Hybrid systems of hydroxyapatite supported on carbonaceous materials of different nature (activated charcoals, acetylene black, carbon black, graphite flake, synthesized microporous and mesoporous carbons) are investigated as catalysts for vapor-phase Guerbet condensation of butan-1-ol. The structure, morphology, and acid–base characteristics of hydroxyapatite, carbon supports, and the hybrid systems have been characterized by XRD, SEM-EDX, low-temperature (77 K) nitrogen ad(de)sorption, NMR, XPS, EPR, Raman spectroscopy, and TPD-NH3/CO2 techniques. The butan-1-ol conversion and selectivity towards the reaction products are found to be highly dependent on carbonaceous supports of the hybrid catalysts. The important role of acid–base capacity ratio is highlighted to achieve high selectivity in vapor-phase Guerbet condensation of butan-1-ol to 2-ethylhexan-1-ol. In particular, the surface’s strong basic sites are preferable for elongating the carbon chain. The high selectivity towards 2-ethylhexan-1-ol of about 75% is achieved over HAP/graphite flake and up to 57% over HAP/activated coconut charcoal. Compared to the bulk hydroxyapatite, the enhanced performance of the hybrid catalysts (initial activity and target product yield) is associated with the redistribution of active sites over carbon supports by strength and location.