Interaural Level Differences Research Articles

Sensitivity to interaural level and time differences in individuals with autism spectrum disorder

Individuals with autism spectrum disorders (ASD) are reported to exhibit degraded performance in sound localization. This study investigated whether the sensitivity to the interaural level differences (ILDs) and interaural time differences (ITDs), major cues for horizontal sound localization, are affected in ASD. Thresholds for discriminating the ILD and ITD were measured for adults with ASD and age- and IQ-matched controls in a lateralization experiment. Results show that the ASD group exhibited higher ILD and ITD thresholds than the control group. Moreover, there was a significant diversity of ITD sensitivity in the ASD group, and it contained a larger proportion of participants with poor ITD sensitivity than the control group. The current study suggests that deficits in relatively low-level processes in the auditory pathway are implicated in degraded performance of sound localization in individuals with ASD. The results are consistent with the structural abnormalities and great variability in the morphology in the brainstem reported by neuroanatomical studies of ASD.

3-D Sound Source Localization With a Ternary Microphone Array Based on TDOA-ILD Algorithm

Sound source localization is essential for machine-based environmental perception when visual methods are not applicable. Current array-based localization methods often require many microphones and are heavy in computing. This article proposes an efficient algorithm for estimating the location of a single source in 3-D based on the time difference of arrival and interaural level difference (TDOA-ILD) with an array of only three microphones. The algorithm can compute the source 3-D coordinates with a closed-form analytical solution derived from geometrical modeling and identify the actual source from the cone of the confusion area through clustering methods. This article comprehensively evaluates the algorithm’s behavior for various array sizes and source locations in a wide range of signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) with simulative models to prove that the algorithm achieves estimation errors close to its Cramer–Rao lower bound (CRLB). Experimental evaluation demonstrates the method’s localization feasibility in outdoor open environments with off-the-shelf sensing equipment. The proposed scheme is suitable for real-time 3-D sound source localization with cost-effective hardware.

Theoretical investigation of active listening behavior based on the echolocation of CF-FM bats.

Bats perceive the three-dimensional environment by emitting ultrasound pulses from their nose or mouth and receiving echoes through both ears. To determine the position of a target object, it is necessary to know the distance and direction of the target. Certain bat species that use a combined signal of long constant frequency and short frequency modulated ultrasounds synchronize their pinnae movement with pulse emission, and this behavior has been regarded as helpful for localizing the elevation angle of a reflective sound source. However, the significance of bats' ear motions remains unclear. In this study, we construct a model of an active listening system including the motion of the ears, and conduct mathematical investigations to clarify the importance of ear motion in direction detection of the reflective sound source. In the simulations, direction detection under rigid ear movements with interaural level differences was mathematically investigated by assuming that bats accomplish direction detection using the amplitude modulation in the echoes caused by ear movements. In particular, the ear motion conditions required for direction detection are theoretically investigated through exhaustive simulations of the pseudo-motion of the ears, rather than simulations of the actual ear motions of bats. The theory suggests that only certain ear motions, namely three-axis rotation, allow for accurate and robust direction detection. Our theoretical analysis also strongly supports the behavior whereby bats move their pinnae in the antiphase mode. In addition, we suggest that simple shaped hearing directionality and well-selected uncomplicated ear motions are sufficient to achieve precise and robust direction detection. Our findings and mathematical approach have the potential to be used in the design of active sensing systems in various engineering fields.

Spatial relationships between interaural differences in a room

The interaural ratio, as it occurs for a human head in a room, can be represented by a filter with a complex transfer function of the spatial location of the head. The log of this transfer function has real and imaginary parts, respectively, the interaural level difference (ILD) and the interaural phase difference (IPD). Because the filter is causal, the ILD and IPD spatial functions are Hilbert transforms of each other if the interaural filter is a minimum phase function of the head location. Interaural differences for a spherical “head” with tiny probe microphones, separated by a head diameter of 17.5 cm, were measured by Mr. Zane Crawford in an empty room having a volume of 63 $m∧3$ and a reverberation time of 0.4 s. The head was moved in increments of 2.54 cm over a two dimensional grid 102 cm by 23 cm. Measurements at 250 Hz showed that the ILD and IPD were almost perfectly related by Hilbert transforms. Measurements at 500 and 1000 Hz showed increasing deviations. Because a function is orthogonal to its Hilbert transform, the ideal ILD is orthogonal to the IPD. Therefore, at locations where the ILD is the most stable function of space, the IPD is the most unstable and vice versa.

Effect of electric-acoustic cochlear implant stimulation and coding strategies on spatial cues of speech signals in reverberant room

The comparison of spatial cues changes in different setups and coding strategies used in cochlear implants (CI) is investigated. In this experiment, we implement three voice coder setups, such as bilateral CI, bimodal CI, and electro-acoustic stimulation (EAS). Two well-known coding strategies are used, which are continuous interleaved sampling (CIS) and spectral peak (SPEAK). Speech signals are convoluted with appropriate binaural room impulse response (BRIR), creating reverberant spatial stimuli. Five different reverberant conditions (including anechoic) were applied to the stimuli. Interaural level and time differences (ILD and ITD) are evaluated objectively and subjectively, and their relationship with the intelligibility of speech is observed. Prior objective evaluation with CIS reveals that clarity (C50) becomes a more important factor in spatial cue change than reverberation time. Vocoded conditions (bilateral CI) show an increment in ILD value (compression has not been implemented yet on the vocoder processing), when the value of ITD gets more different (decreased) from the middle point. Reverberation degrades the intelligibility rate at various rates depending on the C50 value, both in unvocoded and vocoded conditions. In the vocoded condition, decrement on spatial cues was also followed by the decreement on the intelligibility of spatial stimuli.

Effects of Abacus Training on Auditory Spatial Maturation in Children with Normal Hearing.

Introduction The spatial auditory system, though developed at birth, attains functional maturity in the late childhood (12 years). Spatial changes during childhood affect navigation in the environment and source segregation. Accommodation of a new skill through learning, especially during childhood, can expedite this process. Objective To explore the auditory spatial benefits of abacus training on psychoacoustic metrics in children. The study also aimed to identify the most sensitive metric to abacus training related changes in spatial processing, and utilize this metric for a detailed spatial error profiling. Methods A standard group comparison analysis with 90 participants divided into three groups: I: children with abacus training (C-AT); II: children with no training (C-UT); III: adults with no training (A-UT). The groups underwent a series of psychoacoustic tests, such as interaural time difference (ITD), interaural level difference (ILD), and virtual auditory space identification (VASI), as well as perceptual tests such as the Kannada version of the speech, spatial, and quality questionnaire (K-SSQ). Results Significant group differences were observed in the multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) and post-hoc tests, with the C-AT group showing significantly lower ILD scores ( p = 0.01) and significantly higher VASI scores ( p <0.001) compared to the C-UT group, which is indicative of better spatial processing abilities in the former group. The discriminant function (DF) analyses showed that the VASI was the most sensitive metric for training-related changes, based on which elaborate error analyses were performed. Conclusions Despite the physiological limits of the immature neural framework, the performance of the C-AT group was equivalent to that of untrained adults on psychoacoustic tests, which is reflective of the positive role of abacus training in expediting auditory spatial maturation.

Surrounding line sources optimally reproduce diffuse envelopment at off-center listening positions.

Listener envelopment has previously been studied in the fields of room acoustics and multichannel sound reproduction. However, the potentially detrimental effect of a directional imbalance remains uninvestigated. This paper presents a listening experiment under anechoic conditions using a ring of 24 loudspeakers. Participants rated perceived envelopment for various loudspeaker subsets fed by incoherent noise signals. Off-center listening positions were simulated for different acoustic source models: -6 dB (point source), -3 dB (line source), or 0 dB attenuation for every doubling of distance. Only the line-source model preserved envelopment off-center, providing a low interaural level difference and a low interaural coherence as perceptual cues.

Discrimination thresholds for interaural-time differences and interaural-level differences in naïve listeners: Sex differences and learning

The two primary cues to sound-source location on the horizontal plane are interaural time differences (ITDs) and interaural level differences (ILDs). Here we asked whether the ability to discriminate small changes in each of these interaural cues differs between the sexes. We tested one group of males (n = 43) and females (n = 94) on ITD discrimination at 0.5 kHz and a separate group of males (n = 80) and females (n = 166) on ILD discrimination at 4 kHz. None of the participants had any prior experience with psychoacoustic tasks. Testing of each participant was completed in a single testing session of 4–5 blocks of 60 trials. For ILD discrimination, the overall mean threshold, as well as the mean threshold for each block, was statistically significantly lower for males than for females. Despite that, males and females learned at an equal rate over the course of testing. For ITD discrimination, in contrast, thresholds did not differ significantly between the sexes for the overall mean or for any block. There also was no statistically significant learning across blocks for either sex. For both tasks and both sexes, the individual thresholds spanned a wide range. The presence of a statistically significant sex difference and learning for ILD but not for ITD discrimination, along with a larger effect size for ILD than for ITD discrimination, suggests that the factors responsible for these outcomes acted upon an ILD-specific neural pathway, and not upon an ITD-specific pathway, nor any pathway common to the two cues. Because the ILD and ITD specific pathways are most separable initially, the factors associated with sex and learning may have acted upon the ILD-specific pathway at an early stage.

Sound Localization of Listeners With Normal Hearing, Impaired Hearing, Hearing Aids, Bone-Anchored Hearing Instruments, and Cochlear Implants: A Review.

This review article reviews the contemporary studies of localization ability for different populations in different listening environments and provides possible future research directions. The ability to accurately localize a sound source relying on three cues (interaural time difference, interaural level difference, and spectral cues) is important for communication, learning, and safety. Confounding effects including noise and reverberation, which exist in common listening environments, mask or alter localization cues and negatively affect localization performance. Hearing loss, a common public health issue, also affects localization accuracy. Although hearing devices have been developed to provide excellent audibility of speech signals, less attention has been paid to preserving and replicating crucial localization cues. Unique challenges are faced by users of various hearing devices, including hearing aids, bone-anchored hearing instruments, and cochlear implants. Hearing aids have failed to consistently improve localization performance and, in some cases, significantly impair sound localization. Bone-conduction hearing instruments show little to no benefit for sound localization performance in most cases, although some improvement is seen in binaural users. Although cochlear implants provide great hearing benefit to individuals with severe-to-profound sensorineural hearing loss, cochlear implant users have significant difficulty localizing sound, even with two implants. However, technologies in each of these areas are advancing to reduce interference with desired sound signals and preserve localization cues to help users achieve better hearing and sound localization in real-life environments.

Age-Related Changes in Interaural-Level-Difference-Based Across-Frequency Binaural Interference.

Low-frequency interaural time differences and high-frequency interaural level differences (ILDs) are used to localize sounds in the horizontal plane. Older listeners appear to be worse at horizontal-plane sound localization to compared younger listeners, but little is understood about age-related changes to across-frequency binaural processing. This study investigated if the frequency dependence of across-frequency ILD processing is altered for older compared to younger listeners, which was done by using an across-frequency binaural interference task (when the interaural difference sensitivity for a target sound is decreased by a spectrally remote interfering sound with zero interaural differences). It was hypothesized that as listeners experience advancing age and age-related high-frequency hearing loss (i.e., presbycusis), they will demonstrate worse binaural performance and experience more across-channel binaural interference (because of age-related temporal processing deficits), and will increasingly be affected by interferers at lower frequencies (because of age-related hearing loss) when compared to younger listeners. There were 11 older (>65 yrs) and 20 younger (<30 yrs) listeners with normal to near-normal audiometric thresholds up to 2 kHz. They were tested using a left-right ILD lateralization discrimination task. Single-tone ILD discrimination thresholds and across-frequency binaural interference were measured at 0.5, 1, 2, 4, and 8 kHz. ILD thresholds and interference were about twice as large for older compared to younger listeners. Interferers ≤1 kHz produced 2–3 times as much across-frequency binaural interference for older compared to younger listeners. Hearing thresholds were significant predictors of single-tone ILD thresholds; in addition, both target and interferer hearing thresholds were significant predictors of binaural interference. The results suggest a reweighting of binaural information that occurs with advancing age and age-related high-frequency hearing loss. This evidence of plasticity may help explain some of the age-related changes in spatial-hearing abilities.

Musical Training and Its Association With Age-Related Changes in Binaural, Temporal, and Spatial Processing.

This article aimed to assess the relationship between musical training and age-related changes in binaural, temporal, and spatial processing abilities. A standard group comparison study was conducted involving both musicians and nonmusicians. The effect of musical training was assessed using a battery of psychoacoustical tests (interaural time and level difference thresholds: ITD & ILD, binaural gap detection threshold, and virtual auditory space identification test) and subjective ratings (Spatial-Hearing subsection of Speech, Spatial, and Quality of Hearing scale in Kannada). A total of 60 participants, between 41 and 70 years, were divided into three groups of 20 each, based on their age (41-50, 51-60, and 61-70 years). Each of these three groups was subdivided into two, one comprising 10 musicians (vocalists practicing South-Indian classical music) and the other comprising 10 nonmusicians. Multivariate analyses of variance revealed that musicians performed significantly better (p < .001) than nonmusicians in all the tests. Analyses of variance showed that whereas age had no effect (p > .05) on performance in any of the tests in musicians, age affected the performance of nonmusicians significantly in terms of ITD (p = .02) and ILD (p = .01) thresholds. Musical training appears to have the potential to slow down age-related decline in binaural, temporal, and spatial processing.

The Effect of Hearing Aids on Sound Localization in Mild Unilateral Conductive Hearing Loss.

Binaural hearing is of utmost importance for communicating in noisy surroundings and localizing the direction of sound. Unilateral hearing loss (UHL) affects the quality of life in both childhood and adulthood, speech development, and academic achievements. Sound amplification using air-conducting hearing aids (HAs) is a common option for hearing rehabilitation of UHL. The processing time of digital HAs can significantly delay the acoustic stimulation in 3 to 10 milliseconds, which is far longer than the maximal natural interaural time difference (ITD) of 750 microseconds. This can further impair spatial localization in these patients. We sought to assess whether HA effects on ITD and interaural level difference (ILD) impair localization among subjects with unilateral conductive hearing loss (UCHL). "Normal"-hearing participants underwent localization testing in different free field settings. Ten volunteers with "normal"-hearing thresholds participated. Repeated assessments were compared between "normal" (binaural) hearing, UCHL induced by insertion of an inactivated HA to the ear canal (conductive HL), and amplification with a HA. In UCHL mode, with HA switched-off, localization was significantly impaired compared to "normal" hearing (NH; η2 = 0.151). Localization error was more pronounced when sound was presented from the front and from the side of the occluded ear. When switched-on, amplification with HAs significantly improved localization for all participants compared to UCHL. Better localization with HAs was seen in high frequencies compared to low frequencies (η2 = 0.08, 0.03). Even with HAs, localization did not reach that of NH (η2 = 0.034). Mild UCHL caused localization to deteriorate. HAs significantly improved sound localization, albeit the delay caused by the device processing time. Most of the improvements were seen in high-frequency sounds, representing a beneficial effect of amplification on ILD. Our results have potential clinical value in situations of mild CHL, for instance, otitis media with effusion.

Two Types of Auditory Spatial Receptive Fields in Different Parts of the Chicken's Midbrain.

The optic tectum (OT) is an avian midbrain structure involved in the integration of visual and auditory stimuli. Studies in the barn owl, an auditory specialist, have shown that spatial auditory information is topographically represented in the OT. Little is known about how auditory space is represented in the midbrain of birds with generalist hearing, i.e., most of avian species lacking peripheral adaptations such as facial ruffs or asymmetric ears. Thus, we conducted in vivo extracellular recordings of single neurons in the OT and in the external portion of the formatio reticularis lateralis (FRLx), a brain structure located between the inferior colliculus (IC) and the OT, in anaesthetized chickens of either sex. We found that most of the auditory spatial receptive fields (aSRFs) were spatially confined both in azimuth and elevation, divided into two main classes: round aSRFs, mainly present in the OT, and annular aSRFs, with a ring-like shape around the interaural axis, mainly present in the FRLx. Our data further indicate that interaural time difference (ITD) and interaural level difference (ILD) play a role in the formation of both aSRF classes. These results suggest that, unlike mammals and owls which have a congruent representation of visual and auditory space in the OT, generalist birds separate the computation of auditory space in two different midbrain structures. We hypothesize that the FRLx-annular aSRFs define the distance of a sound source from the axis of the lateral visual fovea, whereas the OT-round aSRFs are involved in multimodal integration of the stimulus around the lateral fovea.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Previous studies implied that auditory spatial receptive fields (aSRFs) in the midbrain of generalist birds are only confined along azimuth. Interestingly, we found SRFs s in the chicken to be confined along both azimuth and elevation. Moreover, the auditory receptive fields are arranged in a concentric manner around the overlapping interaural and visual axes. These data suggest that in generalist birds, which mainly rely on vision, the auditory system mainly serves to align auditory stimuli with the visual axis, while auditory specialized birds like the barn owl compute sound sources more precisely and integrate sound positions in the multimodal space map of the optic tectum (OT).

Development of synaptic fidelity and action potential robustness at an inhibitory sound localization circuit: effects of otoferlin‐related deafness

Sound localization involves information analysis in the lateral superior olive (LSO), a conspicuous nucleus in the mammalian auditory brainstem. LSO neurons weigh interaural level differences (ILDs) through precise integration of glutamatergic excitation from the cochlear nucleus (CN) and glycinergic inhibition from the medial nucleus of the trapezoid body (MNTB). Sound sources can be localized even during sustained perception, an accomplishment that requires robust neurotransmission. Virtually nothing is known about the sustained performance and the temporal precision of MNTB-LSO inputs after postnatal day (P)12 (time of hearing onset) and whether acoustic experience guides development. Here we performed whole-cell patch-clamp recordings to investigate neurotransmission of single MNTB-LSO fibres upon sustained electrical stimulation (1-200Hz/60s) at P11 and P38 in wild-type (WT) and deaf otoferlin (Otof) knock-out (KO) mice. At P11, WT and KO inputs performed remarkably similarly. In WTs, the performance increased drastically between P11 and P38, e.g. manifested by an 8 to 11-fold higher replenishment rate (RR) of synaptic vesicles and action potential robustness. Together, these changes resulted in reliable and highly precise neurotransmission at frequencies ≤100Hz. In contrast, KO inputs performed similarly at both ages, implying impaired synaptic maturation. Computational modelling confirmed the empirical observations and established a reduced RR per release site for P38 KOs. In conclusion, acoustic experience appears to contribute massively to the development of reliable neurotransmission, thereby forming the basis for effective ILD detection. Collectively, our results provide novel insights into experience-dependent maturation of inhibitory neurotransmission and auditory circuits at the synaptic level. KEY POINTS: Inhibitory glycinergic inputs from the medial nucleus of the trapezoid body (MNTB) to the lateral superior olive (LSO) are involved in sound localization. This brainstem circuit performs reliably throughout life. How such reliability develops is unknown. Here we investigated the role of acoustic experience on the functional maturation of MNTB-LSO inputs at juvenile (postnatal day P11) and young adult ages (P38) employing deaf mice lacking otoferlin (KO). We analysed neurotransmission at single MNTB-LSO fibres in acute brainstem slices employing prolonged high-frequency stimulation (1-200Hz/60s). At P11, KO inputs still performed normally, as manifested by normal synaptic attenuation, fidelity, replenishment rate, temporal precision and action potential robustness. Between P11 and P38, several synaptic parameters increased substantially in wild-type mice, collectively resulting in high-fidelity and temporally precise neurotransmission. In contrast, maturation of synaptic fidelity was largely absent in KOs after P11. Collectively, reliable neurotransmission at inhibitory MNTB-LSO inputs develops under the guidance of acoustic experience.

High-Frequency Hearing Is Required to Compute a Topographic Map of Auditory Space in the Mouse Superior Colliculus.

A topographic map of auditory space is a feature found in the superior colliculus (SC) of many species, including CBA/CaJ mice. In this genetic background, high-frequency monaural spectral cues and interaural level differences (ILDs) are used to compute spatial receptive fields (RFs) that form a topographic map along the azimuth. Unfortunately, C57BL/6 mice, a strain widely used for transgenic manipulation, display age-related hearing loss (AHL) because of an inbred mutation in the Cadherin 23 gene (Cdh23) that affects hair cell mechanotransduction. To overcome this problem, researchers have used young C57BL/6 mice in their studies, as they have been shown to have normal hearing thresholds. However, important details of the auditory response characteristics of the SC such as spectral responses and spatial localization, have not been characterized in young C57BL/6 mice. Here, we show that two- to four-month C57BL/6 mice lack neurons with frontal auditory RFs and therefore lack a topographic representation of auditory space in the SC. Analysis of the spectrotemporal RFs (STRFs) of the SC auditory neurons shows that C57BL/6 mouse SC neurons lack the ability to detect the high-frequency (>40 kHz) spectral cues that are needed to compute frontal RFs. We also show that crossing C57BL/6 mice with CBA/CaJ mice or introducing one copy of the wild-type Cdh23 to C57BL/6 mice rescues the high-frequency hearing deficit and improves the topographic map of auditory space. Taken together, these results demonstrate the importance of high-frequency hearing in computing a topographic map of auditory space.

Sound Source Localization by Cochlear Implant Recipients with Normal Hearing in the Contralateral Ear: Effects of Spectral Content and Duration of Listening Experience

Introduction: Cochlear implant (CI) recipients with normal hearing (NH) in the contralateral ear experience a significant improvement in sound source localization when listening with the CI in combination with their NH-ear (CI + NH) as compared to with the NH-ear alone. The improvement in localization is primarily due to sensitivity to interaural level differences (ILDs). Sensitivity to interaural timing differences (ITDs) may be limited by auditory aging, frequency-to-place mismatches, the signal coding strategy, and duration of CI use. The present report assessed the sensitivity of ILD and ITD cues in CI + NH listeners who were recipients of long electrode arrays that provide minimal frequency-to-place mismatches and were mapped with a coding strategy that presents fine structure cues on apical channels. Methods: Sensitivity to ILDs and ITDs for localization was assessed using broadband noise (BBN), as well as high-pass (HP) and low-pass (LP) filtered noise for adult CI + NH listeners. Stimuli were 200-ms noise bursts presented from 11 speakers spaced evenly over an 180° arc. Performance was quantified in root-mean-squared error and response patterns were analyzed to evaluate the consistency, accuracy, and side bias of the responses. Fifteen listeners completed the task at the 2-year post-activation visit; seven listeners repeated the task at a later annual visit. Results: Performance at the 2-year visit was best with the BBN and HP stimuli and poorer with the LP stimulus. Responses to the BBN and HP stimuli were significantly correlated, consistent with the idea that CI + NH listeners primarily use ILD cues for localization. For the LP stimulus, some listeners responded consistently and accurately and with limited side bias, which may indicate sensitivity to ITD cues. Two of the 7 listeners who repeated the task at a later annual visit experienced a significant improvement in performance with the LP stimulus, which may indicate that sensitivity to ITD cues may improve with long-term CI use. Conclusions: CI recipients with a NH-ear primarily use ILD cues for sound source localization, though some may use ITD cues as well. Sensitivity to ITD cues may improve with long-term CI listening experience.

The changes to interaural acoustics imparted by placing circumaural headphones over bilateral cochlear-implant sound processors

Interaural level differences (ILDs) are the primary binaural cue used by bilateral cochlear-implant (BiCI) listeners for horizontal-plane sound localization. As such, factors affecting their fidelity are important to understand. One approach for delivering binaural stimuli to BiCI listeners is to present virtually spatialized signals via circumaural headphones placed over the listener’s sound processors. An assumption of this approach is that the binaural cues presented are relatively unaltered by the transmission process and headphone placement; yet there is a lack of evidence supporting this assumption. Therefore, this study measured the effect of small changes to headphone placement on the ILDs received by BiCI sound processors. The intent was to determine both the extent and frequency range in which ILDs are affected using recordings of sine-sweeps received by the device microphones. Results show that slight changes in headphone placement affect coupling to the sound processor microphones and outer ear, primarily influencing ILDs between 1 and 5 kHz as much as 8.6 dB at the midline. They also show that occluding the listener’s ear canals with earplugs or moldable putty significantly reduces ILD variability from inconsistent headphone placement. In summary, these data suggest ways to improve this presentation method for BiCI research studies.

A creeping-wave elliptic-head model that explains non-monotonic envelope interaural time differences

Interaural time and level differences (ITDs and ILDs) created by interactions of impinging sound with the head facilitate horizontal-plane sound localization. ILDs are known to be non-monotonic functions of azimuth, resulting in predictable mislocalization of tonal sources at some frequencies, while ITDs are typically construed as monotonic functions of azimuth. However, recent measurements using a binaural mannequin revealed envelope ITDs (ENV-ITDs) that were non-monotonic functions of azimuth, with the extent of nonmonotonicity dependent on carrier frequency. This study proposes that delayed sound traveling around the back of the head causes this phenomenon. ENV-ITDs created by a time-dependent model of incident sound waves propagating around the front and back of an elliptical head were compared to ENV-ITDs computed using publicly available HRTF libraries for a broadband speech excitation signal. Results from the model align with data from the HRTF libraries, with nonmonotonicities in the ENV-ITD-azimuth functions occurring at nearly identical azimuths and frequencies. These data suggest the veracity of this phenomenon and may have implications for spatial hearing abilities. They also suggest that time-independent models of ITDs that only consider frequency and incident angle, such as spherical head or circular arc length models, could be updated to include such time dependence.

Front-back reversals for tones heard in a room by moving listeners

The tone localization experiments reported by Macaulay and Hartmann [J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 149, 4159–4179 (2021)] were highly biased in favor of sources in front of the listener. Nevertheless, listeners sometimes localized tones in back, both when they were stationary and when they were required to move. The experiments provided extensive data relevant to the matter of in-back localization, because they measured head location and orientation as well as ear canal signals throughout each experiment trial. Because the experiments were done in a room, the data were irregular functions of source azimuth. Analysis revealed the following effects: For stationary trials, back responses were strongly correlated with weaker tone levels in the ear canals for 500, 2000, and 4000 Hz. Correlation was greatly reduced at 1000 Hz. That result is consistent with head-related transfer functions, where ear-canal intensity is greater for sounds in front except near 1000 Hz. For moving trials, back responses at 500 and 1000 Hz were strongly correlated with the slopes of interaural level differences and interaural time differences as functions of head-pointing direction, as naturally occur in free field. Correlations decreased dramatically at higher frequencies.

A sex difference and learning in the discrimination of interaural-level differences but not interaural-time differences in naïve listeners

The two primary cues to sound-source location on the horizontal plane are interaural differences in time (ITDs) and in level (ILDs). Here, we asked whether the ability to discriminate small changes in each of these interaural cues differs between the sexes. We tested males and females who had no prior experience with any psychoacoustic task on either ILD discrimination at 4 kHz or ITD discrimination at 0.5 kHz. For ILD discrimination, the overall mean threshold, as well as the threshold for each 50-trial block, was significantly lower for males (n = 80) than for females (n = 166). Both males and females learned over the course of testing, but there was no sex difference in learning rate. In contrast, for ITD discrimination, thresholds did not differ significantly between the sexes for the overall mean or for any block (n = 43M/94F). There also was no learning across blocks for either group. For both tasks, the individual thresholds spanned a wide range in each group. The presence of sex differences and learning for ILD but not ITD discrimination suggests that the factors responsible for these outcomes influenced a relatively peripheral ILD-specific pathway, and not an ITD-specific pathway, or a more central locus that is not cue specific.