It has been demonstrated that patients with multiple gestations not only have higher implantation rates than patients with singleton gestation, but also have a lower rate of vanishing fetal sacs. Based on these observations the existence of the highly fertile individuals, whose embryos implant with higher efficiency than women with single gestation was postulated. We undertook a study to confirm these findings on a larger sample of patients and further investigate whether this phenomenon holds true for all patient age groups. Retrospective study We retrospectively analyzed 2 groups of IVF-ICSI patients: 1) 528 cycles resulting in multiple pregnancies and 2) 599 cycles resulting in singleton clinical pregnancies, defined as the presence of at least 1 gestational sac at a 5 weeks gestation transvaginal ultrasound. The groups were then subdivided into 3 subgroups: a) < 35 years old; b) 35–37 years old and c) > 37 years old. When the number of viable gestational sacs detected by a subsequent ultrasound exam was lower than the initial one, the number of vanishing embryos was registered. Mann-Whitney test, Fisher's exact test and unpaired t test were used as indicated for statistical analysis. Multiple pregnancies correlated strongly with higher implantation rates. Analyzing all the groups together, there was significant difference for both clinical miscarriage rates in the multiple pregnancy versus the single pregnancy group (10% vs 32.9%, p<0.0001, respectively) and the percentage of lost sacs (24.9% vs 32.9%, p=0.0003, respectively). For young patients (< 35 years old), however, in spite of significant difference in miscarriage rates between multiple vs singleton pregnancy groups (8.3% vs 25.4%, p<0.0001, respectively), interestingly, the percentage of lost sacs was virtually the same (22.9% vs 25.4%, p=0.364, respectively). This was not the case for older patients (group b and c), in whom there was significant difference for both clinical miscarriage rates and percentage of lost sacs between multiple and singleton pregnancies (data not shown). Our data clearly show that, for the younger group, patients with lower implantation rates present the same chance of spontaneous embryo reduction as do patients with high implantation rates. The lower miscarriage rate observed for multiple pregnancies (8.3%) in that group was thus a direct consequence of a higher initial number of implanted embryos. Therefore, intrinsic embryonic factors that could theoretically influence both implantation and post-implantation development potential are not a plausible explanation to our findings. Thus, we must consider that, at least for younger patients, there are other post-implantation factors, whether metabolic, immunological, hormonal or uterine, that certainly influence the development potential of a given embryo.
Read full abstract