Studies of patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) have shown that aspects of language ability degeneration are associated with left hippocampal abnormalities[l], and in vivo studies of the normal human brain have demonstrated that the left hippocampus is active in some aspects of linguistic processing[2]. The aim of the present study was to investigate the relationship between performance on a battery of language tests involving object and word recognition and matching and hippocampal integrity as measured by T2 mapping in a cohort of patients with intractable TLE. Methods Forty three patients with TLE were divided into three groups according to hippocampal volume estimates obtained by using the Calvalieri method in combination with point counting on 3D Tl-weighted MR images. The 95th centiles of hippocampal volumes obtained by an identical approach in 35 controls provided normal limits for detection of medial temporal sclerosis (MTS). By this criterion, 15, 9, and 19 patients were assigned to left MTS, right MTS and no MTS respectively. T2 mapping of the anterior hippocampus was performed on all patients as a measure of hippocampal gliosis. A battery of computerised object matching, semantic matching and word-object matching tasks was used to assess specific aspects of language ability. The tasks required patients to match one of two source items with a target item based on object orientation, context and meaning. The computer automatically recorded accuracy and reaction times (RT). Results There were no overall differences between groups of patients on any of the language tasks. There were, however, significant correlations between anterior hippocampal T2 and aspects of language performance for the non MTS, but not the left and right MTS groups. In particular, for the no MTS group, there were significant positive correlations between left hippocampal T2 and mean RT on tests of object (.673, p=O.O02) and semantic matching (.496, p=O.O3), and corresponding correlations for sub-components of the word-object recognition test ranged from ,483 (p=O.O4) to ,676 (p=O.O03). Also, there was a significant negative correlation between right anterior hippocampal T2, (-531, p=O.O2; -.501, p=O.O4) and word-object matching. Discussion The results indicate that increased T2 relaxation time of left hippocampal tissue is related to language ability degeneration in the no MTS group. This concurs with the lateralisation evidence indicating that left hemispheric structures mediate linguistic processing, and that the hippocampus plays a role in this. The finding that these associations emerged only for the no MTS group may reflect the fact that T2 relaxation time is a reliable indicator of cognitive ability only for non-atrophied hippocampal tissue.
Read full abstract