Abstract In many astrophysical environments the plasma is only partially ionized, and therefore the interaction of charged and neutral particles may alter both the triggering of reconnection and its subsequent dynamical evolution. We derive the tearing mode maximum growth rate for partially ionized plasmas in the cases of weak and strong coupling between the plasma and the neutrals. In addition, critical scalings for current sheet aspect ratios are presented in terms of Lundquist number and ion–neutral collision frequencies for which the tearing mode becomes fast, or ideal. In the decoupled regime the standard tearing mode is recovered with a small correction that depends on the ion–neutral collision frequency; in the intermediate regime collisions with neutrals are shown to stabilize current sheets, resulting in larger critical aspect ratios for ideal tearing to occur. In the coupled regime, the growth rate depends on the density ratio between ions and neutrals through the collision frequency between these two species.