Abstract Background Despite their public health importance, a consensus definition for lower respiratory tract disease (LRTD), or illness (LRTI) is lacking. Clinical trials of three respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) vaccines for older adults used different LRTI/LRTD definitions for vaccine efficacy (VE). We hypothesize differences between definitions could bias product comparisons.Table 1.Variation of signs or symptoms included in criteria to meet case definition of LRTI or LRTD in three RSV vaccine clinical trials Methods We reviewed case definitions for LRTI/LRTD in RSV vaccine clinical trials conducted in older adults.Table 2.Specified values for symptoms/signs included in LRTI/LRTD criteria definitions for three RSV vaccine clinical trials Results Two of three published RSV vaccine clinical trials from Pfizer and Moderna used two outcomes (LRTI/LRTD with ≥2 signs/symptoms or ≥3 signs/symptoms) to measure VE, while the third trial from GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) used one (combining ≥2 and ≥3 signs/symptoms) (Table 1). The Pfizer trial included 5 signs/symptoms as components of LRTI; three of these (tachypnea, wheezing, shortness of breath) suggest lower airway involvement and two (cough and self-reported sputum production) could also result from upper airway infection. At interim analysis, 29 of 45 cases had only 2 symptoms (64.4%). Of these 29, 25 had only cough and sputum production (86.2%). The GSK trial, by contrast, required all LRTD cases to include at least one sign, all of which indicated lower airway involvement (Table 2). The Moderna trial included 10 signs/symptoms, including the potential for subjects to have only cough and sputum production. Even within signs/symptoms, definitions differed (e.g., tachypnea cutoff ranged from 20 to 25 breaths per minute; Table 2). When using comparable definitions, full season 1 VEs for Pfizer and GSK products were similar while the point estimate for the Pfizer product was higher during season 2 (Table 3).Table 3.Vaccine efficacy for three RSV vaccine clinical trials using study LRTI/LRTD definitions Conclusion Lack of standard case definitions limit ability to compare results across trials. Some ≥2 LRTI events for Pfizer and Moderna may not have involved the lower respiratory tract but rather the upper respiratory tract only. The most comparable case definitions likely are ≥3 signs/symptoms LRTI in the Pfizer and Moderna trials, and LRTD in the GSK trial. Disclosures Sarah E. Williams, MD, MPH, Pfizer, Inc: Salary|Pfizer, Inc: Stocks/Bonds (Private Company) Elizabeth Begier, MD, M.P.H., Pfizer Vaccines: Employee|Pfizer Vaccines: Stocks/Bonds (Private Company) Kumar Ilangovan, MD, MSPH, MMCi, Pfizer, Inc.: salary|Pfizer, Inc.: Stocks/Bonds (Public Company) Cassandra Hall-Murray, PharmD, Pfizer, Inc.: employee|Pfizer, Inc.: Stocks/Bonds (Public Company) Bradford D. Gessner, M.D., M.P.H., Pfizer: Employee|Pfizer: Stocks/Bonds (Public Company)
Read full abstract