Flexible temperature sensors are becoming increasingly important these days. In this work, we explore graphene oxide (GO)/poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) nanocomposites for potential application in temperature sensors. The influence of the mixing ratio of both materials, the reduction temperature, and passivation on the sensing performance has been investigated. Various spectroscopic techniques revealed the composite structure and atomic composition. These were complemented by semiempirical quantum chemical calculations to investigate rGO and PVA interaction. Scanning electron and atomic force microscopy measurements were carried out to evaluate dispersion and coated film quality. The temperature sensitivity has been evaluated for several composite materials with different compositions in the range from 10 to 80 °C. The results show that a linear temperature behavior can be realized based on rGO/PVA composites with temperature coefficients of resistance (TCR) larger than 1.8% K-1 and a fast response time of 0.3 s with minimal hysteresis. Furthermore, humidity influence has been investigated in the range from 10% to 80%, and a minor effect is shown. Therefore, we can conclude that rGO/PVA composites have a high potential for excellent passivation-free, humidity-independent, sensitive, and fast response temperature sensors for various applications. The GO reduction is tunable, and PVA improves the rGO/PVA sensor performance by increasing the tunneling effect and band gap energy, consequently improving temperature sensitivity. Additionally, PVA exhibits minimal water absorption, reducing the humidity sensitivity. rGO/PVA maintains its temperature sensitivity during and after several mechanical deformations.