IBEX Ribbon Research Articles

Determining the IBEX Ribbon Transverse Profile from ENA Temporal Variations: A Proof of Concept for IMAP Observations

Since its discovery in 2009, the IBEX energetic neutral atom (ENA) Ribbon has been a subject of numerous studies. It appears at energies ∼0.5–6 keV and is most pronounced at ∼1–3 keV. It is almost circular, ∼20°–40° wide, and its center lies near the pristine local interstellar magnetic field direction, whose field lines are draped around the heliosphere. The Ribbon intensity is enhanced above the more diffuse, globally distributed flux (GDF) and varies on timescales that are delayed compared to the underlying and slowly varying GDF. We present a novel method to infer the Ribbon boundaries and transverse profile of the Ribbon using sequential time variations of ENA fluxes, with minimal modeling assumptions involved. The method utilizes the difference in temporal evolution between the total Ribbon content and GDF fluxes. We then use the inferred Ribbon transverse profile to statistically quantify the GDF contribution to the observed peak Ribbon intensity to be ∼32.23% ± 3.15% in 2009–2011. This Ribbon separation method works best during times of gradual changes in solar wind output, and with high angular resolution and ENA counting statistics; results thus provide a proof of concept for the upcoming Interstellar Mapping and Acceleration Probe ENA measurements.

Unified Picture of the Local Interstellar Magnetic Field from Voyager and IBEX

Prior to the Voyagers’ heliopause crossings, models and the community expected the magnetic field to show major rotations across the boundary. Surprisingly, the field showed no significant change in direction from the heliospheric Parker Spiral at either Voyager location. Meanwhile, a major result from the IBEX mission is the derived magnitude and direction of the interstellar field far from the Sun (∼1000 au) beyond the influence of the heliosphere. Using a self-consistent model fit to IBEX ribbon data, Zirnstein et al. reported that this “pristine” local interstellar magnetic field has a magnitude of 0.293 nT and direction of 227° in ecliptic longitude and 34.°6 in ecliptic latitude. These values differ by 27% (51%) and 44° (12°) from what Voyager 1 (2) currently observes (as of ∼2022.75). While differences are to be expected as the field undrapes away from the heliosphere, the global structure of the draping across hundreds of astronimcal units has not been reconciled. This leads to several questions: How are these distinct sets of observations reconcilable? What is the interstellar magnetic field’s large-scale structure? How far out would a future mission need to go to sample the unperturbed field? Here, we show that if realistic errors are included for the difficult-to-calibrate radial field component, the measured transverse field is consistent with that predicted by IBEX, allowing us to answer these questions through a unified picture of the behavior of the local interstellar magnetic field from its draping around the heliopause to its unfolding into the pristine interstellar medium.

Heliospheric effects caused by Sun-originating versus LISM-advected fluctuations

Context. We investigate the response of the heliosphere to fluctuations in the local interstellar medium (LISM) as compared to the influence of solar-cycle fluctuations. Aims. We discuss the differences between effects coming from the two types of drivers of time-dependent effects in the heliosphere in the context of the shape of the heliosphere, the thickness of the inner heliosheath, and the position of the ribbon of enhanced energetic neutral particle emission, as observed by the IBEX mission. Methods. Our study is based on a comparison of fully time-dependent simulations obtained with a three-dimensional (3D) model of the heliosphere. Results. We show that density fluctuations, taking the form of entropy waves and originating from the LISM, may reduce the thickness of the inner heliosheath to a similar extent as the solar-cycle effects. However, the relative motions of the termination shock and the heliopause in the two types of simulations are different. The amplitude of variation of the heliopause position is greater for the LISM fluctuation. The IBEX ribbon position is shown to be not significantly affected by the two types of drivers, although the effect of LISM fluctuation is stronger than that of the solar cycle. In this context, slight systematic changes of the position of the IBEX ribbon in its different sectors (i.e., changes in the heliospheric nose followed by variations in the heliospheric flanks) may serve as an indicator of the passage of a density fluctuation in the LISM, as suggested by our study. We also discuss the difficulties in fitting the LISM parameters in the presence of time-dependent effects.

Dependence of the IBEX Ribbon Geometry on Pitch-Angle Scattering outside the Heliopause

Abstract Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX) observations of the “ribbon” of enhanced energetic neutral atom (ENA) fluxes show that it is a persistent feature that approximately forms a circle in the sky, likely formed from secondary ENAs whose source lies outside the heliopause. The IBEX ribbon's geometry (radius and center) depends on ENA energy and is believed to be influenced by the draping of the ISMF and the latitudinal structure of the SW. In this study, we demonstrate that the ribbon's geometry also depends on the pitch-angle scattering rate of ions outside the heliopause, which we simulate under strong and weak-scattering limits. The ribbon radius in the weak-scattering model is ∼4° larger than IBEX observations at most energies, and the strong-scattering model produces radii statistically consistent with IBEX at 1.1–2.7 keV. The simulated ribbon center is shifted between ∼2° and 5° along the B–V plane away from the IBEX center for the weak and strong limits, respectively, suggesting that the pristine ISMF far from the heliosphere is shifted ∼2°–5° away from our simulated ISMF toward the VLISM inflow direction. However, the magnitude needs to be decreased from ∼3 to 2 μG for the weak-scattering model to be consistent with the IBEX ribbon radius, which seems unlikely. We also find that the presence of interstellar He does not significantly affect the ribbon in the strong-scattering limit but yields weaker agreement with data in the weak limit. Our results slightly favor the strong-scattering limit for the ribbon's origin.

Erratum: “A New Model for the Heliosphere's ‘IBEX Ribbon’” (2017, ApJL, 812, L9)

Erratum: “A New Model for the Heliosphere's ‘IBEX Ribbon’” (2017, ApJL, 812, L9)

An Empirical Model of Energetic Neutral Atom Imaging of the Heliosphere and Its Implications for Future Heliospheric Missions at Great Heliocentric Distances

Abstract Several concepts for heliospheric missions operating at heliocentric distances far beyond Earth orbit are currently investigated by the scientific community. The mission concept of the Interstellar Probe, e.g., aims at reaching a distance of 1000 au away from the Sun within this century. This would allow the coming generation to obtain a global view of our heliosphere from an outside vantage point by measuring the energetic neutral atoms (ENAs) originating from the various plasma regions. It would also allow for direct sampling of the unperturbed interstellar medium, as well as for many observation opportunities beyond heliospheric science, such as visits to Kuiper Belt objects, a comprehensive view on the interplanetary dust populations, and infrared astronomy free from the foreground emission of the zodiacal cloud. In this study, we present a simple empirical model of ENAs from the heliosphere and derive basic requirements for ENA instrumentation on board a spacecraft at great heliocentric distances. We consider the full energy range of heliospheric ENAs from 10 eV to 100 keV because each part of the energy spectrum has its own merits for heliospheric science. To cover the full ENA energy range, two or three different ENA instruments are needed. Thanks to parallax observations, some insights about the nature of the IBEX ribbon and the dimensions of the heliosphere can already be gained by ENA imaging from a few au heliocentric distance. To directly reveal the global shape of the heliosphere, measurements from outside the heliosphere are, of course, the best option.

Magnetically-Aligned Interstellar Dust Grains at the Heliosphere

Light from nearby stars becomes linearly polarized while traversing a dichroic interstellar medium. Polarization data which reveal heliosphere features are summarized. Polarizing dust grains trace a magnetic field direction consistent with the field affecting the warm breeze of secondary interstellar helium found by IBEX. Polarization data also trace the field direction that dominates the configuration of the IBEX ribbon of energetic neutral atoms (ENA). The polarizations that echo heliospheric features appear to arise from magnetically-aligned submicron interstellar dust grains that are excluded from the inner heliosphere by large charge-to-mass ratios, but, due to long collision times, retain their alignment with respect to the interstellar magnetic field draping over the heliosphere.

The IBEX Ribbon and the Thickness of the Inner Heliosheath

Abstract The dominant feature in global images of 1 keV heliospheric energetic neutral atom (ENA) emissions is the Interstellar Boundary Explorer Ribbon. Several mechanisms have been proposed for creating the Ribbon, including the so-called secondary ENA mechanism. Neutral solar wind that is generated inside the heliosphere through charge exchange with interstellar gas penetrates unimpeded into the outer heliosheath. Pickup ions are generated there, followed by a third charge exchange that forms 1 keV neutrals, which re-enter the heliosphere. The Ribbon is also observed at other energies, up to 6 keV and down to 0.2 keV, and thus far there has been little consideration of their sources. In the secondary ENA process, 0.2 keV ENAs originate from 0.2 keV ions in the inner heliosheath. Thus, the ratio of the Ribbon ENA flux at 0.2 and at 1 keV provides information on the sources of the original ion populations and ultimately on the relative sizes of the heliosphere and inner heliosheath. A simple one-dimensional model is constructed and a data-model comparison demonstrates how the different source regions of the Ribbon are exploited to estimate the thickness of the inner heliosheath in the direction of the Ribbon.

Erratum: “The Energy-dependent Position of the IBEX Ribbon due to the Solar Wind Structure” (2016, ApJ 827, 71)

Erratum: “The Energy-dependent Position of the IBEX Ribbon due to the Solar Wind Structure” (2016, ApJ 827, 71)

Interstellar Mapping and Acceleration Probe (IMAP)

Our piece of cosmic real estate, the heliosphere, is the domain of all human existence – an astrophysical case history of the successful evolution of life in a habitable system. By exploring our global heliosphere and its myriad interactions, we develop key physical knowledge of the interstellar interactions that influence exoplanetary habitability as well as the distant history and destiny of our solar system and world. IBEX is the first mission to explore the global heliosphere and in concert with Voyager 1 and Voyager 2 is discovering a fundamentally new and uncharted physical domain of the outer heliosphere. In parallel, Cassini/INCA maps the global heliosphere at energies (∼5-55 keV) above those measured by IBEX. The enigmatic IBEX ribbon and the INCA belt were unanticipated discoveries demonstrating that much of what we know or think we understand about the outer heliosphere needs to be revised. This paper summarizes the next quantum leap enabled by IMAP that will open new windows on the frontier of Heliophysics at a time when the space environment is rapidly evolving. IMAP with 100 times the combined resolution and sensitivity of IBEX and INCA will discover the substructure of the IBEX ribbon and will reveal, with unprecedented resolution, global maps of our heliosphere. The remarkable synergy between IMAP, Voyager 1 and Voyager 2 will remain for at least the next decade as Voyager 1 pushes further into the interstellar domain and Voyager 2 moves through the heliosheath. Voyager 2 moves outward in the same region of sky covered by a portion of the IBEX ribbon. Voyager 2’s plasma measurements will create singular opportunities for discovery in the context of IMAP's global measurements. IMAP, like ACE before, will be a keystone of the Heliophysics System Observatory by providing comprehensive measurements of interstellar neutral atoms and pickup ions, the solar wind distribution, composition, and magnetic field, as well as suprathermal ion, energetic particle, and cosmic ray distributions to diagnose the changing space environment and understand the fundamental origins of particle acceleration. This paper, the first citable reference for IMAP, is similar to an unpublished whitepaper that was presented to the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine Committee for Solar and Space Physics. We provide the IMAP objectives and instrument straw man traced from the Solar and Space Physics Decadal Survey. It is fitting that our paper is published in the volume of papers that celebrates the 80th birthday of Ed Stone.

Following the interstellar magnetic field from the heliosphere into space with polarized starlight

Starlight linearly polarized by aligned interstellar dust grains provides the necessary data for tracing the structure of the very local interstellar magnetic field (ISMF). Two methods have been developed to recover the ISMF direction from polarized starlight, using data from an ongoing polarization survey. Both methods rely on the probability distribution function for polarized light. Method 1 calculates the ISMF direction from polarization position angles regardless of the data accuracy, while Method 2 relies on high-probability data points. The ISMF direction Bibex recovered by Method 1 corresponds to the closest ISMF to the heliosphere, traced by the center of the IBEX Ribbon arc. Method 2 reveals a new direction for the more distant ISMF, Bnew, toward l=41.1° ± 4.1° and b= 25.8° ± 3.0°, which differs by 30.4° ± 5.6° from the IBEX ISMF direction. Polarizations of filament stars that are located within 25° of a pole of Bnew, where background polarizations would be minimal, show the highest statistical probabilities of tracing the filament ISMF. The IBEX ISMF direction orders the kinematics of interstellar clouds within 15 pc, and Bnew must therefore dominate beyond 15 pc. These new data are consistent with the location of the Sun in the rim of an expanding superbubble shell associated with the evolved Loop I superbubble.

OBSERVATIONS OF THE INTERSTELLAR MAGNETIC FIELD IN THE OUTER HELIOSHEATH: VOYAGER 1

ABSTRACT New observations of the magnetic field from ≈2014.7 through 2016.3288, together with the previous observations dating back to 2012 August 25, show that Voyager 1 continued to observe draped interstellar magnetic fields in the outer heliosheath. During this time, the direction of was nearly constant (±3°), with no significant long-term trend. The slope of a linear least squares fit to the variation of the magnetic field strength B with time is (0.001 ± 0.001) nT yr−1, consistent with no net change, and the average B = (0.48 ± 0.04) nT. The new observations show a second “disturbed interval” in which B was for ≈267 days. This interval began with a weak shock on 2014/236 (2014.6438), contained oscillations in B with a 28 day period, and possibly ended with a pressure balanced structure or a reverse shock. It is likely this disturbed interval was associated with Sun/solar wind disturbances that impacted the heliopause and produced disturbances that propagated into the outer heliosheath. A quiet interval containing weaker less variable was observed from ≈2015.3700 until at least 2016.0. Unlike the previous quiet interval observed in the outer heliosheath, the direction of did not change linearly and could not be extrapolated to the center of the IBEX ribbon.

CHARTING THE INTERSTELLAR MAGNETIC FIELD CAUSING THEINTERSTELLAR BOUNDARY EXPLORER(IBEX) RIBBON OF ENERGETIC NEUTRAL ATOMS

The interstellar magnetic field (ISMF) near the heliosphere is a basic part of the solar neighborhood that can only be studied using polarized starlight. Results of an ongoing survey of polarized starlight are analyzed with the goal of linking the interstellar magnetic field that shapes the heliosphere to the nearby field in interstellar space. New results for the direction of the nearby ISMF, based on a merit function that utilizes polarization position angles, identify several magnetic components. The dominant interstellar field, B_pol, is aligned with the direction L,B= 36.2,49.0 (+/-16.0) degrees and is within 8 degrees of the IBEX Ribbon ISMF direction. Stars tracing B_pol have the same mean distance as stars that do not trace B_pol, but show weaker polarizations consistent with lower column densities of polarizing grains. The variations in the polarization position angle directions indicate a low level of magnetic turbulence. B_pol is found after excluding polarizations that trace a separate magnetic structure that apparently is due to interstellar dust deflected around the heliosphere. Local interstellar cloud velocities relative to the LSR increase with the angles between the LSR velocities and ISMF, indicating that the kinematics of local interstellar material is ordered by the ISMF. Polarization and color excess data are consistent with an extension of Loop I to the solar vicinity. Polarizations are consistent with previous findings of more efficient grain alignment in low column density sightlines. Optical polarization and color excess data indicate the presence of nearby interstellar dust in the BICEP2 field. Color excess E(B-V) indicates an optical extinction of A_V about 0.59 mag in the BICEP2 field, while the polarization data indicate that A_V is larger than 0.09 mag. The IBEX Ribbon ISMF extends to the boundaries of the BICEP2 region.

On the angular distribution of IceCube high‐energy events

AbstractThe detection of high‐energy astro‐physical neutrinos of extraterrestrial origin by the IceCube neutrino observatory in Antarctica has opened a unique window to the cosmos that may help to probe both the distant Universe and our cosmic backyard. The arrival directions of these high‐energy events have been interpreted as uniformly distributed on the celestial sphere. Here, we revisit the topic of the putative isotropic angular distribution of these events applying Monte Carlo techniques to investigate a possible anisotropy. A modest evidence for anisotropy is found. An excess of events appears projected towards a section of the Local Void, where the density of galaxies with radial velocities below 3000 km s–1 is rather low, suggesting that this particular group of somewhat clustered sources are located either very close to the Milky Way or perhaps beyond 40 Mpc. The results of further analyses of the subsample of southern hemisphere events favour an origin at cosmological distances with the arrival directions of the events organized in a fractal‐like structure. Although a small fraction of closer sources is possible, remote hierarchical structures appear to be the main source of these very energetic neutrinos. Some of the events may have their origin at the IBEX ribbon. (© 2015 WILEY‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim)

Plasma Physics of the Very Local Interstellar Medium

Models of the large-scale heliosphere show that the very local interstellar medium (VLISM), bounded by the heliopause and either a bow wave or bow shock, experiences significant heating by the deposition of neutral hydrogen (H) originating from the hot inner heliosheath. As hot neutrals stream into the interstellar medium, they experience charge exchange with the background cooler interstellar protons, creating a population of energetic (~ 1 keV) pickup ions. Similarly, fast neutrals created in the supersonic solar wind stream into the local interstellar medium and create a pickup ion population in the VLISM. The importance of these pickup ions is thought to manifest itself in the creation of the IBEX ribbon. Like the outer regions of the supersonic solar wind and the inner heliosheath, the VLISM is a pickup ion mediated plasma. Here we derive a model of a pickup ion mediated plasma using an approach analogous to a Chapman-Enskog expansion. We derive the anomalous heat flux and obtain a three-fluid model comprising electrons, thermal protons, and pickup ions. We investigate waves in a pickup ion mediated VLISM plasma, comparing the basic properties to those of the better known two-fluid model.

Spatial Retention of the IBEX Ribbon Source Particles - Further Work on the Dominant Turbulence Model

We present an overview of the "dominant turbulence" picture of pickup proton isotropization and its recent application to the spatial retention of these particles in the nearby interstellar medium as an explanation for the IBEX ribbon structure. We report the progress of further modeling in this area, expanding the published model to 3D and adding a contribution of energetic neutral atoms from the inner heliosheath to the ribbon volume. We find that the ribbon flux expected at IBEX from this model is still below the observed value, but the discrepancy is much smaller than that of our previous result.

MAGNETIC FIELD FLUCTUATIONS OBSERVED IN THE HELIOSHEATH AND INTERSTELLAR MAGNETIC FIELD BYVOYAGER 1AT 115.7-124.9 AU DURING 2011-2013

We discuss microscale fluctuations of the hour averages of the magnetic field B observed on a scale of one day by Voyager 1 (V1) from 2011.0 to 2012.3143 (when it was within the distant heliosheath, where the average magnetic field strength (B) = 0.17 nT) and during the interval from 2012.6503 to 2013.5855 (when it was within the interstellar plasma with (B) = 0.47 nT). In both regions, the fluctuations were primarily compressive fluctuations, varying along the average B (≈T direction in RTN coordinates). In the heliosheath, the average of the daily standard deviations (SDs) of the compressive and transverse components of B were (SD{sub c}) = 0.010 nT and (SD{sub t}) ≤ 0.005 nT (which is the limit of the measurement). In the distant heliosheath (SD{sub c})/(B) = 0.06, and the distributions of SD were skewed and highly kurtotic. The interstellar magnetic field (ISMF) strength was B = 0.48 nT, but the fluctuations were below the limit of measurement: (SD{sub c}) = 0.004 nT and (abs(SD{sub t})) = 0.004 nT. The distributions of these interstellar SDs have skewness and kurtosis consistent with a Gaussian noise distribution. We also discuss the fluctuations of 48 s averages of B on amore » scale of 1 day during a 30 day interval when V1 was observing the ISMF. For the fluctuations in all three components of B, SD = 0.010 nT, which gives an upper limit on the fluctuations of the ISMF on the scales observed by V1. This SD rules out the possibility that there is significant power in electromagnetic fluctuations generated by pickup ion ring instabilities at these scales, which strongly constrains models of the IBEX ribbon.« less

ASSESSMENT OF ENERGETIC NEUTRAL He ATOM INTENSITIES EXPECTED FROM THE IBEX RIBBON

Full sky maps of energetic neutral atoms (ENA) obtained with the Interstellar Boundary Explorer revealed a bright, arc-like Ribbon. We compare possible, though as yet undetected, He ENA emission in two models of the Ribbon origin. The models were originally developed for hydrogen ENA. In the first one, ENA are produced outside the heliopause from the ionized neutral solar wind in the direction where the local interstellar magnetic field is perpendicular to the line-of-sight. The second model proposes production at the contact layer between the Local Interstellar Cloud (LIC) and the Local Bubble (LB). The models are redesigned to helium using relevant interactions between atoms and ions. Resulting intensities are compared with possible emission of helium ENA from the heliosheath. In the first model, the expected intensity is ~ 0.014 (cm^2 s sr keV)^-1, i.e., of the order of the He emission from the heliosheath, whereas in the second, the LIC/LB contact layer model, the intensity is ~ (2-7) (cm^2 s sr keV)^-1, i.e., a few hundred times larger. If the IBEX Ribbon needs a source population of He ENA leaving the heliosphere, it should not be visible in He ENA fluxes mainly because of the insufficient supply of the parent He ENA originating from the neutralized solar wind {\alpha}-particles. We conclude that full-sky measurements of He ENA could give promising prospect for probing the Local Interstellar Medium at the distance of a few thousand AU and create possibility of distinction between above mentioned models of Ribbon origin.

The IBEX ribbon as a signature of the inhomogeneity of the local interstellar medium

Context. An ew hypothesis is offered to explain the so-called ribbon feature appearing in the all-sky flux maps of energetic neutral atoms presently observed withthe IBEXspacecraft, namely that theribbon isa consequenc eo finhomogeneities inthelocal interstellar medium. Aims. The study aims at a detailed presentation of this hypothesis and its implications for the interpretation of ENA measurements with IBEX. Methods. Theoretical considerations regarding three different topics, namely IBEX measurements related to high-energy neutral atoms, Lyman-α observations (made with the Voyager 1 spacecraft) related to low-energy neutral atoms, and astronomical data related to the structure of the interstellar medium, are critically discussed in order to corroborate the hypothesis. Results. It is found that inhomogeneities in the local interstellar medium can explain not onl yt he IBEX ribbon andouter heliospheric Lyman-α observations, but can also account for the interstellar Lyman-α absorption that could only with difficulty be fully attributed to the hydrogen wall in the outer heliosheath if the heliospheric bow shock would indeed be absent. Conclusions. The IBEX observations of the ribbon provide a unique opportunity to learn more about the nature of the interstellar medium surrounding the heliosphere.

THE EFFECTS OF LOCAL INTERSTELLAR MAGNETIC FIELD ON ENERGETIC NEUTRAL ATOM SKY MAPS

We study the effects of the strength and direction of the local interstellar magnetic field (ISMF) on the heliosphere geometry that generates the locus of points associated with the position of the IBEX ribbon of energetic neutral atoms. MHD heliosphere models are run for a variety of ISMF parameters to specifically study the correlation between locations of maxima of the ISMF magnitude along the field lines and places where the local ISMF B is perpendicular to radial vectors r from the Sun, i.e., B ? r = 0. The study confirms the existence of a strong physical relationship between the ribbon and the ISMF.