Thinning Intensity Research Articles

Thinning intensity and frequency enhance Quercus robur L. growth responses to drought in Southern Sweden

ABSTRACT Drought can impact forests directly causing a decrease of growth, but also increase the vulnerability of trees to secondary pests and pathogens, causing additional loss of volume production. To develop new silvicultural strategies, it is crucial to understand if thinning can promote resilience of the remaining trees to drought by enhancing an efficient use of resources. Given projected drier vegetation periods in Southern Sweden, the aim of the study was to determine how tree growth is affected by severe summer droughts under different thinning regimes. We used an experiment established in 1991 in a 40-year-old pure oak (Quercus robur L.) stand with two thinning intensities and an unthinned control. We collected tree cores before and after specific drought events occurring after treatment. We observed that heavy thinning intensity increased drought resistance, and decreased recovery time and growth reduction when the time since the last intervention was 4–5 years. Our results suggest that heavy and frequent thinning interventions would be an appropriate management alternative to alleviate drought stress in pure oak stands close to the northern edge of their distribution.

Effect of forest thinning on the diversity and composition of macrofungal sporocarps in Pinus uncinata stands

Pine forests represent globally distributed conifers growing in a wide range of habitats within the Mediterranean basin. One example are the high-altitude mountain pine (Pinus uncinata) forests in the Pyrenees, which stand out for their high fungal sporocarps richness. Nevertheless, studies on the effects of forest management on sporocarps diversity in mountain pine forests have been lacking, despite their importance for optimizing multiple-use forestry practices. To address this gap, we analysed the impact of different thinning intensities on fungal sporocarp diversity and composition in P. uncinata stands in the Pyrenees. The experimental design involved a BACI approach used to compare annual sporocarp diversity and composition five years before and three years after the thinning intervention in 18 permanent plots (9 thinned and 9 control). The results indicated an absence of a thinning effect in the lighter thinning intensities (< 25 % of basal area removal) for the sporocarp richness, while negative effects emerged steadily when increasing the thinning intensity until a clear negative effect reported when removing more than 70 % of the basal area. Sporocarp evenness and Shannon index revealed a negative effect due to forest thinning, with a dominance of some species that can cope with the new stand conditions. The ECM sporocarp composition was mainly affected by interannual variability, while the saprotrophic sporocarp composition was mainly driven by site conditions. However, in both guilds, we detected a reduction of the sporocarps fructification in the higher thinning intensities. Our results indicate that lighter thinning intensities do not compromise fungal diversity conservation. Finally, forest management practices that balance timber production and fungal diversity could create opportunities to enhance the ecological, social and economic value of these forest stands, which have historically been managed exclusively for timber purposes.

Rainfall partitioning in the Robinia pseudodcacia plantations with different thinning intensities in the semiarid Loess Plateau of China

Rainfall partitioning in the Robinia pseudodcacia plantations with different thinning intensities in the semiarid Loess Plateau of China

Seasonal shifts in depth-to-water uptake by young thinned and overstocked lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta) forests under drought conditions in the Okanagan Valley, British Columbia, Canada

Abstract. As drought and prolonged water stress become more prevalent in dry regions under climate change, preserving water resources becomes a focal point for maintaining forest health. Forest regeneration after forest loss or disturbance can lead to overstocked juvenile stands with high water demands and low water-use efficiency. Forest thinning is a common practice with the goal of improving tree health, carbon storage, and water use while decreasing stand demands in arid and semi-arid regions. However, little is known about the impacts of stand density on seasonal variation in depth-to-water uptake or the magnitude of the effect of growing season drought conditions on water availability. Existing reports are highly variable by climatic region, species, and thinning intensity. In this study, stable isotope ratios of deuterium (δ2H) and oxygen (δ18O) in water collected from various soil depths and from branches of lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta) under different degrees of thinning (control: 27 000 stems per hectare; moderately thinned: 4500 stems per hectare; heavily thinned: 1100 stems per hectare) over the growing season were analyzed using the MixSIAR Bayesian mixing model to calculate the relative contributions of different water sources in the Okanagan Valley in the interior of British Columbia, Canada. We found that under drought conditions the lodgepole pine trees shifted their depth-to-water uptake through the growing season (June to October) to rely more heavily on older precipitation events that percolated through the soil profile when shallow soil water became less accessible. Decreased forest density subsequent to forest thinning did not cause a significant difference in the isotopic composition of branch water but did cause changes in the timing and relative proportion of water utilized from different depths. Thinned lodgepole pine stands were able to maintain water uptake from 35 cm below the soil profile, whereas the overstocked stands relied on a larger proportion of deep soil water and groundwater towards the end of the growing season. Our results support other findings by indicating that, although lodgepole pines are drought-tolerant and have dimorphic root systems, they do not shift back from deep water sources to shallow soil water when soil water availability increases following precipitation events at the end of the growing season.

Thinning-induced decrease in fine root biomass, but not other fine root traits in global forests

In forest ecosystems, changes in the expression of tree absorptive root traits following management interventions are expected to influence post-thinning forest structure and function. Fine root traits are expected to be especially responsive to forest thinning—one of the most common forest management interventions and the focus of our research here—influencing tree-level responses to environmental change, and thereby contributing to post-thinning stand-level dynamics and ecosystem processes. However, there remains limited understanding surrounding whether or not forest thinning influences the expression of root morphological, chemical, and physiological traits associated with belowground resource acquisition. We conducted a global meta-analysis to evaluate the response of 13 fine root traits to forest thinning. Our study included analysis of 769 paired observations of root traits values pre- and post-thinning, derived from 89 peer-reviewed publications. Our meta-analysis found that forest thinning leads to a decrease in fine root biomass by 11.7% on average, while other root traits including fine root length, root C and N concentrations, root lifespan, and root respiration rates, are largely unresponsive to thinning treatments. Thinning tended to reduce fine root biomass at early stand recovery stages, with increases in fine root biomass being detected at later seral stages, especially in heavy thinning experiments. The effect of thinning on fine root biomass was most pronounced in deeper soil horizons. The influence of thinning on fine root trait expression was not affected by ecosystem or stand type, with the exception of biomass which decreased in temperate and coniferous forests. Our results demonstrate variations of fine root traits to forest management, as well as the importance of stand recovery time and thinning intensity in regulating fine root trait expression in retention trees. These patterns may have strong implications for governing soil carbon stocks in managed forests associated with decreased root inputs into deeper soils. Overall, our findings can enhance our comprehension of how forest management affects fine root trait expression, and relationship between managed forests and belowground ecosystem structure and function.

Evaluation of Physico-Static and Dynamic Elastic Properties of Eucalyptus pellita in Various Thinning Intensities

Acoustic velocity (AV) offers a non-destructive means of reliably measuring wood properties, presenting a valuable alternative to the traditional method known for its destructiveness, costliness, and time consumption. This technique is widely used in the timber industry to predict the bending strength of standing trees and logs. Hence, a study was conducted to assess the dynamic and static elastic properties of Eucalyptus pellita in various thinning intensities using the AV technique and laboratory testing. The selected 11-year-old E. pellita wood was obtained from thinning trials in Sabah Softwood Berhad, Brumas, Sabah. This investigation collected samples from three distinct thinning intensities (0%, 40%, and 60%). Dynamic modulus of elasticity (MOE), which relies on the time of flight (TOF) principle, was measured using an acoustic velocity approach, and physical and static testing was conducted according to standard ISO 13061. Results from this study show that thinning treatments significantly affect the physical and mechanical properties of E. pellita. The study also found that the static modulus of elasticity (MOE) value may be predicted using the acoustic velocity approach, with R2 = 0.46, R2 = 0.60, and R2 = 0.53 on standing trees, billets, and wood slabs, respectively. The application of non-destructive tests in forest plantations can help the foresters assess the wood properties efficiently, and specific parameters can be measured on a tree stand without falling the tree. Besides, thinning at a moderate intensity also helped to enhance the mechanical properties and dynamic MOE value of the E. pellita wood.

Multifunctional Evaluation of Spruce–Fir Forest Based on Different Thinning Intensities

Multifunctional Evaluation of Spruce–Fir Forest Based on Different Thinning Intensities

Response of Fuel Characteristics, Potential Fire Behavior, and Understory Vegetation Diversity to Thinning in Platycladus orientalis Forest in Beijing, China

Objective: Active fuel management operations, such as thinning, can minimize extreme wildfire conditions while preserving ecosystem services, including maintaining understory vegetation diversity. However, the appropriate thinning intensity for balancing the above two objectives has not been sufficiently studied. Methods: This study was conducted to assess the impact of various thinning intensities (light thinning, LT, 15%; moderate thinning, MT, 35%; heavy thinning, HT, 50%; and control treatment, CK) on fuel characteristics, potential fire behavior, and understory vegetation biodiversity in Platycladus orientalis forest in Beijing using a combination of field measurements and fire behavior simulations (BehavePlus 6.0.0). Results: A significant reduction in surface and canopy fuel loads with increasing thinning intensity, notably reducing CBD to below 0.1 kg/m3 under moderate thinning, effectively prevented the occurrence of active crown fires, even under extreme weather conditions. Additionally, moderate thinning enhanced understory species diversity, yielding the highest species diversity index compared to other treatments. Conclusions: These findings suggest that moderate thinning (35%) offers an optimal balance, substantially reducing the occurrence of active crown fires while promoting biodiversity. Therefore, it is recommended to carry out moderate thinning in the study area. Forest managers can leverage this information to devise technical strategies that simultaneously meet fire prevention objectives and enhance understory vegetation species diversity in areas suitable for thinning-only treatments.

A global analysis of the effects of forest thinning on soil N stocks and dynamics

Forest thinning is a critical management measure for changing the forest community structure and improving the soil microclimate and nitrogen (N) cycle. However, differences in forest types, thinning intensity, recovery time, and climate conditions make the accumulation of soil N under forest thinning uncertain; especially the soil N accumulation rate is still lacking. This study systematically discusses the effects of forest thinning on the rate of soil N stock change (RNC) and analyzes the relationship between the RNC and the rate of soil carbon (C) stock change (RCC) by synthesizing 387 global data points. Forest thinning significantly increased the soil N stock, with the RNC being +0.07 Mg/ha yr−1. The RNCs in coniferous and mixed forests (+0.07 and +0.09 Mg/ha yr−1, respectively) were higher than that in broadleaf forest (−0.03 Mg/ha yr−1). Heavy forest thinning inhibited soil N accumulation; however, light forest thinning and long-term recovery were more conducive to improving it. The RNC decreased with increasing precipitation and temperature under forest thinning. Additionally, the RNC was positively correlated with the RCC. Overall, heavy forest thinning decreases the soil N accumulation rate in the global forest ecosystem; conversely, long-term recovery increases it. Reducing the forest thinning intensity and extending the recovery time can accelerate soil N accumulation and thus reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

Effects of Thinning Practices on Soil Properties and Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi in Natural Pure Oriental Beech Forests

Thinning intensities in Fagus orientalis Lipsky. stands may influence the soil properties, arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi symbiosis, and their interaction through soil quality enhancement. We aimed to investigate the impact of four thinning intensities—control (no thinning); moderate (15%), moderately intense (35%), and intense thinning (55%)—implemented five years ago in pure oriental beech forests. In this context, the percentage indicates the proportion of trees removed by each thinning intensity, based on the total number of trees before thinning. Our focus encompassed soil physical–chemical properties, AM fungi community composition, and root colonization. At the intense thinning sites, the soil organic carbon, total nitrogen, available potassium, AMF spore density, and root colonization increased by 209.7, 88.9, 115.8, 404.9, and 448.5%, respectively, when compared to the control sites. This suggests a potential rise in AMF spore density and root colonization—a vital aspect for natural regeneration. These findings highlight the importance of considering management practices in forest systems that can enhance the root system in a sustainable manner to improve plant performance, soil fertility, and symbiosis with AM fungi.

Effects of Growth and Treatment Conditions on the Quality of Norway Spruce (Picea abies L.) Sawn Timber

A study was conducted to improve the effectiveness of silvicultural production of structural sawn timber from softwoods. It intends to explore prediction methods for mechanical timber quality. The study material was obtained from six stands divided into age groups of approximately 40- and 80-year-old trees (examining the influence of age). The stands were differentiated by their applied thinning system of thinning from below or above (examining the influence of the thinning system). Resulting from these different levels of data, i.e., stand parameters, tree anatomy, and visual board properties are examined and analyzed in ordinal logistic models and linear mixed models. Visual board properties were discerned by means of the German standard for visual grading of sawn timber. The mechanical board properties were measured in on-edge bending strength tests and allocated into strength classes, which were modeled in dependence of visual characteristics and forestry conditions. The evaluation of mechanical properties attributed a significant loss of timber quality to short rotation periods, non-ideal water supply, and a single-tree management system. The prediction capabilities of models based on site and tree characteristics were on par with the accuracy of visual grading. Management adaptations by intense thinning from above can lead to a significant decline in Norway spruce (Picea abies L.) timber quality when site factors coincide. Particular care should be taken in the management of locations with high yield potential. Non-destructive evaluation based on site characteristics combined with terrestrial laser scan data of tree characteristics has potential as a pregrading method.

Thinning followed by slash burning enhances growth and reduces vulnerability to drought for Pinus nigra.

Increasingly frequent severe drought events are pushing Mediterranean forests to unprecedented responses. Lack of management leads to dense forests that are highly susceptible to drought stress, potentially resulting in extensive dieback and increased vulnerability to other disturbances. Forest treatments like thinning and slash burning reduce competition for resources and have the potential to enhance tree growth and vigor and minimize tree vulnerability to drought. Here, we used tree rings to study the growth and physiological response of black pine (Pinus nigra) to drought in northeastern Spain under different treatments, including two thinning intensities (light and heavy, with 10% and 40% basal area reduction, respectively) followed by two understory treatments (clearing alone and in combination with slash burning), resulting in a research design of four treatments plus an untreated control with three replicates. Specifically, we studied basal area increment (BAI), resilience indices, and intrinsic water use efficiency (iWUE) using carbon and oxygen isotope composition (δ13C and δ18O in tree-ring cellulose) before and after treatments. Our results showed that BAI and resistance to drought increased in the heavy-thin (burned and unburned) and light-thin burned units. Resilience increased in the burned units regardless of the thinning intensity, while recovery was not affected by treatment. Slash burning additionally increased BAI in the light-thin and resistance and resilience in the heavy-thin units compared with clearing alone. The stable isotope analysis revealed a minor effect of treatments on δ13C and δ18O. No change in iWUE among treatments was presumably linked to a proportional increase in both net CO2 assimilation and stomatal conductance, which particularly increased in the heavy-thin (burned and unburned) and light-thin burned units, indicating that these trees were the least affected by drought. This study shows that management approaches aimed at reducing wildfire hazard can also increase the vigor of dominant trees under drought stress. By reducing competition both from the overstory and the understory, thinning followed by clearing alone or in combination with slash burning promotes tree growth and vigor and increases its resistance and resilience to drought.

Managing both overstory and understory vegetation mitigates the impact of drought on soil nematode communities in a Mediterranean pine forest

Forest management strategies can effectively mitigate the impacts of drought on tree species, but their effects on soil fauna remain largely unexplored. Among soil organisms, soil nematodes can serve as valuable bioindicators to assess the impact of forest management on soil biodiversity and soil functioning. Consequently, we investigated two related questions in a Mediterranean Pinus halepensis Mill. forest located in southeastern France. First, how do soil nematodes respond to forest management practices? Second, can forest management practices help modulate the effects of Mediterranean summer drought on these soil organisms? We conducted a field experiment in which we explored the influence of two forest management techniques—tree thinning (intense, moderate, or absent) and understory removal (shrubs present or absent)—on soil nematodes before and after the summer drought. We found that only total and bacterivorous nematode abundances were positively influenced by the forest management practices. The highest values were observed under conditions of intense thinning combined with shrub presence, with an average of 97,509 individuals per kg of dry soil. In contrast, the abundances of all nematodes, with the exception of predaceous nematodes, were lower after the summer drought with a reduction ranging from −55 % to −82 %. Total, bacterivorous, and fungivorous nematode abundances were less negatively affected by the summer drought under conditions of moderate thinning when shrubs were present versus absent. More generally, we discovered that bacterivorous and fungivorous nematodes were particularly sensitive to the forest management practices and the summer drought. It is thus apparent that habitat alterations induced by forest management can strongly affect nematode community structure and could therefore prompt shifts in ecosystem functioning. Finally, this study highlights that, in forests, understory vegetation can have significant positive impacts on soil nematode populations when severe dry periods occur.

Determinants of carbon sequestration in thinned forests

Given global climate change and the projected increases in the greenhouse effect, enhancing the carbon storage capacity of forest ecosystems is especially critical. To fully realize the potential carbon sequestration, it is imperative to understand the drivers affecting carbon storage in forest ecosystems, particularly with disturbances that disrupt existing balance. In this study, we explored the effects of stem-only harvest at various thinning intensities on forest structure and carbon density in middle-aged natural secondary forests, located in the northern temperate zone. Carbon density included aboveground carbon density (ACD), soil organic carbon stocks (SOCD), and total carbon density (TCD), which was the sum of ACD and SOCD. We employed the random forest analysis method to identify significant variables influencing changes in carbon density. Structural equation modelling (SEM) was then used to determine the drivers of changes in forest carbon density. The results showed that moderate thinning (20 %–35 % trees removed), is an effective management practice for increasing the TCD in forests. Although heavy thinning (35.1 %–59.9 % trees removed) accelerated individual growth, it did not fully offset the carbon removed due to thinning. It is noteworthy that light thinning (0–19.9 % trees removed) not only reduced the species richness but also caused a significant number of tree deaths. Large live trees were an important direct determining factor of ACD, but not the only one. In addition, thinning indirectly influenced ACD by reducing canopy density and deformed tree density. The increase in dead tree density had an adverse impact on SOCD, and this phenomenon increased with the passage of recovery time. Conversely, greater thinning intensity enhanced SOCD. Moreover, TCD was directly influenced by tree height, large live trees, and stand density. Furthermore, thinning altered the conifer ratio, thereby influencing tree growth and indirectly controlling the TCD. We believe that this knowledge will be highly beneficial for successful forest management and enhancing the carbon sequestration capacity of forest ecosystems.

Evaluating effects of silvicultural treatments on forest canopy structure outcomes

Traditional forest management can homogenize forests, and management strategies that can restore complexity and promote adaptive capacity to global change are needed. However, effects of different silvicultural practices on complexity of forest structural components, such as the canopy, are not well understood mechanistically. We conducted a coupled field and simulation-modeling study to evaluate: 1) how near-term effects of silviculture on canopy structure and complexity differ across treatment types, and 2) how outcomes of common silvicultural treatments compare to a spectrum of randomly implemented removals. Thirteen different silvicultural treatments replicated across 12 study plots were simulated within 3D models derived from terrestrial lidar data. Treatment types often differed in their multi-dimensional structural outcomes, including vertical heterogeneity and canopy structural complexity. Moderate intensity thinning treatments that preferentially removed smaller trees increased near-term canopy structural complexity, while diameter-limit cutting often reduced complexity. Silvicultural treatments collectively produced a wide range of residual canopy conditions; however, variability among structural outcomes within individual treatment types or categories was limited relative to the range of possible outcomes from random removals. Most treatments induced shifts in canopy structure outside the spectrum of random removal, suggesting ample space for adapting management to promote forest heterogeneity.

Effect of thinning intensity on the carbon sequestration of natural mixed coniferous and broadleaf forests in Xiaoxing’an Mountains, China

To study the effect of thinning intensity on the carbon sequestration by natural mixed coniferous and broadleaf forests in Xiaoxing’an Mountains, China, we established six 100 m × 100 m experimental plots in Dongfanghong Forest that varied in thinning intensity: plot A (10%), B (15%), C (20%), D (25%), E (30%), F (35%), and the control sample area (0%). A principal component analysis was performed using 50 different variables, including species diversity, soil fertility, litter characteristics, canopy structure parameters, and seedling regeneration parameters. The effects of thinning intensity on carbon sequestration were strongest in plot E (0.75), followed by D (0.63), F (0.50), C (0.48), B (0.22), A (0.11), and the control (0.06). The composite score of plot E was the highest, indicating that the carbon sequestration effect was strongest at a thinning intensity of 30%. These findings provide useful insights that could aid the management of natural mixed coniferous and broadleaf forests in Xiaoxing’an Mountains, China. This information has implications for future studies of these forests, and the methods used could aid future ecological assessments of the natural forests in Xiaoxing’an Mountains, China.

Thinning alters nitrogen transformation processes in subtropical forest soil: Key roles of physicochemical properties

Thinning—a widely used forest management practice—can significantly influence soil nitrogen (N) cycling processes in subtropical forests. However, the effects of different thinning intensities on nitrification, denitrification, and their relationships with soil properties and microbial communities remain poorly understood. Here, we conducted a study in a subtropical forest in China and applied three thinning treatments, i.e., no thinning (0 %), intermediate thinning (10–15 %), and heavy thinning (20–25 %), and investigated the effects of thinning intensity on the potential nitrification rate (PNR), potential denitrification rate (PDR), and microbial communities. Moreover, we explored the relationships among soil physicochemical properties, microbial community structure, and nitrogen transformation rates under different thinning intensities. Our results showed that intermediate and heavy thinning significantly increased the PNR by 87 % and 61 % and decreased the PDR by 31 % and 50 % compared to that of the control, respectively. Although the bacterial community structure was markedly influenced by thinning, the fungal community structure remained stable. Importantly, changes in microbial community composition and diversity had minimal impacts on the nitrogen transformation processes, whereas soil physicochemical properties, such as pH, organic carbon content, and nitrogen forms, were identified as the primary drivers. These findings highlight the critical role of managing soil physicochemical properties to regulate nitrogen transformations in forest soils. Effective forest management should focus on precisely adjusting the thinning intensity to enhance the soil physicochemical conditions, thereby promoting more efficient nitrogen cycling and improving forest ecosystem health in subtropical regions.

Wood decay and Norway spruce vulnerability to wind-inflicted mortality in monospecific and mixed stands in hemiboreal forests

Pathogen-caused stem and root decay are becoming increasingly common in Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) H. Karst) which is believed to contribute to greater stand instability and susceptibility to wind-inflicted damage. Thus, this study aims to assess the effect of root and stem decay on Norway spruce vulnerability to wind-inflicted mortality in monospecific and mixed stands, to widen our base of knowledge on potentially more resilient spruce forest management approaches in hemiboreal forest zone. In this study we used data from: i) the National Forest inventory (NFI), ii) 34 observation plots established in wind-affected stands, iii) two transects (9200 m long, 36.8 ha inspection area combined), iv) and monospecific spruce plantation thinning experiment (five thinning intensities with two repetitions of each) affected by wind. We found that the total mortality of spruce during the NFI four five-year re-measurement cycles (2003–2007, 2008–2012, 2013–2017, 2018–2022) was 2.28 %, during which the main disturbance-causing agents were wind at 0.86 %, pests at 0.41 %, intra/interspecific competition at 0.37 %, and diseases at 0.36 %. NFI data-based multinomial logistic regression model revealed that the probability of wind-inflicted spruce mortality is dictated by soil moisture regime, stand age, stand stocking level, and tree decay presence. Results from the 34 established observation plots show that wood decay is a potential risk factor associated with wind damage occurrence in spruce stands. In a spruce stand, when a group of trees are damaged by wind the proportion of undecayed trees increases. Whereas a single tree is more likely to be attributed to decay caused wind damage.Results point towards deciduous broadleaf admixture having a positive effect on mitigating wind damage among non-decayed spruce trees: however, decayed trees, are more likely to be affected in such stands. The thinning experiment portion of this study suggests that increasingly intensive thinning in monospecific spruce stands will lead to an increasing spread of root and stem decay and thus the risk of wind damage. Therefore, from this perspective, the main goal is to reduce the root and stem decay presence in the stand and thus increase wind stability. We suggest further research to be directed into finding the optimal initial spruce seedlings density with a combination of coniferous and deciduous broadleaf species in order to mitigate root and stem decay presence and wind-inflicted spruce mortality in the forest stands.

Effectiveness of thinning in mitigating post-drought legacy effects on Chinese fir in subtropical plantation forests, Southeastern China

Legacy effects following drought are widely detected across worldwide forests, significantly affecting the growth recovery and susceptibility of trees after droughts. Thinning is a common forest management practice used to alter tree growth and climate-growth relationships. Although the effects of thinning on tree response during drought have been investigated, how thinning modulates post-drought legacy effects remains largely unknown. In this study, based on tree-ring data of 140 trees, we examined the effects of thinning on post-drought legacy effects using the quantile mixed effect model for Chinese fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata) in Southeastern China. The tree-ring data were stratified sampling from a thinning experiment applied 10 years ago in 8-year-old plantations, and included four thinning intensities (20 %, 25 %, 33 %, and 50 % reduction of tree number) and an unthinned control treatment. Drought legacy effects of tree growth positively depended on tree social status with the magnitudes and variations larger in higher status classes. Dominant large trees without thinning management had the greatest drought legacy effects. Although the effects of thinning varied slightly at different quantiles, they all indicated that thinning mitigated the growth legacies after drought and the reduction effect was more pronounced with increasing thinning intensity. Thinning could also reduce post-drought climate sensitivities, but only after moderate thinning (20 % and 25 % thinning intensity). Heavier thinning (33 % and 50 % thinning intensity) instead enhanced tree growth responses to climate changes following drought. Thinning intensity needs to be carefully considered to really reap the post-drought benefits of forest thinning management. Our findings suggested that mild thinning offered an alleviation of climate dependency following drought in addition to reducing drought legacy effects on growth, benefiting tree recovery from drought. The results of this study are useful to inform management adaptive strategies for drought-vulnerable plantations under increasingly frequent droughts.

Contrasting Patterns of Fungal and Bacterial Endophytes Inhabiting Temperate Tree Leaves in Response to Thinning.

The phyllosphere is an important but underestimated habitat for a variety of microorganisms, with limited knowledge about leaf endophytes as a crucial component of the phyllosphere microbiome. In this study, we investigated the mechanisms of communities and co-occurrence networks of leaf endophytes in response to forest thinning in a temperate forest. As we expected, contrasting responses of fungal and bacterial endophytes were observed. Specifically, the diversity of leaf endophytic fungi and the complexity of their co-occurrence networks increased significantly with thinning intensity, whereas the complexity of endophytic bacterial co-occurrence networks decreased. In particular, microbiota inhabiting damaged leaves seem to be more intensively interacting, showing an evident fungi-bacteria trade-off under forest thinning. In damaged leaves, besides the direct effects of thinning, thinning-induced changes in neighbor tree diversity indirectly altered the diversity of leaf fungal and bacterial endophytes via modifying leaf functional traits such as leaf dry matter content and specific leaf area. These findings provide new experimental evidence for the trade-offs between leaf endophytic fungi and bacteria under the different magnitudes of deforestation, highlighting their dependence on the presence or absence of leaf damage.