Due to the sensitivity and potential embarrassment of discussing erectile dysfunction (ED) in person, men are seeking treatment online. We sought to compare offerings of direct-to-consumer (DTC) platforms for ED treatment with respect to consultation, pricing, services, and privacy policy. Google was queried to identify DTC platforms offering ED treatment with the keywords: "telehealth erectile dysfunction," "telemedicine erectile dysfunction," and "online erectile dysfunction." Inclusion criteria were as follows: serving a majority of U.S. states, existing online only, providing both the consultation and prescription for phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitors, and delivering the prescription to the patient. Fifteen DTC platforms met criteria. Ten provided free consultations; 4 bundled the consultation fee with the first month of the prescription, with 1 of these functioning as a subscription service. Fourteen (93%) relied on online intake forms and 10 (67%) advertised review by the prescriber within 2 business days. Only 4 (27%) platforms explicitly advertised physician-only consults. Direct contact with the prescriber would only occur if needed or if required by state law at 8 (53%) platforms. Purchasing sildenafil and tadalafil was advertised on all platforms. Minimum prices of sildenafil ranged from $0.50 to $35/pill (mean $5.16/pill, median $2.65/pill); tadalafil ranged from $0.50 to $9.80/pill (mean $4.70/pill, median $3.21/pill). In addition to ED therapy, 13 (86%) platforms offered treatment for other men's health issues. All platforms included a website privacy policy, but only 10 (67%) mentioned Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act compliance, with 2 of these claiming to not be covered entities. Although DTC platforms are transparent with phosphodiesterase type 5 inhibitor medication and subscription pricing information, few offer direct contact with a physician to further discuss issues related to ED after completion of the online intake form. For comprehensive evaluation of ED in Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act-compliant settings, in-person or telemedicine visits should be arranged with men's physicians.