Shore ice is a common feature on cold climate coasts, which are abundant in mid- and high-latitude regions, however it is understudied. Previous research has reported both beach protection and erosion as potential impacts from shore ice presence. Altered ice dynamics resulting from a changing climate are likely to intensify these impacts. To address this discrepancy and improve future coastal change predictions we conducted the first combined field, laboratory and modeling study of shore-ice processes and impacts. Beach and nearshore morphology mapping, experiments with a novel cryogenic wave tank, and 3D coastal evolution modeling revealed that shore ice protected the beach from storms, but scoured the nearshore at the ice edge and transported sediment offshore, likely past the depth of closure. This resulted in enhanced beach erosion during the ice-free and non-storm season, countering the protective benefit from the ice. This study indicates that shore ice plays an important and likely evolving role in geomorphic evolution along cold climate coasts.