Objective: Infertile patients with oligo-astheno-teratozoospermia (OAT) and normal karyotype have a higher rate of sperm aneuploidy which is correlates with the severity of OAT. These patients frequently undergo intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) to father a child, raising concerns about the possible increased risk of chromosomal aneuploidies for the concepti, since a natural selection does not occur with this technique. Accordingly, few reports have shown that a high proportion of patients undergoing ICSI program have an increased sperm aneuploidy rate. Another important issue, addressed in this study, is to evaluate the impact of the abnormal sperm chromosome asset on ICSI outcome.Design: Forty-eight consecutive and unselected male partners of couples undergoing ICSI had sperm aneuploidy rate evaluated in the same sperm preparation used for ICSI and obtained by swim-up. They were divided into two groups whether their sperm aneuploidy rate was below (group A) or above (group B) the upper range (1.55%) found in 14 healthy normozoospermic men (control group). Their main ICSI outcome measures were compared.Materials/Methods: Sperm chromosome analysis was conducted by fluorescence in-situ hybridization (FISH), using alpha-centromeric DNA probes for chromosomes 8, 18 (two-color) and 12, X and Y (three-color FISH).Results: Twelve out of 48 patients (25%) had a total sperm aneuploidy rate below the cut-off value of the control group (median: 1.25%; range: 0.85–1.52%), whereas the remaining 36 (75%) patients had an elevated sperm aneuploidy rate (median: 3.25%; range: 1.64–23.60%). Group A patients’ age (median: 33 years; range: 23–40) was similar to that of group B patients’ (median 35 years; range: 25–52). Fertilization (93% vs. 85%) and cleavage (100% vs. 98%) rates resulted similar in both groups of patients. Patients of group A had a significantly higher clinical pregnancy (75% vs. 34%) and implantation (34% vs. 13%) rates compared to the patients of group B. Thirty-two percent of implanted embryos miscarried (preclinical and clinical abortion) in group B compared to the 11% of group A, but the difference did not reach the statistical significance. Other factors which may account for this difference, such as the age of the female partner, theirs infertility factor and the main sperm parameters, resulted to be similar in both groups of patients.Conclusions: This study confirmed that an elevated proportion of patients undergoing ICSI have an increased sperm aneuploidy rate and that cytogenetically abnormal spermatozoa have a negative impact on ICSI outcome.Supported by: A grant from MURST, Rome, Italy, 1999. Objective: Infertile patients with oligo-astheno-teratozoospermia (OAT) and normal karyotype have a higher rate of sperm aneuploidy which is correlates with the severity of OAT. These patients frequently undergo intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) to father a child, raising concerns about the possible increased risk of chromosomal aneuploidies for the concepti, since a natural selection does not occur with this technique. Accordingly, few reports have shown that a high proportion of patients undergoing ICSI program have an increased sperm aneuploidy rate. Another important issue, addressed in this study, is to evaluate the impact of the abnormal sperm chromosome asset on ICSI outcome. Design: Forty-eight consecutive and unselected male partners of couples undergoing ICSI had sperm aneuploidy rate evaluated in the same sperm preparation used for ICSI and obtained by swim-up. They were divided into two groups whether their sperm aneuploidy rate was below (group A) or above (group B) the upper range (1.55%) found in 14 healthy normozoospermic men (control group). Their main ICSI outcome measures were compared. Materials/Methods: Sperm chromosome analysis was conducted by fluorescence in-situ hybridization (FISH), using alpha-centromeric DNA probes for chromosomes 8, 18 (two-color) and 12, X and Y (three-color FISH). Results: Twelve out of 48 patients (25%) had a total sperm aneuploidy rate below the cut-off value of the control group (median: 1.25%; range: 0.85–1.52%), whereas the remaining 36 (75%) patients had an elevated sperm aneuploidy rate (median: 3.25%; range: 1.64–23.60%). Group A patients’ age (median: 33 years; range: 23–40) was similar to that of group B patients’ (median 35 years; range: 25–52). Fertilization (93% vs. 85%) and cleavage (100% vs. 98%) rates resulted similar in both groups of patients. Patients of group A had a significantly higher clinical pregnancy (75% vs. 34%) and implantation (34% vs. 13%) rates compared to the patients of group B. Thirty-two percent of implanted embryos miscarried (preclinical and clinical abortion) in group B compared to the 11% of group A, but the difference did not reach the statistical significance. Other factors which may account for this difference, such as the age of the female partner, theirs infertility factor and the main sperm parameters, resulted to be similar in both groups of patients. Conclusions: This study confirmed that an elevated proportion of patients undergoing ICSI have an increased sperm aneuploidy rate and that cytogenetically abnormal spermatozoa have a negative impact on ICSI outcome. Supported by: A grant from MURST, Rome, Italy, 1999.
Read full abstract