ABSTRACT Background This study investigated pupils’ and teachers’ experiences with newbuilt schools. The schools can be characterised as innovative learning environments, designed and built to support the development of a knowledge economy and the learning of twenty-first-century skills. The buildings had a flexible learning space layout and were equipped with modern technology and furniture to fit reformed teacher work practices and pupils’ learning. Purpose The study, which took place in Norway, sought to provide insights into pupils’ and teachers’ perceptions and experiences of their interplay with new physical school environments, following their move to newly built schools. We asked the following research question: How are pupils and teachers in primary and lower secondary school experiencing new school buildings? Method The study was conducted in four primary and secondary schools across Norway. Twelve groups of teachers and pupils (aged 10 to 16) took part in the research across these schools, which adopted a qualitative research design including photovoice – an approach where participants photographed spaces and interiors important to them and then used these to inform group dialogues. Reflexive thematic analysis was used to analyse transcriptions and other qualitative data. Findings Moving into new school buildings was generally a positive experience for study participants, although with some challenges. Participants’ experiences coalesced around three major themes: significant spaces and places; perceived qualities of spaces; and design principles and intentions of spaces and places. Each of these themes contained sub-themes, the most relevant of which were having break-out spaces, flexibility and safety. Break-out rooms offered flexibility to plan for varied education and shelter for sensitive talks. Crowded areas, such as cloakrooms, were perceived as unsafe, while classrooms and the health nurse’s area were perceived as safe. Conclusion While the experiences of teachers and pupils were mostly positive, new learning environments cannot alone operationalise the concept of twenty-first-century skills to create effective learners. There appears to be a mismatch between daily school users’ and planners/architects’ understandings of flexibility.
Read full abstract