Once every generation or so, a major volume has appeared that has made a profound difference in the way both the archaeological profession and the general public thinks about Hopewell in eastern North America. In the 1960s, Caldwell and Hall produced an edited volume entitled Hopewellian Studies that widely introduced the concept of a Hopewell interaction sphere. In the late 1970s, Brose and Greber's Hopewellian Archaeology: The Chillicothe Conference brought together, for the first time, a wealth of case studies from across the continent, defining the full geographic extent of Hopewell. In the mid-1990s two volumes appeared, A View from the Core: A Synthesis of Ohio Hopewell Archaeology, edited by Pacheco, and Ohio Hopewell Community Organization, edited by Dancey and Pacheco, that refined this broad perspective, and simultaneously began to document the settlement systems of the people who created Hopewell, in the heartland and beyond. Two new volumes have just appeared, and are likely to have a similar impact. Syntheses of Hopewell archaeology have been dominated by edited volumes in recent years, replacing an earlier tradition of single-authored works, such as Gerard Fowke's masterful Archaeological History of Ohio ( 1 902) or the overviews of Shetrone ( 1 930) and Thomas (1894), the latter two encompassing sites far beyond Hopewell, but remaining great sources of insight and description about this culture. The two volumes examined here reflect something of a return to the earlier tradition. The Hopewell Episode is the work of one scholar (Byers), while Gathering Hopewell is clearly a team effort, albeit one whose approach was greatly shaped by the theoretical and methodological perspective of one person (Carr). While edited volumes provide varying perspectives, there is a lot to be said for the extensive exploration of a topic using one approach or overarching theoretical framework. These two new volumes do not disappoint in this regard. Gathering Hopewell, edited by Chris Carr and Troy Case, is a book that I predict will, as its message becomes known, have an impact as great as any of the earlier syntheses that have appeared. A superbly written, edited, and illustrated volume, sturdily and attractively produced by the publisher, it is well worth the price. Given that a paperback version is now being released, this volume is readily accessible, and there is no reason why it should not be on the shelf, and its general message in the heads, of anybody serious about North American prehistory. What is the message of this volume? That Hopewell life and practice, in all its richness and complexity, at the local and interregional scale, can be grasped and understood through archaeological research. For what I believe is the first time in American archaeology, a rich sense of hat a prehistoric culture could have been like (and given the analytical effort and evidence, probably was like) is presented in a level of detail and a richness of text comparable to that of the finest ethnographies, differing only in the sources and emphases of its interpretations. This is a scholarly and scientific product, solidly grounded in theory and data, but it is much more, a massive yet integrated constellation of information, ideas, and interpretations that I believe will challenge and inspire researchers interested in Hopewell for decades to come. Gathering Hopewell is dedicated to Stuart Struever,
Read full abstract