T-cell immunoglobulin and mucin (TIM) family proteins facilitate the clearance of apoptotic cells, are involved in immune regulation, and promote infection of enveloped viruses. These processes are frequently studied in experimental animals, such as mice or rhesus macaques, but functional differences among the TIM orthologs from these species have not been described. Previously, we reported that while all three human TIM proteins bind phosphatidylserine (PS), only human TIM1 (hTIM1) binds phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), and that this PE-binding ability contributes to both phagocytic clearance of apoptotic cells and viral infection. Here, we show that rhesus macaque TIM1 (rhTIM1) and mouse TIM1 (mTIM1) bind PS but not PE, and that their inability to bind PE makes them less efficient than hTIM1. We also show that alteration of only two residues of mTIM1 or rhTIM1 enables them to bind both PE and PS, and that these PE-binding variants are more efficient at phagocytosis and mediating viral entry. Further, we demonstrate that the mucin domain also contributes to the binding of the virions and apoptotic cells, although it does not directly bind phospholipid. Interestingly, contribution of the hTIM1 mucin domain is more pronounced in the presence of a PE-binding head domain. These results demonstrate that rhTIM1 and mTIM1 are inherently less functional than hTIM1, owing to their inability to bind PE and their less functional mucin domains. They also imply that mouse and macaque models underestimate the activity of hTIM1.IMPORTANCEWe previously reported that human T-cell immunoglobulin and mucin protein 1 (TIM1) binds phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) as well as phosphatidylserine (PS), and that PE is exposed on the apoptotic cells and viral envelopes. Moreover, TIM1 recognition of PE contributes to phagocytic clearance of apoptotic cells and virus uptake. Here, we report that unlike human TIM1, murine and rhesus TIM1 orthologs bind only PS, and as a result, their ability to clear apoptotic cells or promote virus infection is less efficient. These findings are significant because they imply that the activity of TIM1 in humans is greater than what the studies conducted in common animal models would indicate.