Abstract Allergic diseases are a major global health issue, causing significant morbidity and mortality. Interleukin-9 (IL-9) producing T helper 9 (Th9) cells promote allergic inflammation, yet Th9 effector functions are incompletely understood because the heterogeneity and instability of Th9 cells makes them challenging to study. Although the significance and mechanisms of Th9 instability are unknown, T cell receptor (TCR) activation is hypothesized to play a key role. Conversely to this paradigm, we found that resting Th9 cells did not require TCR restimulation for IL-9 production, which was induced by STAT5- and STAT6-dependent paracrine cytokines. This mechanism was seen in circulating T cells from allergic patients and was restricted to recently activated cells. Analysis of IL-9 +T cells from allergic subjects revealed a transcriptional program that was enriched for activation pathways and unstable over time, with IL9 amongst the least stable genes. Prolonged resting of cells decreased the accessibility of STAT5-dependent IL9 enhancers, inactivating the locus. In vivo, Th9 cells induced airway inflammation via TCR-independent, STAT-dependent mechanisms. In allergic patients, Th9 expansion was associated with STAT activation and responsiveness to JAK inhibitors. These findings suggest that Th9 instability is a negative checkpoint on TCR-independent inflammation that breaks down in allergic disease, and that JAK inhibitors should be considered for allergic patients with a Th9 signature. Supported by the NIAID intramural research program (2018-2022), University of Pittsburgh start-up funds (2022-current), and the National Psoriasis Foundation (Robertson Fellowship, 2018-2021; Translational Grant, 2022-current)