Isothermal Titration Calorimetry Approach Research Articles

Quantifying cooperative multisite binding in the hub protein LC8 through Bayesian inference.

Multistep protein-protein interactions underlie most biological processes, but their characterization through methods such as isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is largely confined to simple models that provide little information on the intermediate, individual steps. In this study, we primarily examine the essential hub protein LC8, a small dimer that binds disordered regions of 100+ client proteins in two symmetrical grooves at the dimer interface. Mechanistic details of LC8 binding have remained elusive, hampered in part by ITC data analyses employing simple models that treat bivalent binding as a single event with a single binding affinity. We build on existing Bayesian ITC approaches to quantify thermodynamic parameters for multi-site binding interactions impacted by significant uncertainty in protein concentration. Using a two-site binding model, we identify positive cooperativity with high confidence for LC8 binding to multiple client peptides. In contrast, application of an identical model to the two-site binding between the coiled-coil NudE dimer and the intermediate chain of dynein reveals little evidence of cooperativity. We propose that cooperativity in the LC8 system drives the formation of saturated induced-dimer structures, the functional units of most LC8 complexes. In addition to these system-specific findings, our work advances general ITC analysis in two ways. First, we describe a previously unrecognized mathematical ambiguity in concentrations in standard binding models and clarify how it impacts the precision with which binding parameters are determinable in cases of high uncertainty in analyte concentrations. Second, building on observations in the LC8 system, we develop a system-agnostic heat map of practical parameter identifiability calculated from synthetic data which demonstrates that the ability to determine microscopic binding parameters is strongly dependent on both the parameters themselves and experimental conditions. The work serves as a foundation for determination of multi-step binding interactions, and we outline best practices for Bayesian analysis of ITC experiments.

Isothermal Titration Calorimetry in Biocatalysis

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a popular chemical analysis technique that can be used to measure macromolecular interactions and chemical and physical processes. ITC involves the measurement of heat flow to and from a measurement cell after each injection during a titration experiment. ITC has been useful to measure the thermodynamics of macromolecular interactions such as protein-ligand or protein-protein binding affinity and also chemical processes such as enzyme catalyzed reactions. The use of ITC in biocatalysis has a number of advantages as ITC enables the measurement of enzyme kinetic parameters in a direct manner and, in principle, can be used for most enzymes and substrates. ITC approaches have been developed to measure reversible and irreversible enzyme inhibition, the effects of molecular crowding on enzyme activity, the activity of immobilized enzymes and the conversion of complex polymeric substrates. A disadvantage is that in order to obtain accurate kinetic parameters special care has to be taken in proper experimental design and data interpretation, which unfortunately is not always the case in reported studies. Furthermore, special caution is necessary when ITC experiments are performed that include solvents, reducing agents and may have side reactions. An important bottleneck in the use of calorimetry to measure enzyme activity is the relatively low throughput, which may be solved in the future by sensitive chip based microfluidic enzyme calorimetric devices.

Mechanistic Studies of Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer in a Calorimetry Cell.

Mechanistic studies of proton-coupled electron-transfer (PCET) reactions in proteins are complicated by the challenge of following proton transfer (PT) in these large molecules. Herein we describe the use of isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) to establish proton involvement in protein redox reactions and the identity of PT sites. We validate this approach with three variants of a heme protein cytochrome c (cyt c) and show that the method yields a wealth of thermodynamic information that is important for characterizing PCET reactions, including reduction potentials, redox-dependent p Ka values, and reaction enthalpies for both electron-transfer (ET) and PT steps. We anticipate that this facile and label-free ITC approach will find widespread applications in studies of other redox proteins and enhance our knowledge of PCET reaction mechanisms.

Real-time monitoring of D-Ala-D-Ala dipeptidase activity of VanX in living bacteria by isothermal titration calorimetry

The d,d-dipeptidase enzyme VanX is the main cause of vancomycin resistance in gram-positive bacteria because of hydrolysis of the D-Ala-D-Ala dipeptide used in cell-wall biosynthesis. Continuous assay of VanX has proven challenging due to lack of a chromophoric substrate. Here, we report a direct approach for continuous assay of VanX in vitro and in vivo from hydrolysis of D-Ala-D-Ala, based on the heat-rate changes measured with isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). With the ITC approach, determination of kinetic parameters of VanX hydrolyzing D-Ala-D-Ala and the inhibition constant of d-cysteine inhibitor yielded KM of 0.10 mM, kcat of 11.5 s−1, and Ki of 18.8 μM, which are consistent with the data from ninhydrin/Cd(II) assays. Cell-based ITC studies demonstrated that the VanX expressed in E. coli and in clinical strain VRE was inhibited by d-cysteine with IC50 values of 29.8 and 28.6 μM, respectively. Also, the total heat from D-Ala-D-Ala (4 mM) hydrolysis decreases strongly (in absolute value) from 1.26 mJ for VRE to 0.031 mJ for E. faecalis, which is consistent with the large MIC value of vancomycin of 512 μg/mL for VRE and the much smaller value of 4 μg/mL for E. faecalis. The ITC approach proposed here could be applied to screen and evaluate small molecule inhibitors of VanX or to identify drug resistant bacteria.

Preparation To Minimize Buffer Mismatch in Isothermal Titration Calorimetry Experiments.

There is a growing need to study ligand binding to proteins in native or complex solution using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). For example, it is desirable to measure ligand binding to membrane proteins in more native lipid-like environments such as bicelles, where ligands can access both sides of the membrane in a homogeneous environment. A critical step to obtain high signal-to-noise is matching the reaction chamber solution to the ligand solution, typically through a final dialysis or gel filtration step. However, to obtain reproducible bicelles, the lipid concentrations must be carefully controlled which eliminates the use of dialysis that can disrupt these parameters. Here, we report and validate a rapid preparation ITC (RP-ITC) approach to measure ligand binding without the need for a dialysis step. This general approach is used to quantify ion binding to a K(+) channel embedded in bicelles and can be applied to complex, less defined systems.

Development of a Model Protein Interaction Pair as a Benchmarking Tool for the Quantitative Analysis of 2-Site Protein-Protein Interactions.

A significant challenge in the molecular interaction field is to accurately determine the stoichiometry and stepwise binding affinity constants for macromolecules having >1 binding site. The mission of the Molecular Interactions Research Group (MIRG) of the Association of Biomolecular Resource Facilities (ABRF) is to show how biophysical technologies are used to quantitatively characterize molecular interactions, and to educate the ABRF members and scientific community on the utility and limitations of core technologies [such as biosensor, microcalorimetry, or analytic ultracentrifugation (AUC)]. In the present work, the MIRG has developed a robust model protein interaction pair consisting of a bivalent variant of the Bacillus amyloliquefaciens extracellular RNase barnase and a variant of its natural monovalent intracellular inhibitor protein barstar. It is demonstrated that this system can serve as a benchmarking tool for the quantitative analysis of 2-site protein-protein interactions. The protein interaction pair enables determination of precise binding constants for the barstar protein binding to 2 distinct sites on the bivalent barnase binding partner (termed binase), where the 2 binding sites were engineered to possess affinities that differed by 2 orders of magnitude. Multiple MIRG laboratories characterized the interaction using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), AUC, and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) methods to evaluate the feasibility of the system as a benchmarking model. Although general agreement was seen for the binding constants measured using solution-based ITC and AUC approaches, weaker affinity was seen for surface-based method SPR, with protein immobilization likely affecting affinity. An analysis of the results from multiple MIRG laboratories suggests that the bivalent barnase-barstar system is a suitable model for benchmarking new approaches for the quantitative characterization of complex biomolecular interactions.

Kinetic and thermodynamic characterization of the functional properties of a hybrid versatile peroxidase using isothermal titration calorimetry: Insight into manganese peroxidase activation and lignin peroxidase inhibition

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) was developed for measuring lignin peroxidase (LiP) and manganese peroxidase (MnP) activities of versatile peroxidase (VP) from Bjerkandera adusta. Developing an ITC approach provided an alternative to colorimetric methods that enabled reaction kinetics to be accurately determined. Although VP from Bjerkandera adjusta is a hybrid enzyme, specific conditions of [Mn+2] and pH were defined that limited activity to either LiP or MnP activities, or enabled both to be active simultaneously. MnP activity was found to be more efficient than LiP activity, with activity increasing with increasing concentrations of Mn+2. These properties of MnP were explained by a second metal binding site involved in homotropic substrate (Mn+2) activation. The activation of MnP was also accompanied by a decrease in both activation energy and substrate (Mn) affinity, reflecting a flexible enzyme structure. In contrast to MnP activity, LiP activity was inhibited by high dye (substrate) concentrations arising from uncompetitive substrate inhibition caused by substrate binding to a site distinct from the catalytic site. Our study provides a new level of understanding about the mechanism of substrate regulation of catalysis in VP from B. adjusta, providing insight into a class of enzyme, hybrid class II peroxidases, for which little experimental data is available.

Thermodynamics and Solvent Effects on Substrate and Cofactor Binding in Escherichia coli Chromosomal Dihydrofolate Reductase

Chromosomal dihydrofolate reductase from Escherichia coli catalyzes the reduction of dihydrofolate to tetrahydrofolate using NADPH as a cofactor. The thermodynamics of ligand binding were examined using an isothermal titration calorimetry approach. Using buffers with different heats of ionization, zero to a small, fractional proton release was observed for dihydrofolate binding, while a proton was released upon NADP(+) binding. The role of water in binding was additionally monitored using a number of different osmolytes. Binding of NADP(+) is accompanied by the net release of ∼5-24 water molecules, with a dependence on the identity of the osmolyte. In contrast, binding of dihydrofolate is weakened in the presence of osmolytes, consistent with "water uptake". Different effects are observed depending on the identity of the osmolyte. The net uptake of water upon dihydrofolate binding was previously observed in the nonhomologous R67-encoded dihydrofolate reductase (dfrB or type II enzyme) [Chopra, S., et al. (2008) J. Biol. Chem. 283, 4690-4698]. As R67 dihydrofolate reductase possesses a nonhomologous sequence and forms a tetrameric structure with a single active site pore, the observation of weaker DHF binding in the presence of osmolytes in both enzymes implicates cosolvent effects on free dihydrofolate. Consistent with this analysis, stopped flow experiments find betaine mostly affects DHF binding via changes in k(on), while betaine mostly affects NADPH binding via changes in k(off). Finally, nonadditive enthalpy terms when binary and ternary cofactor binding events are compared suggest the presence of long-lived conformational transitions that are not included in a simple thermodynamic cycle.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Rv ESAT‐6–CFP‐10 complex formation confers thermodynamic and biochemical stability

The 6-kDa early secretory antigenic target (ESAT-6) and culture filtrate protein-10 (CFP-10), expressed from the region of deletion-1 (RD1) of Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Rv, are known to play a key role in virulence. In this study, we explored the thermodynamic and biochemical changes associated with the formation of the 1 : 1 heterodimeric complex between ESAT-6 and CFP-10. Using isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), we precisely determined the association constant and free energy change for formation of the complex to be 2 x 10(7) M(-1) and -9.95 kcal.mol(-1), respectively. Strikingly, the thermal unfolding of the ESAT-6-CFP-10 heterodimeric complex was completely reversible, with a T(m) of 53.4 degrees C and DeltaH of 69 kcal.mol(-1). Mixing of ESAT-6 and CFP-10 at any temperature below the T(m) of the complex led to induction of helical conformation, suggesting molecular recognition between specific segments of unfolded ESAT-6 and CFP-10. Enhanced biochemical stability of the complex was indicated by protection of ESAT-6 and an N-terminal fragment of CFP-10 from proteolysis with trypsin. However, the flexible C-terminal of CFP-10 in the complex, which has been shown to be responsible for binding to macrophages and monocytes, was cleaved by trypsin. In the presence of phospholipid membranes, ESAT-6, but not CFP-10 and the complex, showed an increase in alpha-helical content and enhanced thermal stability. Overall, complex formation resulted in structural changes, enhanced thermodynamic and biochemical stability, and loss of binding to phospholipid membranes. These features of complex formation probably determine the physiological role of ESAT-6, CFP-10 and/or the complex in vivo. The ITC and thermal unfolding approach described in this study can readily be applied to characterization of the 11 other pairs of ESAT-6 family proteins and for screening ESAT-6 and CFP-10 mutants.

Precise and continuous observation of cellulase-catalyzed hydrolysis of cello-oligosaccharides using isothermal titration calorimetry

Heat is a characteristic of all chemical reactions, and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) provides a possible way to continuously detect the heat from catalytic reactions with high sensitivity and reproducibility. Cellulase, the enzyme of glycosyl hydrolase, catalyzes the cleavage of β-1,4 glycosidic bonds in cellulose. In this paper, ITC was applied to evaluate cellulase activity using cello-oligosaccharides as substrates. The hydrolysis heat of a single glycosidic bond of the substrate was successfully detected by combining ITC and normal-phase HPLC, and the time course of the enzymatic reaction was monitored continuously by ITC. The enzymatic parameters k cat and K M, obtained from calorimetric observables, clearly indicated that the reaction was well approximated by a simple Michaelis–Menten equation under the experimental conditions of this study. The normal-phase HPLC analysis was combined with the ITC approach to observe hydrolysis patterns and was found to be an effective and precise way to evaluate the activity of cellulase against cello-oligosaccharides.