There is a lot to admire in this paper and I congratulate the authors in using experiment and CFD to contribute to the understanding of a complicated phenomenon. Once a flow becomes nonuniform, as it does for the flow described here, there a many more degrees of freedom and the flow can establish itself in many different ways. In consequence, flow that is stalled (in the sense that this takes for rotating stall in compressors) can exhibit many different arrangements. I would like to suggest that the rotating disturbance found here is a particular type of rotating stall corresponding to the special circumstances of an isolated rotor with large tip clearance. The problem that I have with this paper and with others that have come from Germany over the last few years is the term “rotating instability.” One of the useful conclusions from the present paper, referred to in the section “What We Learned” is that the flow is actually very stable. In fact, a condition of instability is very hard to observe, since it is by its very nature transient: A pencil standing vertically on its point is in a condition of instability, but the moment it is microscopically perturbed it ceases to be in the state of instability but is falling toward its new stable condition. The compressor will similarly be unstable at the instant before it moves from being unstalled to being in rotating stall; similarly, for a compressor in rotating stall, there will be an instantaneous condition of instability as the throttle is opened and it moves from stalled to unstalled. The stalled condition, however, is normally very stable. I have been told that the term “rotating instability” is well established and it is implied by this that it should remain in circulation. The term gained currency in Germany a few years ago to describe the type of rotating disturbance described in this paper. It was an unfortunate choice then and remains unfortunate now. It is a widely recognized feature of the English language that words can be created, adapted, and re-used to suit needs. One of the most famous of English quotations is “What’s in a name? that which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet” (Romeo and Juliet: Shakespeare). While accepting the spirit of this quotation, it is also true that it would be confusing to refer to a rose using the word “thorn,” or even the word “garlic.” Put another way, if we want to choose a new use for a word, we should make sure that it does not have a prior meaning that could be confusing, by implying properties that do not apply. Such is the case for “rotating instability,” which strictly has no clear meaning, but which implies a special condition that is inconsistent with the stable behavior of the rotating stall flow pattern that is the subject of this paper.