewers, stormwater control measures, and the removal of vegetation substantially modify the pathways rainfall and meltwater take to streams. Hydrologic responses are well characterized for urban streams, however, the relative sources and flow pathways of water within urban landscapes are relatively understudied compared with undisturbed areas. Different water sources (e.g. groundwater, or ‘old’ water, rainfall, or ‘new’ water) can have distinct chemical characteristics whose mixing determines the quality of streamwater. In this study, we investigated the relative contribution of different sources of water (pre‐event water/groundwater, rainfall, wastewater, and tap water) to urban stormflow. Water samples were collected from three highly urban streams (65%–89% impervious cover) during 11 storm events and analysed for stable isotopes of oxygen and hydrogen in water (δ18O and δ2H). Precipitation samples were collected from a nearby precipitation collector to characterize the isotopic signature of new water inputs. Isotopic hydrograph separation (IHS) was used to estimate the relative proportion of new and old water in each event. The IHS results indicated that 25%–63% (δ18O) of the storm hydrograph was old water. For 9 of the 11 storms, the peak in old water contribution coincided with peak flow. These results are similar to findings from IHS studies in undisturbed catchments which suggests that under certain conditions (i.e. low intensity, long duration rainfall) the contribution of old water to stormflow in urban catchments is of a similar magnitude to undisturbed catchments. The use of tracer data is important for further exploring the conceptual model of streamflow generation that suggests that new water dominates stormflow in flashy and heavily urbanized catchments, and can be useful for characterizing the role of greenspaces and storm characteristics on water partitioning.

Applicability of Difference in Oxygen-18 and Deuterium of Water Sources and Isotopic Hydrograph Separation in a Bamboo Catchment during Different Rainfall Types

Typhoon storm and plum rain are two typical rainfall types in the lower regions of the Yangtze River Basin, which frequently cause flood disasters in China. New information in stable water isotopes offers the opportunity to advance understanding of runoff mechanisms and water source dynamics in response to these two typical rainfall types. We intensively monitored two representative rainfall events in a small bamboo forestry watershed in 2016. Results showed that precipitation isotopic variations during the event were generally larger than those of other monitored compartments (including throughfall, surface overland water, groundwater and river water) and also larger for the plum rain than for the typhoon event (δ18O varied in 5.2‰ and 3.7‰, respectively). Importantly, the differences of isotopic temporal variation between rainfall and throughfall showed significant impacts on the two-component hydrograph separation for both rainfall types (e.g., if not considered, the pre-event water fractions were 26.6% and 15.3% higher for the typhoon and plum rain events, respectively). Furthermore, we evaluated the role of soil water on the three-component isotopic hydrograph separation model; results revealed that soil water accounted for 10.9% and 28.3% of the total discharge in typhoon and plum rain events, respectively. This underpins the important role of soil water dynamics during the rainy season in this humid region.

Global Isotopic Hydrograph Separation Research History and Trends: A Text Mining and Bibliometric Analysis Study

Scientific research into isotope hydrograph separation (IHS) has rapidly increased in recent years. However, there is a lack of systematic and quantitative research to explore how this field has evolved over time. In this study, the methods of text mining and bibliometric analysis were combined to address this shortcoming. The results showed that there were clear periodical characteristics in IHS studies between 1986 and 2019. High-frequency words, e.g., catchment, stable isotope, runoff, groundwater, precipitation, runoff generation, and soil, were the basic topics in IHS studies. Forest and glacier/snow were the main landscapes in this research field. ‘Variation’, ‘spatial’, and ‘uncertainty’ are hot issues for future research. Today, studies involving the geographical source, flow path, and transit/residence time of streamflow components have enhanced our understanding of the hydrological processes by using hydrometeorological measurements, water chemistry, and stable isotope approaches. In the future, new methods, such as path analysis and ensemble hydrograph separation, should be verified and used in more regions, especially in remote and mountainous areas. Additionally, the understanding of the role of surface water in streamflow components remains limited and should be deeply studied in the future.

Application of Machine Learning Models to Predict Maximum Event Water Fractions in Streamflow

Estimating the maximum event water fraction, at which the event water contribution to streamflow reaches its peak value during a precipitation event, gives insight into runoff generation mechanisms and hydrological response characteristics of a catchment. Stable isotopes of water are ideal tracers for accurate estimation of maximum event water fractions using isotopic hydrograph separation techniques. However, sampling and measuring of stable isotopes of water is laborious, cost intensive, and often not conceivable under difficult spatiotemporal conditions. Therefore, there is a need for a proper predictive model to predict maximum event water fractions even at times when no direct sampling and measurements of stable isotopes of water are available. The behavior of maximum event water fraction at the event scale is highly dynamic and its relationships with the catchment drivers are complex and non-linear. In last two decades, machine learning algorithms have become increasingly popular in the various branches of hydrology due to their ability to represent complex and non-linear systems without any a priori assumption about the structure of the data and knowledge about the underlying physical processes. Despite advantages of machine learning, its potential in the field of isotope hydrology has rarely been investigated. Present study investigates the applicability of Artificial Neural Network (ANN) and Support Vector Machine (SVM) algorithms to predict maximum event water fractions in streamflow using precipitation, soil moisture, and air temperature as a set of explanatory input features that are more straightforward and less expensive to measure compared to stable isotopes of water, in the Schwingbach Environmental Observatory (SEO), Germany. The influence of hyperparameter configurations on the model performance and the comparison of prediction performance between optimized ANN and optimized SVM are further investigated in this study. The performances of the models are evaluated using mean absolute error (MAE), root mean squared error (RMSE), coefficient of determination (R2), and Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency (NSE). For the ANN, the results showed that an appropriate number of hidden nodes and a proper activation function enhanced the model performance, whereas changes of the learning rate did not have a major impact on the model performance. For the SVM, Polynomial kernel achieved the best performance, whereas Linear yielded the weakest performance among the kernel functions. The result showed that maximum event water fraction could be successfully predicted using only precipitation, soil moisture, and air temperature. The optimized ANN showed a satisfactory prediction performance with MAE of 10.27%, RMSE of 12.91%, R2 of 0.70, and NSE of 0.63. The optimized SVM was superior to that of ANN with MAE of 7.89%, RMSE of 9.43%, R2 of 0.83, and NSE of 0.78. SVM could better capture the dynamics of maximum event water fractions across the events and the predictions were generally closer to the corresponding observed values. ANN tended to underestimate the events with high maximum event water fractions and to overestimate the events with low maximum event water fractions. Machine learning can prove to be a promising approach to predict variables that are not always possible to be estimated due to the lack of routine measurements.

Examining sources and pathways of phosphorus transfer in a ditch-drained field.

Understanding the processes that mobilize and transport dissolved phosphorus (P) during storms is critical to managing P in flat landscapes with open ditch drainage and legacy soil P. In this study, we used routine baseflow monitoring and intensive storm sampling at a ditch-drained site on Maryland's Lower Eastern Shore (July 2017-September 2018) to assess whether concentration-discharge (C-Q) relationships and chemical and isotopic hydrograph separation could provide insight into the processes that mobilize and transport dissolved P in ditch drainage. Using a segmented regression model, we determined that long-term C-Q relationships for dissolved P differed above and below a discharge threshold of 6.4 L s-1 . Intensive storm sampling revealed that small storms (n=3) occurring at or below the discharge threshold generally exhibited complex hysteresis and dissolved P dilution patterns that were consistent with deeper(>122cm) groundwater inputs with low dissolved P concentrations (0.04mg L-1 ). In contrast, large storms occurring well above the discharge threshold (n=4) induced rising water tables and preferential flow pathways that most likely tapped dissolved P-enriched shallow(<20cm) soil waters (0.89mg L-1 ), producing consistent clockwise hysteresis and dissolved P flushing patterns. Notably, chemical and isotope hydrograph separation during two of the largest storms revealed significant event water fractions (59-68%) that strongly suggested a role for the rapid delivery of dissolved P via preferential flow pathways. Findings highlight the need to mitigate vertical P stratification as a means for reducing dissolved P flushing from ditch-drained landscapes with legacy P.

Stormflows Drive Stream Carbon Concentration, Speciation, and Dissolved Organic Matter Composition in Coastal Temperate Rainforest Watersheds

AbstractStream water carbon concentrations can be highly dynamic on the time scales of both individual storm events and seasonal hydroclimatic shifts. We collected stream water daily over a 6‐day storm from three headwater subcatchments of varying landcover (poor fen, forested wetland, and upland forest) and the catchment outlet to evaluate how precipitation events impact the concentration and speciation of carbon (organic vs. inorganic) as well as the composition of dissolved organic matter (DOM) exported laterally from coastal temperate rainforest catchments. Dissolved and particulate organic carbon concentrations increased during the storm at all sites, while dissolved inorganic carbon concentrations were diluted during peak flows. These results highlight the importance of quantifying all forms of lateral carbon export when evaluating the role of storms in catchment‐scale carbon cycling. Isotopic hydrograph separation using stream water δ18O showed that percent new water was significantly related to carbon concentration and form providing a clear link between stream water sources (i.e., recent event water) and soil carbon source areas that become connected to surface water during storms. Furthermore, ultrahigh‐resolution mass spectrometry showed that stream water DOM exported from the upland forest contained the greatest molecular diversity of the three landscape types and had the largest changes in composition over the storm suggesting that the wetland‐dominated subcatchments were less compositionally diverse with regard to soil DOM pools active during the storm. Overall, this study provides insight into hydro‐biogeochemical drivers that control lateral carbon export from forested catchments in a region where an increasing fraction of precipitation is falling as rain.

High-Resolution, In Situ Monitoring of Stable Isotopes of Water Revealed Insight into Hydrological Response Behavior

High temporal resolution (20-min intervals) measurements of stable isotopes from groundwater, stream water and precipitation were investigated to understand the hydrological response behavior and control of precipitation and antecedent wetness conditions on runoff generation. Data of 20 precipitation events were collected by a self-sufficient mobile system for in situ measurements over four months in the Schwingbach Environmental Observatory (SEO, temperate climate), Germany. Isotopic hydrograph separation indicated that more than 79% of the runoff consisted of pre-event water. Short response times of maximum event water fractions in stream water and groundwater revealed that shallow subsurface flow pathways rapidly delivered water to the stream. Macropore and soil pipe networks along relatively flat areas in stream banks were likely relevant pathways for the rapid transmission of water. Event water contribution increased with increasing precipitation amount. Pre-event water contribution was moderately affected by precipitation, whereas, the antecedent wetness conditions were not strong enough to influence pre-event water contribution. The response time was controlled by mean precipitation intensity. A two-phase system was identified, at which the response times of stream water and groundwater decreased after reaching a threshold of mean precipitation intensity of 0.5 mm h−1. Our results suggest that high temporal resolution measurements of stable isotopes of multiple water sources combined with hydrometrics improve the understanding of the hydrological response behavior and runoff generation mechanisms.

Characteristics of Water Isotopes and Water Source Identification During the Wet Season in Naqu River Basin, Qinghai–Tibet Plateau

Climate change is affecting the discharge of headstreams from mountainous areas on the Qinghai–Tibet Plateau. To constrain future changes in discharge, it is important to understand the present-day formation mechanism and components of runoff in the basin. Here we explore the sources of runoff and spatial variations in discharge through measurements of δ2H and δ18O in the Naqu River, at the source of the Nu River, on the Qinghai–Tibet plateau, during the month of August from 2016 to 2018. We established thirteen sampling sites on the main stream and tributaries, and collected 39 samples from the river. We examined all the water samples and analyzed them for isotopes. We find a significant spatial variation trend based on one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) (p &lt; 0.05) between Main stream-2 and tributaries. The local meteoric water-line (LMWL) can be described as: δ2H = 7.9δ18O + 6.29. Isotopic evaporative fractionation in water and mixing of different water sources are responsible for the spatial difference in isotopic values between Main stream-2 and tributaries. Based on isotopic hydrograph separation, the proportion of snowmelt in runoff components ranges from 15% to 47%, and the proportion of rainwater ranges from 3% to 35%. Thus, the main components of runoff in the Naqu River are snowmelt and groundwater.

Studying catchment storm response using event- and pre-event-water volumes as fractions of precipitation rather than discharge

Abstract. Catchment response to precipitation is often investigated using two-component isotope-based hydrograph separation, which quantifies the contribution of precipitation (i.e., event water Qe) or water from storage (i.e., pre-event water Qpe) to total discharge (Q) during storm events. In order to better understand streamflow-generating mechanisms, two-component hydrograph separation studies often seek to relate the event-water fraction Qe∕Q to storm characteristics or antecedent wetness conditions. However, these relationships may be obscured because the same factors that influence Qe also necessarily influence total discharge Q as well. Here we propose that the fractions of event water and pre-event water relative to total precipitation (Qe∕P and Qpe∕P), instead of total discharge, provide useful alternative tools for studying catchment storm responses. These two quantities separate the well-known runoff coefficient (Q∕P, i.e., the ratio between total discharge and precipitation volumes over the event timescale) into its contributions from event water and pre-event water. Whereas the runoff coefficient Q∕P quantifies how strongly precipitation inputs affect streamflow, the fractions Qe∕P and Qpe∕P track the sources of this streamflow response. We use high-frequency measurements of stable water isotopes for 24 storm events at a steep headwater catchment (Erlenbach, central Switzerland) to compare the storm-to-storm variations in Qe/Q,Qe/P and Qpe∕P. Our analysis explores how storm characteristics and antecedent wetness conditions affect the mobilization of event water and pre-event water at the catchment scale. Isotopic hydrograph separation shows that catchment outflow was typically dominated by pre-event water, although event water exceeded 50 % of discharge for several storms. No clear relationships were found linking either storm characteristics or antecedent wetness conditions with the volumes of event water or pre-event water (Qe, Qpe), or with event water as a fraction of discharge (Qe∕Q), beyond the unsurprising correlation of larger storms with greater Qe and greater total Q. By contrast, event water as a fraction of precipitation (Qe∕P) was strongly correlated with storm volume and intensity but not with antecedent wetness, implying that the volume of event water that is transmitted to streamflow increases more than proportionally with storm size under both wet and dry conditions. Conversely, pre-event water as a fraction of precipitation (Qpe∕P) was strongly correlated with all measures of antecedent wetness but not with storm characteristics, implying that wet conditions primarily facilitate the mobilization of old (pre-event) water, rather than the fast transmission of new (event) water to streamflow, even at a catchment where runoff coefficients can be large. Thus, expressing event- and pre-event-water volumes as fractions of precipitation rather than discharge was more insightful for investigating the Erlenbach catchment's hydrological behaviour. If Qe∕P and Qpe∕P exhibit similar relationships with storm characteristics and antecedent wetness conditions in other catchments, we suggest that these patterns may potentially be useful as diagnostic “fingerprints” of catchment storm response.

Isotopic hydrograph separation in two small mountain catchments during multiple events

Two-component isotopic hydrograph separation (IHS) was developed to determine the event- and pre-event components of a single storm event. Its application for several sucessive events requires repeated determination of isotopic signatures of end-members (precipitation, pre-event component) for each event. The existence of several possible alternative signatures results in differences in calculated contributions of event-/pre- event components. This article addresses the question of how big the differences could be in small mountain catchments with different methods for detemining the end member signatures. We analyzed data on isotopic composition of daily/event precipitation at different elevations in two catchments located in the highest part of the Carpathians in July 2014.The isotopic composition of streamflow sampled every 4-6 hours was analyzed as well. Elevational gradients of δ18O and δ2H in precipitation in the study period were -0.18 ‰ 100 m-1 and -1.1 ‰ 100 m-1, respectively. An elevation gradient in deuterium excess (0.29 ‰ 100 m-1) was also found. Precipitation on the windward side of the mountains was isotopically lighter than expected for a given rain gauge elevation. Five large rainfall-runoff events occurred in the study period in the meso-scale catchment of the Jalovecký creek (Western Tatra Mountains, area 22.2 km2) and in the headwater catchment of the Škaredý creek (High Tatra Mountains, area 1.4 km2). Isotopic hydrograph separation was conducted using eight options for the isotopic signatures of event and pre-event water. The isotopic signature of the event water (rainfall) was alternatively represented by data from high or low elevations. Pre-event water was represented either by the streamflow before the event or by the value taken from the statistics of the long-term data on isotopic composition of the stream. Both isotopes (18O and 2H) were used to calculate event water fractions during peak flows of individual events. Calculated peak flow event water fractions were below 0.2-0.3 for most events. However, the differences in calculated event water fractions for alternative isotopic composition of end-members were significant even if we did not take into account changes in isotopic composition during individual rainfalls. Coefficients of variation for event water fractions calculated for various options varied during individual events from 0.14 to 0.36. It is therefore perhaps better to use a range of possible values instead of a single accurate number to interpret the IHS results. Hydrograph separations based on 18O and 2H provided similar results.

Impacts of forest conversion and agriculture practices on water pathways in Southern Brazil

AbstractLand‐use/cover change (LUCC), and more specifically deforestation and multidecadal agriculture, is one of the various controlling factors of water fluxes at the hillslope or catchment scale. We investigated the impact of LUCC on water pathways and stream stormflow generation processes in a subtropical region in southern Brazil. We monitored, sampled and analysed stream water, pore water, subsurface water, and rainwater for dissolved silicon concentration (DSi) and 18O/16O (δ18O) signature to identify contributing sources to the streamflow under forest and under agriculture. Both forested and agricultural catchments were highly responsive to rainfall events in terms of discharge and shallow groundwater level. DSi versus δ18O scatter plots indicated that for both land‐use types, two run‐off components contributed to the stream discharge. The presence of a dense macropore network, combined with the presence of a compact and impeding B‐horizon, led to rapid subsurface flow in the forested catchment. In the agricultural catchment, the rapid response to rainfall was mostly due to surface run‐off. A 2‐component isotopic hydrograph separation indicated a larger contribution of rainfall water to run‐off during rainfall event in the agricultural catchments. We attributed this higher contribution to a decrease in topsoil hydraulic conductivity associated with agricultural practices. The chemical signature of the old water component in the forested catchment was very similar to that of the shallow groundwater and the pore soil water: It is therefore likely that the shallow groundwater was the main source of old water. This is not the case in the agricultural catchments where the old water component had a much higher DSi concentration than the shallow groundwater and the soil pore water. As the agricultural catchments were larger, this may to some extent simply be a scale effect. However, the higher water yields under agriculture and the high DSi concentration observed in the old water under agriculture suggest a significant contribution of deep groundwater to catchment run‐off under agriculture, suggesting that LUCC may have significant effects on weathering rates and patterns.

Quantitative evaluation of the rainfall influence on streamflow in an inland mountainous river basin within Central Asia

ABSTRACTStable isotopes of water have been widely used in understanding the hydrological functions of alpine inland catchments. This study identifies dominant runoff generation mechanisms based on isotopic data (δ18O and δ2H) of 487 rainwater and river-water samples from three tributaries in the Tarim River Basin in China for the period May–September 2013. The isotope hydrograph separation results provide a comprehensive overview of the rainfall influence on hydrological processes. Stream water and groundwater have varied responses to different intensities of rainfall events. Only a small proportion of rainfall is directly transported to the stream during such events. An inconsistent temporal trend of event water contribution is observed in the three catchments. The average fractional contributions of rainfall for the Tizinafu, Kumalak and Huangshuigou rivers are 10.3% (±1.1%), 9.7% (±2.9%) and 8.7% (±2.4%), respectively.

Spatial variability in the isotopic composition of rainfall in a small headwater catchment and its effect on hydrograph separation

Isotope hydrograph separation (IHS) is a valuable tool to study runoff generation processes. To perform an IHS, samples of baseflow (pre-event water) and streamflow are taken at the catchment outlet. For rainfall (event water) either a bulk sample is collected or it is sampled sequentially during the event. For small headwater catchment studies, event water samples are usually taken at only one sampling location in or near the catchment because the spatial variability in the isotopic composition of rainfall is assumed to be small. However, few studies have tested this assumption. In this study, we investigated the spatiotemporal variability in the isotopic composition of rainfall and its effects on IHS results using detailed measurements from a small pre-alpine headwater catchment in Switzerland. Rainfall was sampled sequentially at eight locations across the 4.3km2 Zwäckentobel catchment and stream water was collected in three subcatchments (0.15, 0.23, and 0.70km2) during ten events. The spatial variability in rainfall amount, average and maximum rainfall intensity and the isotopic composition of rainfall was different for each event. There was no significant relation between the isotopic composition of rainfall and total rainfall amount, rainfall intensity or elevation. For eight of the ten studied events the temporal variability in the isotopic composition of rainfall was larger than the spatial variability in the rainfall isotopic composition. The isotope hydrograph separation results, using only one rain sampler, varied considerably depending on which rain sampler was used to represent the isotopic composition of event water. The calculated minimum pre-event water contributions differed up to 60%. The differences were particularly large for events with a large spatial variability in the isotopic composition of rainfall and a small difference between the event and pre-event water isotopic composition. Our results demonstrate that even in small catchments the spatial variability in the rainfall isotopic composition can be significant and has to be considered for IHS studies. Using data from only one rain sampler can result in significant errors in the estimated pre-event water contributions to streamflow.

인공강우실험을 이용한 동위원소수문분리 및 각각의 추적자에 따른 의미

Many studies using tracers have been conducted to understand a physical process in a system. Rain-on-snow could accelerate snowmelt processes, which influences the hydrological process in both temperate and polar regions. Hydrological and ecological conditions will be affected by the amount and timing of discharge reaching the bottom of a snowpack. The discharge consists of the rain-on-snow, pore water penetrating into the snowpack and natural meltwater. In this study, after a rain-on-snow experiment, we conducted an isotopic hydrograph separation to distinguish rainwater and pore water from meltwater. Using the isotopic data of snow and meltwater from Lee et al. (2010), two components were separated based on the assumption that rainwater and pore water are new water and natural meltwater is old water. After the second rain-on-snow experiment, the maximum contributions of rainwater and pore water reached up to 69% of the discharge and then decreased. During the study period, the measured total discharge was 4153 L and 40% (based on hydrogen isotope) of rainwater and pore water was calculated in the discharge, which is not consistent with what Lee et al. (2016) calculated using chemical separation (63%). This inconsistency can be explained by how an end-member was defined in both approaches. The contributions of artificial rainonsnow and pore water to melwater discharge range between the two methods. This study will suggest a mixing calculation from isotopic compositions of the Southern Ocean.

The importance of snowmelt spatiotemporal variability for isotope-based hydrograph separation in a high-elevation catchment

Abstract. Seasonal snow cover is an important temporary water storage in high-elevation regions. Especially in remote areas, the available data are often insufficient to accurately quantify snowmelt contributions to streamflow. The limited knowledge about the spatiotemporal variability of the snowmelt isotopic composition, as well as pronounced spatial variation in snowmelt rates, leads to high uncertainties in applying the isotope-based hydrograph separation method. The stable isotopic signatures of snowmelt water samples collected during two spring 2014 snowmelt events at a north- and a south-facing slope were volume weighted with snowmelt rates derived from a distributed physics-based snow model in order to transfer the measured plot-scale isotopic composition of snowmelt to the catchment scale. The observed δ18O values and modeled snowmelt rates showed distinct inter- and intra-event variations, as well as marked differences between north- and south-facing slopes. Accounting for these differences, two-component isotopic hydrograph separation revealed snowmelt contributions to streamflow of 35 ± 3 and 75 ± 14 % for the early and peak melt season, respectively. These values differed from those determined by formerly used weighting methods (e.g., using observed plot-scale melt rates) or considering either the north- or south-facing slope by up to 5 and 15 %, respectively.