<h3>Background</h3> Intraosseous lipoma (IL) is an uncommon, benign lesion of the bones, making up approximately 0.1% of all primary osseous tumors. Presentation within the jaws remains particularly rare, with no more than 20 cases of mandibular intraosseous lipoma (MIL) documented within the English language literature. Its presentation is often mistaken for other entities, such as anterior Stafne bone defect, traumatic bone cavity, keratocystic odontogenic tumor, adenomatoid odontogenic tumor, and glandular odontogenic cyst. MIL has been documented with variable signs and symptoms and locations, but manifestations in the anterior mandible are especially uncommon. <h3>Discussion/Conclusions</h3> A 33-year-old Hispanic female presented with an incidental finding of a well-defined, intraosseous unilocular radiolucent lesion in the right anterior mandible that was not visible on previous radiographs. The lesion measured 30 × 20 mm, without cortical expansion, and was located apical to teeth #25, #26, and #27, which were asymptomatic. The lesion was enucleated, and the specimen was histologically confirmed to be MIL. This uncommon case of MIL has helped to better describe the features of this rare entity. The medial border of this lesion closely approximated the symphyseal midline, even when the lesion approaches the anterior mandible in only about 20% of described cases. The lesion also presented in the fourth decade of life, below the typical age of the fifth and sixth decades. Features of the current case have not been previously reported, given the small number of cases documented in the literature. Although MIL has a mild behavior and does not require aggressive surgical management, this case illustrates that it may mimic other diseases, given its location in the anterior mandible in a younger patient, thus hindering an accurate diagnosis.