Although in vitro and animal studies have shown that iron loading in pancreatic beta cells impairs insulin secretion, no human studies have documented the acute effects of oral iron on beta-cell insulin secretory capacity. In the present study, we determined beta-cell insulin secretory capacity at baseline and after a single oral dose of iron (ferrous sulphate, 120 mg elemental iron) in healthy male individuals. Fifteen healthy male volunteers underwent an oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) to document baseline glucose tolerance and insulin secretion kinetics (baseline OGTT). One week later, the same subjects underwent a second OGTT, 2 h after an oral dose of ferrous sulphate (120 mg of elemental iron) (post-iron OGTT). Changes in disposition index, insulin secretion kinetics, glucose tolerance, insulin resistance, insulin clearance and iron-related parameters in serum were determined. Compared to baseline OGTT, the areas under the curve (AUC) for serum iron and transferrin saturation increased by 125% and 118%, respectively, in the post-iron OGTT. The disposition index decreased by 20% (p = 0.009) and the AUC for glucose concentrations increased by 5.7% (p < 0.001) during the post-iron OGTT. The insulin secretion rate was marginally lower during the first hour (-3.5%, p = 0.63), but became significantly higher during the second hour (22%, p = 0.005) of the post-iron OGTT. Insulin resistance and insulin clearance rate were not affected by iron intake. The decrease in disposition index and glucose tolerance observed after the oral dose of iron points to an acute iron-induced impairment in pancreatic beta-cell insulin secretory capacity.