Lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush Walbaum, 1792) forages across macrohabitats (offshore vs nearshore) that likely pose different challenges to the visual system. We examined how differential foraging between macrohabitats challenges the visual system by sampling lake trout from four lakes with differing food web structures (e.g., presence/absence of cisco/smallmouth bass) and evaluating the association between nearshore energy use and visual traits. We found that lake trout foraging more nearshore had relatively larger eyes (corrected for body size) and larger optic tectum size only in lakes with the large pelagic cisco prey absent, while there was no association with these visual traits when cisco was present. Eye shape was not influenced by nearshore foraging. Our results suggest that nearshore foraging challenges the visual system more than offshore foraging but that this may be dependent on important food web structural attributes.