Background: We present a case of a young female with no pre-existent conditions, who presented to the hospital one month after a mild COVID-19 infection with severe myocarditis complicated by cardiogenic shock. Case: A 40-year-old female with no prior medical history and a regular, vigorous exercise program developed a mild COVID-19 infection with symptoms of mild fatigue, myalgias, chills, fever, and loss of taste, which resolved within a week. A month later, she presented to the hospital with exertional dyspnea, weakness, chest pressure, abdominal pain, and fatigue. A transthoracic echocardiogram revealed a left ventricular ejection fraction of 15% with a severely dilated left ventricle, global hypokinesis and severe mitral regurgitation. Right heart catheterization demonstrated cardiogenic shock with a cardiac index of 1.4 liters per minute by Fick equation, and she was admitted to the cardiac intensive care unit. Cardiac magnetic resonance revealed subepicardial delayed enhancement along the lateral and inferolateral walls and elevated T1 mapping consistent with myocarditis. A right ventricle biopsy revealed myocyte hypertrophy and patchy interstitial fibrosis without evidence of inflammatory tissue. She was diuresed, supported with inotropic therapy, and empirically treated with high doses of glucocorticoids. She clinically improved with weaning of inotropes and was discharged in stable condition on goal-directed medical therapy after 2.5 weeks. Conclusion: This patient represents a case of severe cardiogenic shock, after initial infection and in the absence of previously identified risk factors for development of COVID myocarditis. The absence of inflammatory tissue on pathology raises questions regarding the centrality of inflammatory processes in COVID-19-related myocardial injury leading to “long COVID” syndrome. These findings indicate the need for ongoing investigation of the long-term cardiovascular consequences of COVID-19.