Prediction Of Intrinsic Disorder Research Articles

Surveying over 100 predictors of intrinsic disorder in proteins

ABSTRACT Introduction Intrinsic disorder prediction field develops, assesses, and deploys computational predictors of disorder in protein sequences and constructs and disseminates databases of these predictions. Over 40 years of research resulted in the release of numerous resources. Areas covered We identify and briefly summarize the most comprehensive to date collection of over 100 disorder predictors. We focus on their predictive models, availability and predictive performance. We categorize and study them from a historical point of view to highlight informative trends. Expert opinion We find a consistent trend of improvements in predictive quality as newer and more advanced predictors are developed. The original focus on machine learning methods has shifted to meta-predictors in early 2010s, followed by a recent transition to deep learning. The use of deep learners will continue in foreseeable future given recent and convincing success of these methods. Moreover, a broad range of resources that facilitate convenient collection of accurate disorder predictions is available to users. They include web servers and standalone programs for disorder prediction, servers that combine prediction of disorder and disorder functions, and large databases of pre-computed predictions. We also point to the need to address the shortage of accurate methods that predict disordered binding regions.

FlDPnn: Accurate intrinsic disorder prediction with putative propensities of disorder functions

Identification of intrinsic disorder in proteins relies in large part on computational predictors, which demands that their accuracy should be high. Since intrinsic disorder carries out a broad range of cellular functions, it is desirable to couple the disorder and disorder function predictions. We report a computational tool, flDPnn, that provides accurate, fast and comprehensive disorder and disorder function predictions from protein sequences. The recent Critical Assessment of protein Intrinsic Disorder prediction (CAID) experiment and results on other test datasets demonstrate that flDPnn offers accurate predictions of disorder, fully disordered proteins and four common disorder functions. These predictions are substantially better than the results of the existing disorder predictors and methods that predict functions of disorder. Ablation tests reveal that the high predictive performance stems from innovative ways used in flDPnn to derive sequence profiles and encode inputs. flDPnn’s webserver is available at http://biomine.cs.vcu.edu/servers/flDPnn/

Critical assessment of protein intrinsic disorder prediction

Intrinsically disordered proteins, defying the traditional protein structure–function paradigm, are a challenge to study experimentally. Because a large part of our knowledge rests on computational predictions, it is crucial that their accuracy is high. The Critical Assessment of protein Intrinsic Disorder prediction (CAID) experiment was established as a community-based blind test to determine the state of the art in prediction of intrinsically disordered regions and the subset of residues involved in binding. A total of 43 methods were evaluated on a dataset of 646 proteins from DisProt. The best methods use deep learning techniques and notably outperform physicochemical methods. The top disorder predictor has Fmax = 0.483 on the full dataset and Fmax = 0.792 following filtering out of bona fide structured regions. Disordered binding regions remain hard to predict, with Fmax = 0.231. Interestingly, computing times among methods can vary by up to four orders of magnitude.

Insights into the evolutionary forces that shape the codon usage in the viral genome segments encoding intrinsically disordered protein regions.

Intrinsically disordered regions/proteins (IDRs) are abundant across all the domains of life, where they perform important regulatory roles and supplement the biological functions of structured proteins/regions (SRs). Despite the multifunctionality features of IDRs, several interrogations on the evolution of viral genomic regions encoding IDRs in diverse viral proteins remain unreciprocated. To fill this gap, we benchmarked the findings of two most widely used and reliable intrinsic disorder prediction algorithms (IUPred2A and ESpritz) to a dataset of 6108 reference viral proteomes to unravel the multifaceted evolutionary forces that shape the codon usage in the viral genomic regions encoding for IDRs and SRs. We found persuasive evidence that the natural selection predominantly governs the evolution of codon usage in regions encoding IDRs by most of the viruses. In addition, we confirm not only that codon usage in regions encoding IDRs is less optimized for the protein synthesis machinery (transfer RNAs pool) of their host than for those encoding SRs, but also that the selective constraints imposed by codon bias sustain this reduced optimization in IDRs. Our analysis also establishes that IDRs in viruses are likely to tolerate more translational errors than SRs. All these findings hold true, irrespective of the disorder prediction algorithms used to classify IDRs. In conclusion, our study offers a novel perspective on the evolution of viral IDRs and the evolutionary adaptability to multiple taxonomically divergent hosts.

Comparative Assessment of Intrinsic Disorder Predictions with a Focus on Protein and Nucleic Acid-Binding Proteins.

With over 60 disorder predictors, users need help navigating the predictor selection task. We review 28 surveys of disorder predictors, showing that only 11 include assessment of predictive performance. We identify and address a few drawbacks of these past surveys. To this end, we release a novel benchmark dataset with reduced similarity to the training sets of the considered predictors. We use this dataset to perform a first-of-its-kind comparative analysis that targets two large functional families of disordered proteins that interact with proteins and with nucleic acids. We show that limiting sequence similarity between the benchmark and the training datasets has a substantial impact on predictive performance. We also demonstrate that predictive quality is sensitive to the use of the well-annotated order and inclusion of the fully structured proteins in the benchmark datasets, both of which should be considered in future assessments. We identify three predictors that provide favorable results using the new benchmark set. While we find that VSL2B offers the most accurate and robust results overall, ESpritz-DisProt and SPOT-Disorder perform particularly well for disordered proteins. Moreover, we find that predictions for the disordered protein-binding proteins suffer low predictive quality compared to generic disordered proteins and the disordered nucleic acids-binding proteins. This can be explained by the high disorder content of the disordered protein-binding proteins, which makes it difficult for the current methods to accurately identify ordered regions in these proteins. This finding motivates the development of a new generation of methods that would target these difficult-to-predict disordered proteins. We also discuss resources that support users in collecting and identifying high-quality disorder predictions.

Prediction of Intrinsic Disorder with Quality Assessment Using QUARTER.

Intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) are estimated to be highly abundant in nature. While only several thousand proteins are annotated with experimentally derived IDRs, computational methods can be used to predict IDRs for the millions of currently uncharacterized protein chains. Several dozen disorder predictors were developed over the last few decades. While some of these methods provide accurate predictions, unavoidably they also make some mistakes. Consequently, one of the challenges facing users of these methods is how to decide which predictions can be trusted and which are likely incorrect. This practical problem can be solved using quality assessment (QA) scores that predict correctness of the underlying (disorder) predictions at a residue level. We motivate and describe a first-of-its-kind toolbox of QA methods, QUARTER (QUality Assessment for pRotein inTrinsic disordEr pRedictions), which provides the scores for a diverse set of ten disorder predictors. QUARTER is available to the end users as a free and convenient webserver at http://biomine.cs.vcu.edu/servers/QUARTER/ . We briefly describe the predictive architecture of QUARTER and provide detailed instructions on how to use the webserver. We also explain how to interpret results produced by QUARTER with the help of a case study.

Computational Prediction of Intrinsic Disorder in Protein Sequences with the disCoP Meta-predictor.

Intrinsically disordered proteins are either entirely disordered or contain disordered regions in their native state. These proteins and regions function without the prerequisite of a stable structure and were found to be abundant across all kingdoms of life. Experimental annotation of disorder lags behind the rapidly growing number of sequenced proteins, motivating the development of computational methods that predict disorder in protein sequences. DisCoP is a user-friendly webserver that provides accurate sequence-based prediction of protein disorder. It relies on meta-architecture in which the outputs generated by multiple disorder predictors are combined together to improve predictive performance. The architecture of disCoP is presented, and its accuracy relative to several other disorder predictors is briefly discussed. We describe usage of the web interface and explain how to access and read results generated by this computational tool. We also provide an example of prediction results and interpretation. The disCoP's webserver is publicly available at http://biomine.cs.vcu.edu/servers/disCoP/ .

SPOT-Disorder2: Improved Protein Intrinsic Disorder Prediction by Ensembled Deep Learning

Intrinsically disordered or unstructured proteins (or regions in proteins) have been found to be important in a wide range of biological functions and implicated in many diseases. Due to the high cost and low efficiency of experimental determination of intrinsic disorder and the exponential increase of unannotated protein sequences, developing complementary computational prediction methods has been an active area of research for several decades. Here, we employed an ensemble of deep Squeeze-and-Excitation residual inception and long short-term memory (LSTM) networks for predicting protein intrinsic disorder with input from evolutionary information and predicted one-dimensional structural properties. The method, called SPOT-Disorder2, offers substantial and consistent improvement not only over our previous technique based on LSTM networks alone, but also over other state-of-the-art techniques in three independent tests with different ratios of disordered to ordered amino acid residues, and for sequences with either rich or limited evolutionary information. More importantly, semi-disordered regions predicted in SPOT-Disorder2 are more accurate in identifying molecular recognition features (MoRFs) than methods directly designed for MoRFs prediction. SPOT-Disorder2 is available as a web server and as a standalone program at https://sparks-lab.org/server/spot-disorder2/.

Disorder Atlas: Web-based software for the proteome-based interpretation of intrinsic disorder predictions

Intrinsically disordered proteins lack a stable three-dimensional structure under physiological conditions. While this property has gained considerable interest within the past two decades, disorder poses substantial challenges to experimental characterization efforts. In effect, numerous computational tools have been developed to predict disorder from primary sequences, however, interpreting the output of these algorithms remains a challenge. To begin to bridge this gap, we present Disorder Atlas, web-based software that facilitates the interpretation of intrinsic disorder predictions using proteome-based descriptive statistics. This service is also equipped to facilitate large-scale systematic exploratory searches for proteins encompassing disorder features of interest, and further allows users to browse the prevalence of multiple disorder features at the proteome level. As a result, Disorder Atlas provides a user-friendly tool that places algorithm-generated disorder predictions in the context of the proteome, thereby providing an instrument to compare the results of a query protein against predictions made for an entire population. Disorder Atlas currently supports ten eukaryotic proteomes and is freely available for non-commercial users at http://www.disorderatlas.org.

Codon selection reduces GC content bias in nucleic acids encoding for intrinsically disordered proteins.

Protein-coding nucleic acids exhibit composition and codon biases between sequences coding for intrinsically disordered regions (IDRs) and those coding for structured regions. IDRs are regions of proteins that are folding self-insufficient and which function without the prerequisite of folded structure. Several authors have investigated composition bias or codon selection in regions encoding for IDRs, primarily in Eukaryota, and concluded that elevated GC content is the result of the biased amino acid composition of IDRs. We substantively extend previous work by examining GC content in regions encoding IDRs, from 44 species in Eukaryota, Archaea, and Bacteria, spanning a wide range of GC content. We confirm that regions coding for IDRs show a significantly elevated GC content, even across all domains of life. Although this is largely attributable to the amino acid composition bias of IDRs, we show that this bias is independent of the overall GC content and, most importantly, we are the first to observe that GC content bias in IDRs is significantly different than expected from IDR amino acid composition alone. We empirically find compensatory codon selection that reduces the observed GC content bias in IDRs. This selection is dependent on the overall GC content of the organism. The codon selection bias manifests as use of infrequent, AT-rich codons in encoding IDRs. Further, we find these relationships to be independent of the intrinsic disorder prediction method used, and independent of estimated translation efficiency. These observations are consistent with the previous work, and we speculate on whether the observed biases are causal or symptomatic of other driving forces.

BASILIScan: a tool for high-throughput analysis of intrinsic disorder patterns in homologous proteins

BackgroundIntrinsic structural disorder is a common property of many proteins, especially in eukaryotic and virus proteomes. The tendency of some proteins or protein regions to exist in a disordered state usually precludes their structural characterisation and renders them especially difficult for experimental handling after recombinant expression.ResultsA new intuitive, publicly-available computational resource, called BASILIScan, is presented here. It provides a BLAST-based search for close homologues of the protein of interest, integrated with a simultaneous prediction of intrinsic disorder together with a robust data viewer and interpreter. This allows for a quick, high-throughput screening, scoring and selection of closely-related yet highly structured homologues of the protein of interest. Comparative parallel analysis of the conservation of extended regions of disorder in multiple sequences is also offered. The use of BASILIScan and its capacity for yielding biologically applicable predictions is demonstrated. Using a high-throughput BASILIScan screen it is also shown that a large proportion of the human proteome displays homologous sequences of superior intrinsic structural order in many related species.ConclusionThrough the swift identification of intrinsically stable homologues and poorly conserved disordered regions by the BASILIScan software, the chances of successful recombinant protein expression and compatibility with downstream applications such as crystallisation can be greatly increased.

Accurate Single-Sequence Prediction of Protein Intrinsic Disorder by an Ensemble of Deep Recurrent and Convolutional Architectures.

Recognizing the widespread existence of intrinsically disordered regions in proteins spurred the development of computational techniques for their detection. All existing techniques can be classified into methods relying on single-sequence information and those relying on evolutionary sequence profiles generated from multiple-sequence alignments. The methods based on sequence profiles are, in general, more accurate because the presence or absence of conserved amino acid residues in a protein sequence provides important information on the structural and functional roles of the residues. However, the wide applicability of profile-based techniques is limited by time-consuming calculation of sequence profiles. Here we demonstrate that the performance gap between profile-based techniques and single-sequence methods can be reduced by using an ensemble of deep recurrent and convolutional neural networks that allow whole-sequence learning. In particular, the single-sequence method (called SPOT-Disorder-Single) is more accurate than SPOT-Disorder (a profile-based method) for proteins with few homologous sequences and comparable for proteins in predicting long-disordered regions. The method performance is robust across four independent test sets with different amounts of short- and long-disordered regions. SPOT-Disorder-Single is available as a Web server and as a standalone program at http://sparks-lab.org/jack/server/SPOT-Disorder-Single .

Quality assessment for the putative intrinsic disorder in proteins.

While putative intrinsic disorder is widely used, none of the predictors provides quality assessment (QA) scores. QA scores estimate the likelihood that predictions are correct at a residue level and have been applied in other bioinformatics areas. We recently reported that QA scores derived from putative disorder propensities perform relatively poorly for native disordered residues. Here we design and validate a general approach to construct QA predictors for disorder predictions. The QUARTER (QUality Assessment for pRotein inTrinsic disordEr pRedictions) toolbox of methods accommodates a diverse set of ten disorder predictors. It builds upon several innovative design elements including use and scaling of selected physicochemical properties of the input sequence, post-processing of disorder propensity scores, and a feature selection that optimizes the predictive models to a specific disorder predictor. We empirically establish that each one of these elements contributes to the overall predictive performance of our tool and that QUARTER's outputs significantly outperform QA scores derived from the outputs generated the disorder predictors. The best performing QA scores for a single disorder predictor identify 13% of residues that are predicted with 98% precision. QA scores computed by combining results of the ten disorder predictors cover 40% of residues with 95% precision. Case studies are used to show how to interpret the QA scores. QA scores based on the high precision combined predictions are applied to analyze disorder in the human proteome. http://biomine.cs.vcu.edu/servers/QUARTER/. Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

StructureMapper: a high-throughput algorithm for analyzing protein sequence locations in structural data.

MotivationStructureMapper is a high-throughput algorithm for automated mapping of protein primary amino sequence locations to existing three-dimensional protein structures. The algorithm is intended for facilitating easy and efficient utilization of structural information in protein characterization and proteomics. StructureMapper provides an analysis of the identified structural locations that includes surface accessibility, flexibility, protein–protein interfacing, intrinsic disorder prediction, secondary structure assignment, biological assembly information and sequence identity percentages, among other metrics.ResultsWe have showcased the use of the algorithm by estimating the coverage of structural information of the human proteome, identifying critical interface residues in DNA polymerase γ, profiling structurally protease cleavage sites and post-translational modification sites, and by identifying putative, novel phosphoswitches.Availability and implementationThe StructureMapper algorithm is available as an online service and standalone implementation at http://structuremapper.uta.fi.Supplementary information Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Comprehensive review of methods for prediction of intrinsic disorder and its molecular functions.

Computational prediction of intrinsic disorder in protein sequences dates back to late 1970 and has flourished in the last two decades. We provide a brief historical overview, and we review over 30 recent predictors of disorder. We are the first to also cover predictors of molecular functions of disorder, including 13 methods that focus on disordered linkers and disordered protein-protein, protein-RNA, and protein-DNA binding regions. We overview their predictive models, usability, and predictive performance. We highlight newest methods and predictors that offer strong predictive performance measured based on recent comparative assessments. We conclude that the modern predictors are relatively accurate, enjoy widespread use, and many of them are fast. Their predictions are conveniently accessible to the end users, via web servers and databases that store pre-computed predictions for millions of proteins. However, research into methods that predict many not yet addressed functions of intrinsic disorder remains an outstanding challenge.

Computational Prediction of Intrinsic Disorder in Proteins.

Computational prediction of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) is a mature research field. These methods predict disordered residues and regions in an input protein chain. More than 60 predictors of IDPs have been developed. This unit defines computational prediction of intrinsic disorder, summarizes major types of predictors of disorder, and provides details about three accurate and recently released methods. We demonstrate the use of these methods to predict intrinsic disorder for several illustrative proteins, provide insights into how predictions should be interpreted, and quantify and discuss predictive performance. Predictions can be freely and conveniently obtained using webservers. We point to the availability of databases that provide access to annotations of intrinsic disorder determined by structural studies and putative intrinsic disorder pre-computed by computational methods. Lastly, we also summarize experimental methods that can be used to validate computational predictions. © 2017 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

MobiDB-lite: fast and highly specific consensus prediction of intrinsic disorder in proteins

Intrinsic disorder (ID) is established as an important feature of protein sequences. Its use in proteome annotation is however hampered by the availability of many methods with similar performance at the single residue level, which have mostly not been optimized to predict long ID regions of size comparable to domains. Here, we have focused on providing a single consensus-based prediction, MobiDB-lite, optimized for highly specific (i.e. few false positive) predictions of long disorder. The method uses eight different predictors to derive a consensus which is then filtered for spurious short predictions. Consensus prediction is shown to outperform the single methods when annotating long ID regions. MobiDB-lite can be useful in large-scale annotation scenarios and has indeed already been integrated in the MobiDB, DisProt and InterPro databases. MobiDB-lite is available as part of the MobiDB database from URL: http://mobidb.bio.unipd.it/. An executable can be downloaded from URL: http://protein.bio.unipd.it/mobidblite/. silvio.tosatto@unipd.it. Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Improving protein disorder prediction by deep bidirectional long short-term memory recurrent neural networks.

Capturing long-range interactions between structural but not sequence neighbors of proteins is a long-standing challenging problem in bioinformatics. Recently, long short-term memory (LSTM) networks have significantly improved the accuracy of speech and image classification problems by remembering useful past information in long sequential events. Here, we have implemented deep bidirectional LSTM recurrent neural networks in the problem of protein intrinsic disorder prediction. The new method, named SPOT-Disorder, has steadily improved over a similar method using a traditional, window-based neural network (SPINE-D) in all datasets tested without separate training on short and long disordered regions. Independent tests on four other datasets including the datasets from critical assessment of structure prediction (CASP) techniques and >10 000 annotated proteins from MobiDB, confirmed SPOT-Disorder as one of the best methods in disorder prediction. Moreover, initial studies indicate that the method is more accurate in predicting functional sites in disordered regions. These results highlight the usefulness combining LSTM with deep bidirectional recurrent neural networks in capturing non-local, long-range interactions for bioinformatics applications. SPOT-disorder is available as a web server and as a standalone program at: http://sparks-lab.org/server/SPOT-disorder/index.php . j.hanson@griffith.edu.au or yuedong.yang@griffith.edu.au or yaoqi.zhou@griffith.edu.au. Supplementary data is available at Bioinformatics online.

InterPro in 2017-beyond protein family and domain annotations.

InterPro (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/interpro/) is a freely available database used to classify protein sequences into families and to predict the presence of important domains and sites. InterProScan is the underlying software that allows both protein and nucleic acid sequences to be searched against InterPro's predictive models, which are provided by its member databases. Here, we report recent developments with InterPro and its associated software, including the addition of two new databases (SFLD and CDD), and the functionality to include residue-level annotation and prediction of intrinsic disorder. These developments enrich the annotations provided by InterPro, increase the overall number of residues annotated and allow more specific functional inferences.

Intrinsic Disorder and Semi-disorder Prediction by SPINE-D.

Over the past decade, it has become evident that a large proportion of proteins contain intrinsically disordered regions, which play important roles in pivotal cellular functions. Many computational tools have been developed with the aim of identifying the level and location of disorder within a protein. In this chapter, we describe a neural network based technique called SPINE-D that employs a unique three-state design and can accurately capture disordered residues in both short and long disordered regions. SPINE-D was trained on a large database of 4229 non-redundant proteins, and yielded an AUC of 0.86 on a cross-validation test and 0.89 on an independent test. SPINE-D can also detect a semi-disordered state that is associated with induced folders and aggregation-prone regions in disordered proteins and weakly stable or locally unfolded regions in structured proteins. We implement an online web service and an offline stand-alone program for SPINE-D, they are freely available at http://sparks-lab.org/SPINE-D/ . We then walk you through how to use the online and offline SPINE-D in making disorder predictions, and examine the disorder and semi-disorder prediction in a case study on the p53 protein.