Alternative fuels can reduce the carbon intensity of diesel engine use, and a detailed understanding of the combustion process for these fuels can minimize resulting fuel consumption and emissions. 1-Octanol has been considered as an alternative diesel fuel, but little work evaluating its combustion process in detail exists. In this work, ignition of 1-octanol, both pure and in blends with conventional and renewable diesel base fuels, is analyzed in a constant volume combustion chamber and a modified Cooperative Fuels Research Octane Rating engine operating in homogeneous charge compression ignition combustion mode. 1-Octanol blending reduced the derived cetane number of either base fuel, but modest increases in chamber temperature at injection could compensate for even dramatic reductions in derived cetane number. It was further found that greater amounts of low-temperature heat release were required to reach main ignition as the 1-octanol blending volume fraction was increased in the constant volume combustion chamber. This finding is attributed to the changing local equivalence ratio, as the reacting spray diffuses further into the chamber and approaches the (lean) global equivalence ratio as the ignition delay grows. Finally, it was found that, despite lowering the derived cetane number, 1-octanol blending enhanced the reactivity of the conventional diesel fuel observed in the variable compression ratio engine. This finding is attributed to the higher rates of hydrogen abstraction from the weaker average C–H bonds in 1-octanol, as hydrogen abstraction governs intermediate temperature heat release. These findings clarify the effect of 1-octanol on physical processes and the various chemical regimes of heat release in compression ignition. The dependence of the effects of 1-octanol blending on the base fuel are emphasized, as these can inform the deployment of 1-octanol as a diesel blendstock. Application of these results can support the optimization of conventional combustion strategies for use with 1-octanol, as well as the development of 1-octanol-fueled low-temperature combustion strategies with the associated promise of very low criteria pollutant emissions.