Click to increase image sizeClick to decrease image size NotesA problem is defined as a statement (or any other form of expression) recognizing a state of disharmonious adjustment between two or more dependent and interrelated variables. For example, when production of foodstuffs exceeds the consumption, the two variables lack harmony of adjustment and a “surplus food” problem arises. Conversely, a “food shortage” problem may arise.An issue is defined as a debated or controversial point in which the primary consideration involved is a question of the relative desirability of two or more alternatives, each of which may be supported by definite facts as well as by personal opinions.Perhaps the outstanding example of trend projection is to be found in the report of the President’s Research Committee on Social Trends, Recent Social Trends and its supplementary monographs. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1933, two volumes.John A. Hockett, A Determination of the Major Social Problems of American Life (New York: Teachers College, Columbia University, 1927), vi + 101 pages.Baldwin Lee, Issues in the Social Studies (New York: Teachers College, Columbia University, 1928), viii +191 pages.Irving R. Melbo, Graduating High School Seniors’ Information on Contemporary Social, Political, and Economic Problems and Issues. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of California, Berkeley, 1934.A somewhat similar suggestion has been made by A. K. Loomis, “Should Contemporary Life Be Studied in High Schools?”, The Nations Schools, February 1934.Irving R. Melbo, op. cit. One of the major findings of this study was that the correlations between the amount of information on contemporary problems and issues and the amount of social-studies instruction taken indicate an almost complete lack of relationship. The correlations ranged from 26, P.E.r ± .04 to — 13, P.E.r ± .04. In a number of instances the P.E.r equaled or exceeded r. Expressed in other terms, students who had taken ten or more semesters of social-studies instruction during their four years of high school were no more likely to have information on contemporary problems and issues than those students who had taken only one or two semesters.Ros s L. Finney, A Sociological Philosophy of Education (New York: The Macmillan Company, 1928), p. 40.A brief discussion of some of the instructional problems involved can be found in: Irving R. Melbo, “Teaching and Studying Contemporary Problems and Issues,” California Journal of Secondary Education, January 1935, pp. 97–100.
Read full abstract