Strong claims have been made about the ability of Interactive Multimedia (IMM) programs to positively affect student learning outcomes. This study sought to evaluate the design of a specific IMM program,Working Mathematically: Space, and to see if use of the program would promote student learning in spatial mathematics when compared to non-computer based instruction. An evaluative framework was established to facilitate examination of program design and focussed attention on the technical and cognitive interaction between student and program. Subsequent investigation focused on the impact of the software use on Year 7 students’ problem-solving processes, their spatial mathematics performance, and student-to-student interaction in teacher supported and unsupported learning environments. Use of the IMM program was not associated with any gain in problem-solving performance when compared with the use of small blocks to solve a tower-building task. The IMM program did, however, result in increased frequency of low-level interaction between student pairs, which appeared to be associated with the technical design of the software. Several aspects of the design seemed to negatively impact on the processing events undertaken by students. Although the results of this study are limited to the detailed examination of one task using one IMM program, the outcomes of the evaluation point to areas that should be of concern to program developers and teachers.