The wet heathland communities of the Ericetum tetralicis and the Cirsio-Molinietum have declined in the Netherlands due to acidification, eutrophication and lowering of the water table. To investigate the prospects of restoration of both communities, the effects of sod cutting and hydrological measures on vegetation and soil chemistry were studied in two nature reserves where these plant communities occurred decades ago. The combination of sod cutting and hydrological measures has restored several rare, groundwater dependent heathland communities. Sod cutting has restored the Ericetum tetralicis, but not the Cirsio-Molinietum. This might be due to the absence of viable seeds of characteristic species of the Cirsio-Molinietum and/or the absence of optimal site conditions, especially high phosphorus concentrations in the top soil. The high phosphorus concentrations might be a consequence of high mineralization rates and/or prolonged inundation with iron-poor water and the decreased flux of iron-rich groundwater into the topsoil. Restoration of the Cirsio-Molinietum only seems possible when sod cutting is carried out together with hydrological measures that counter prolonged inundation and reinforce the discharge of base and iron-rich groundwater.