ABSTRACT Background: Inferior oblique muscle overaction (IOOA) is a prevalent ocular muscle motility disorder. This study aimed to investigate the outcomes and impact of IO muscle myectomy with and without tucking the proximal end of the muscle into Tenon’s capsule in two surgical groups as a treatment for IOOA. Methods: Randomized cohort study that involves two surgical groups. A total of 33 patients (55 eyes). Patients were randomly divided into two groups: first group underwent myectomy without tucking the proximal end of the muscle, whereas the second group underwent myectomy with tucking of the proximal end of the muscle. Each patient had four visits. During each visit, each patient had a comprehensive ophthalmic examination. Surgical success was defined as IOOA grade range of 0 to + 1 and correction of hypertropia in primary gaze. Results: The median age was 6 years. Sixteen (48.5%) patients underwent IO muscle myectomy with tucking, while 17 (51.5%) had an IO myectomy without tucking. Both the tucking and without tucking groups showed reductions in the angles of deviations, but there was no significant difference between the groups at baseline or postoperatively at 6 months. The success rate was 92.85% for the tucking group and 92.59% for the without tucking group. Conclusion: The study suggests that both surgical techniques are effective in correcting IOOA and associated HT, without any clear benefits of the addition of tucking. Ultimately, the two surgical techniques are equally effective, and the choice of surgical technique remains a personal preference of the surgeon.