The 'Constitutional Conduct Group' of India is a forum of former government officials who have written open letters commenting on the policies of the Narendra Modi administration. On the 10th of January 2020 the group published an open letter on the burning issue of government policy with regards to identity management: Citizenship Amendment Act, National Population Register and National Register of Indian Citizens. Comments on the Open Letter are published here in an annotated version. Our main concern with the Open Letter is that the Conduct Group does not offer an alternative, comprehensive policy, but just suggests targeting some symptoms. Over the past decade India has followed a highly unorthodox identity management path. In stead of addressing foundational weaknesses in its idm systems it has focussed on Aadhaar which ignores citizenship, kicking the can down the road for civil registration and its natural and orthodox culmination in a national population register (including people's citizenship status, NRIC in India). By joining protests re (the conflated) 'CAA-NPR-NRIC', the Conduct Group shows it suggests kicking the can down the road some more. That won't put the genie back into the bottle. (To view comments download PDF, open comments list and expand comment where needed.)