Understanding the biotransformation mechanisms of toxic sulfur-containing polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PASH) pollutants such as benzothiophene (BT) is useful for predicting their environmental fates. In the natural environment, nondesulfurizing hydrocarbon-degrading bacteria are major active contributors to PASH biodegradation at petroleum-contaminated sites; however, BT biotransformation pathways by this group of bacteria are less explored when compared to desulfurizing organisms. When a model nondesulfurizing polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon-degrading soil bacterium, Sphingobium barthaii KK22, was investigated for its ability to cometabolically biotransform BT by quantitative and qualitative methods, BT was depleted from culture media but was biotransformed into mostly high molar mass (HMM) hetero and homodimeric ortho-substituted diaryl disulfides (diaryl disulfanes). HMM diaryl disulfides have not been reported as biotransformation products of BT. Chemical structures were proposed for the diaryl disulfides by comprehensive mass spectrometry analyses of the chromatographically separated products and were supported by the identification of transient upstream BT biotransformation products, which included benzenethiols. Thiophenic acid products were also identified, and pathways that described BT biotransformation and novel HMM diaryl disulfide formation were constructed. This work shows that nondesulfurizing hydrocarbon-degrading organisms produce HMM diaryl disulfides from low molar mass polyaromatic sulfur heterocycles, and this may be taken into consideration when predicting the environmental fates of BT pollutants.