Human alterations to landscapes can greatly influence watershed-scale sedimentary processes; therefore, in this study, we test the viability of a novel Rb-Sr isotope and elemental geochemical method for fingerprinting the impacts of human land use on sediment provenance. We analyzed a ∼1200-year sediment core record from Little Kennebago Lake, Maine, USA, that captures negligible anthropogenic activity pre-1900 CE, timber transport downstream during log drives (1900−1952 CE), and increased road construction and timber harvest (1952−2018 CE). 87Sr/86Sr data alone reveal several spikes, likely due to storm events, and variability but no systematic shift at the onset of logging. The pre-logging record Rb-Sr isotope data comprise an isochron corresponding to an age of 354 ± 16 Ma (two standard errors [2SE]; mean square of weighted deviates [MSWD] = 2.1, n = 33). None of the bedrock or glacial till sources that we analyzed fall along the pre-logging isochron, nor did any binary or ternary bulk rock mixtures. However, the linearity of all pre-logging samples and coincidence of the isochron age with Acadian metamorphism in the region suggests that sediment was derived from a single source in the undisturbed watershed, though that exact bedrock or glacial till source remains unclear. The onset of logging coincides with a shift toward generally lower sediment Rb-Sr isotope ratios that are offset from the pre-logging isochron. This logging data forms a scattered pseudo-isochron with an apparent Carboniferous age of 322 ± 32 Ma (2SE; MSWD = 4.5, n = 10). No rocks of this age exist in the region. Therefore, we interpret this age to have no geologic meaning and instead reflect the introduction of new sediment sources due to logging. Logging also coincides with subtle changes in elemental geochemistry. The Big Island Pond Pluton underlies most of the northern part of the watershed and is the only catchment lithology capable of producing each geochemical change; therefore, we conclude that it was the primary new source of sediment introduced by logging. We found little variation in sediment geochemistry between the period of early log drives and later road expansion, suggesting that sediment provenance was constant once altered by the initial onset of logging, which could reflect the same source being tapped by activities in each period. We established a framework for interpreting bulk sediment Rb-Sr isotope ratios and demonstrated their viability for identifying shifts in human impacts on geomorphic processes. Our findings suggest that relative changes in sediment Rb-Sr isotope ratios are a promising tool for investigating changes to sedimentary processes not identifiable by other commonly used fingerprints and that the method should be further tested in a range of other natural and anthropogenic settings globally.