IN A foregoing communication (Black and Walter, 1965) the probabilistic relation between stimulus association and anterior brain responses has been demonstrated. In particular (Walter, 1965), the development of the Contingent Negative Variation or “Expectancy Wave” has been found to follow very closely alterations in the significance of conditional stimuli, whether objective or subjectively manipulated by direct suggestion under hypnosis. While these experiments were in progress similar observations were being made on a large number of normal subjects and patients in order to ascertain the origin of the E-wave and its relation to physical and mental activity. Altogether, over 600 complete polygraphic records have been obtained from 320 people, including 190 children. In the early series of experiments the sensory stimuli were essentially “physiological” in the sense that they were fairly loud clicks or bright flashes of light, with no intrinsic meaning or interest. The “significance” of the conditional or warning stimuli was acquired by repeated experience of their association with the unconditional or imperative stimuli to which the subject had been instructed to respond by an operant action such as pressing a button. The circuit arrangements were such that this action would terminate the imperative stimuli only if the action were deferred until their onset; if the subject “jumped the gun” the operant action was ineffective. The inclusion of some action by the subject is an essential condition for the development and maintenance of the E-wave, which can persist through thousands of trials as long as the subject retains his interest. The abbreviation of the motor reaction time when the E-wave appears suggested that the cortical state is modified by the change of potential so as to defer the response until the correct moment, but accelerate its development when triggered by the arrival of the imperative signal. However, several chance observations during the early experiments indicated that although some response was necessary this did not have to be a simple motor action; in several subjects a purely mental event, amounting to a simple decision, was adequate to sustain an E-wave. The procedure was accordingly modified to permit the study of responses to stimuli intended to evoke a change in mental rather than motor state. At the same time it was also observed that the amplitude of the stimuli could be reduced to threshold level without affecting the E-wave, provided, again, that the subject maintained his interest and engagement. Even “negative” stimuli, that is the termination of a tone or light, were found to be adequate to evoke an E-wave when such an event was assigned conditional significance by association. In such conditions the primary responses in non-specific frontal regions are often small and long delayed but the subsequent E-wave is as large as when the stimuli are maximal. These observations corroborated the conclusion drawn from the early experiments, that the E-wave reflects only the subjective estimation of significance. Experiments were therefore made to analyse the brain responses to purely semantic stimuli in which the intrinsic significance or “amount of information” could be varied with only trivial
Read full abstract