Warped disk galaxies are classified into two morphologies: S and U types. Conventional theories routinely attribute both types to galactic tidal interaction and/or gas accretion, but reproducing U types in simulations is extremely challenging. Here we investigate whether both types are governed by the same mechanisms using the most extensive sample of ∼8000 nearby (0.02 < z < 0.06) massive (M */M ⊙ > 109) edge-on disks from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. We find that U types show on average bluer optical colors and a higher specific star formation rate (sSFR) than S types, with more strongly warped U types having a higher sSFR. We also find that while the S-type warp properties correlate with the tidal force by the nearest neighbor regardless of the environment, there is no such correlation for U types in groups/clusters, suggesting a nontidal mechanism could be at play for U types, such as ram pressure stripping (RPS). Indeed, U types are more common in groups/clusters than in fields and they have stellar mass, gas fraction, sSFR enhancement, and phase-space distribution closely analogous to RPS-induced jellyfish galaxies in clusters. We furthermore show that the stellar disks of most RPS galaxies in the IllustrisTNG simulation are warped in a U shape and bent in the opposite direction of stripped gas tails, satisfying theoretical expectations for stellar warps embedded in jellyfishes. We therefore suggest that despite the majority of U types that live in fields being still less explained, RPS can be an alternative origin for those in groups/clusters.
Read full abstract